\documentclass[11pt]{article}
\usepackage[T1]{fontenc}
\usepackage{lmodern,amsmath,amssymb,amsthm,mathtools}
\usepackage[margin=27mm]{geometry}
\usepackage{longtable,array,float}
\usepackage[colorlinks=true,linkcolor=blue,citecolor=blue,urlcolor=blue]{hyperref}
\newcommand{\R}{\mathbb R}
\newcommand{\C}{\mathbb C}
\newcommand{\N}{\mathbb N}
\newcommand{\norm}[1]{\left\|#1\right\|}
\newcommand{\dd}{\,\mathrm d}
\newcommand{\supp}{\operatorname{supp}}
\newcommand{\eps}{\varepsilon}
\newcommand{\Prad}{P_{\mathrm{rad}}}
\newtheorem{theorem}{Theorem}[section]
\newtheorem{proposition}[theorem]{Proposition}
\newtheorem{lemma}[theorem]{Lemma}
\newtheorem{corollary}[theorem]{Corollary}
\theoremstyle{remark}
\newtheorem{remark}[theorem]{Remark}
\usepackage{tikz}
\usetikzlibrary{arrows.meta,positioning,calc}
\newcommand{\betaG}{\beta_{\mathrm G}}
\newtheorem{definition}[theorem]{Definition}
\title{Non-unique vanishing-viscosity solutions of 2D Euler with vorticity in $L^p$}
\author{}
\date{9 October 2026}
\hypersetup{pdftitle={Non-unique vanishing-viscosity solutions of 2D Euler with vorticity in $L^p$},pdfsubject={Revised mathematical manuscript},pdfkeywords={Euler, Navier--Stokes, vanishing viscosity, selection}}
\begin{document}
\maketitle
\begin{abstract}
For every finite $p>2$, we construct one real compactly supported
zero-circulation initial vorticity in $L^1(\mathbb R^2)\cap L^p(\mathbb R^2)$
whose unforced Navier--Stokes evolutions have two distinct strong
vanishing-viscosity accumulation paths. Both limits are renormalized
unforced Euler solutions with the same strong initial trace.
The construction uses a fixed infinite concentric stack, a smooth unstable
fourfold profile, actual positive scalar envelopes, and a finite nonlinear
expansion retaining the interacting harmonic histories. Discounted source
history is controlled through the complete prospective receiver stop,
and exact-cap normalization yields a depth-uniform outgoing reset.
Protected first crossings, phase degree and a sparse phase assignment
then separate the two limits. The analytical preliminaries, finite-sector
spectral scope, source-reference comparison and uniform parameter order
are included in the proof.
\end{abstract}
\tableofcontents
\section{Introduction}\label{sec:introduction}
The vanishing-viscosity approximation of an incompressible flow combines
an existence procedure with a selection question. For each positive
viscosity the two-dimensional Navier--Stokes equation has a unique global
vorticity evolution from an integrable initial density. As viscosity tends
to zero, compactness can produce Euler solutions, and renormalization can
upgrade weak convergence to strong convergence. These facts do not by
themselves determine whether all viscosities select the same Euler path.
The distinction is relevant when the initial vorticity lies in
$L^1(\mathbb R^2)\cap L^p(\mathbb R^2)$ for a finite $p>2$.
We study the unforced planar equation
\[
\partial_t\omega^\nu+(K*\omega^\nu)\cdot\nabla\omega^\nu
=\nu\Delta\omega^\nu,
\qquad K(x)=\frac{x^\perp}{2\pi|x|^2}.
\]
The initial condition in our construction is fixed once and for all; only
$\nu$ varies. Zero circulation is imposed to place its Biot--Savart
velocity in the finite-energy class. The strong topology used throughout
is the sum norm on $X_p=L^1\cap L^p$, and the Euler solutions have their
strong initial trace in this space. The definitions of distributional and
renormalized solutions are collected in Section~\ref{sec:preliminaries}.
\subsection{Main result}
\begin{theorem}[Non-unique selection from one fixed datum]
\label{thm:next-fixed-data-nonunique}\label{thm:main}
For every $2
0$, two sequences
$\nu_n^+\downarrow0$ and $\nu_n^-\downarrow0$, and two distinct
renormalized solutions $\omega^+,\omega^-$ of the unforced Euler equation
such that
\[
\omega^\pm\in C([0,T_f];X_p),\qquad \omega^\pm(0)=\omega_0,
\qquad
\lim_{n\to\infty}\|\omega^{\nu_n^\pm}-\omega^\pm\|_{C([0,T_f];X_p)}=0.
\]
Here $\omega^\nu$ is the unique unforced Navier--Stokes solution with
viscosity $\nu$ and the same initial condition $\omega_0$ for every
$\nu>0$. Distinctness means that the two paths differ on $[0,T_f]$.
Consequently this fixed-datum family does not converge as $\nu\downarrow0$.
\end{theorem}
The theorem asserts non-unique accumulation points in a strong vorticity
topology. It does not assert that every Euler solution from this datum can
be selected by viscosity, or prescribe the total set of accumulation
points. The velocity convergence along each of the displayed subsequences
is also strong in $C([0,T_f];L^\infty)$, by Lemma~\ref{pre:kernel}.
\subsection{Background and analytical setting}
The global integrable-vorticity Navier--Stokes theory used below is stated
precisely in Proposition~\ref{pre:NS}; its existence input is
Gallay--Wayne~\cite[Theorem~2.2]{GW01}. Smooth Euler evolution and the
Biot--Savart formulation are part of the classical planar theory; see
Majda--Bertozzi~\cite{MB02}. We give the kernel estimates and the comparison
arguments needed by the construction, including the low-frequency
cancellation supplied by zero circulation.
The treatment of transported densities follows the renormalization
framework of DiPerna--Lions~\cite{DL89}. In the present range $p>2$, the
commutator estimates for the limiting total vorticity and for bounded
passive colours are proved directly, together with their endpoint traces.
For comparison, Ciampa--Crippa--Spirito~\cite[Theorem~3.2]{CCS21} prove
strong convergence to an identified renormalized inviscid limit under
their stated approximation hypotheses. That theorem concerns convergence
to a limit already identified along the relevant family, and does not
assert uniqueness of selection. The fixed rough datum used here is
handled by the self-contained compactness proof in
Theorem~\ref{cp:compact}, rather than by an unstated application of that
approximation theorem.
The auxiliary tools in Section~\ref{sec:preliminaries} are distinguished
from the cascade estimates in the later sections. In particular,
compactness and uniqueness of a passive colour for a prescribed Euler
velocity are established analytical inputs. They do not imply uniqueness
of the nonlinear Euler path.
\paragraph{Relation to earlier nonuniqueness constructions.}
The two-interface unstable vortex underlying our profile is already
present in the work of Castro, Faraco, Mengual and Solera~\cite{CFMS24}; the exact
sign/rescaling is recorded in Section~\ref{smooth-active-section}.
Their work establishes forced Euler nonuniqueness and constructs a smooth
compact unstable vortex. The modal calculations needed here are rederived
for the chosen vorticity mollification. The spectral prototype is therefore
an established ingredient; the additional claim of this paper concerns
the interacting unforced Navier--Stokes cascade and one fixed initial datum.
Mengual~\cite{Mengual23} constructs nonunique bounded admissible velocity
solutions from initial vorticity in $L^1\cap L^p$, $2
1$.
Albritton--Colombo--Mescolini~\cite{ACM25} construct nonunique
vanishing-viscosity limits for forced Euler with viscosity-dependent
perturbations of the initial data. The unforced equation, the same datum
for every viscosity, and the strong finite-$p>2$ topology in
Theorem~\ref{thm:main} are separate assertions that require the actual
cascade estimates below; none follows from those earlier results.
\subsection{Construction and proof strategy}
The datum is an infinite concentric stack of copies of one smooth radial
profile $W$ with zero circulation, perturbed by neutral fourfold seeds:
\begin{equation}\label{eq:intro-stack}
\omega_0(x)=\sum_{j\ge1}A_j
\bigl[W(x/R_j)+\alpha\Phi_{\vartheta_j}(x/R_j)\bigr],
\qquad A_j=\beta^{j-1},\quad R_j=q^{j-1}.
\end{equation}
The fixed parameters obey $\beta>1$, $0=Latex,font=\small]
\begin{scope}[x=3.3cm,y=2cm]
\fill[blue!8] (.73,-.43) rectangle (.82,.64);
\fill[blue!8] (.96,-.43) rectangle (1.04,.64);
\draw[->] (-.06,0)--(1.25,0) node[right] {$r$};
\draw[->] (0,-.54)--(0,.82) node[above] {$W(r)$};
\draw[densely dotted] (0,.6)--(1,.6);
\draw[densely dotted] (0,-.4)--(.775,-.4);
\node[left] at (0,.6) {$3/5$};
\node[left] at (0,-.4) {$-2/5$};
\draw[black,thick] (0,-.4)--(.775,-.4)--(.775,.6)--(1,.6)--(1,0)--(1.16,0);
\draw[blue!75!black,very thick]
(0,-.4)--(.72,-.4) .. controls (.76,-.4) and (.77,.6) .. (.83,.6)
--(.94,.6) .. controls (.98,.6) and (1,0) .. (1.06,0)--(1.16,0);
\node[below] at (.775,-.47) {$\rho$};
\node[below] at (1,-.04) {$1$};
\node[anchor=west] at (.07,.83) {radial values};
\draw[black,thick] (.09,-.79)--(.21,-.79);
\node[anchor=west] at (.24,-.79) {$W_0$ (exact step)};
\draw[blue!75!black,very thick] (.09,-1.02)--(.21,-1.02);
\node[anchor=west] at (.24,-1.02) {$W$ (smoothing schematic)};
\end{scope}
\begin{scope}[shift={(8.5cm,0cm)}]
\fill[orange!15] (0,0) circle (1.65cm);
\fill[blue!16] (0,0) circle (1.28cm);
\draw[black] (0,0) circle (1.65cm);
\draw[black] (0,0) circle (1.28cm);
\draw[blue!75!black,line width=3pt,opacity=.45] (0,0) circle (1.28cm);
\draw[blue!75!black,line width=3pt,opacity=.45] (0,0) circle (1.65cm);
\fill (0,0) circle (1pt);
\node at (0,.2) {$W_0=-2/5$};
\node at (0,-.27) {$r<\rho$};
\node[anchor=west,align=left] at (1.92,.57) {$W_0=3/5$\\$\rho] (1.94,.45)--(1.43,.2);
\node[align=center] at (0,2.08) {negative disk and positive annulus};
\node[align=center,text width=5.6cm] at (0,-2.48)
{$W'$ and $\Phi_\vartheta$ lie in the shaded collars;\\
$\displaystyle\int_{\mathbb R^2}W=0$.};
\end{scope}
\end{tikzpicture}
\caption{The fixed zero-circulation profile. The black radial graph is
the exact unsmoothed $W_0$; the blue transition is schematic because
the mollifier determines its precise shape. The disk picture displays
the two constant regions before smoothing. The collars have widths
of order $\epsilon$ and carry the derivative and the neutral seeds.}
\label{fig:reader-profile}
\end{figure}
Let $f_\epsilon$ be the growing radial eigenfunction normalized in
Section~\ref{smooth-active-section}. The precise neutral seed is
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-neutral-seed}
\begin{split}
b_\epsilon&:=2\pi\int_0^\infty r^5f_\epsilon(r)\,\mathrm dr,\\
\Phi_\vartheta(r,\varphi)&:=
2\operatorname{Re}\!\left[
e^{i\vartheta}\left(f_\epsilon(r)
-\frac{b_\epsilon}{\overline{b_\epsilon}}
\overline{f_\epsilon(r)}\right)e^{4i\varphi}
\right].
\end{split}
\end{equation}
Here $b_\epsilon\ne0$. The growing and stable contributions cancel in
the initial fourth moment, while the growing coefficient remains
$e^{i\vartheta}$. Thus neutrality is an exact moment condition, rather
than absence of an unstable component.
The associated growing eigenvalue and its real and imaginary parts are
\[
\lambda:=\lambda_\epsilon,\qquad
\sigma:=\operatorname{Re}\lambda>0,\qquad
\tau:=\operatorname{Im}\lambda,\qquad \lambda=\sigma+i\tau.
\]
With $\beta>1$ fixed before $q$, the scale parameters are
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-scales}
A_j:=\beta^{j-1},\quad R_j:=q^{j-1},\quad
L:=\log(1/q),\quad \alpha:=q^K,\quad \delta:=L^{-4},
\qquad 6N}^\nu:=\sum_{j>N}\omega_j^\nu,
\qquad P_{>N}^\nu:=\sum_{j>N}P_j^\nu.
\end{equation}
Scale $N$ is the selected source. Its transmitted signal passes successively
to $N-1,N-2,\ldots,1$, moving towards larger radii. The packet
$\omega_{>N}^\nu$ is controlled by diffusion and signed-moment estimates;
$P_{>N}^\nu$ is used for absolute bounds. Figure~\ref{fig:reader-scales}
shows these roles.
\begin{figure}[H]
\centering
\begin{tikzpicture}[x=1cm,y=1cm,>=Stealth,
every node/.style={font=\small},
info/.style={align=left,text width=6.15cm}]
\draw[black!55,thick] (3.25,3.05) circle (2.80);
\draw[black!55,thick] (3.25,3.05) circle (2.17);
\draw[blue!75!black,very thick] (3.25,3.05) circle (1.85);
\draw[blue!75!black,very thick] (3.25,3.05) circle (1.43);
\draw[orange!85!black,very thick] (3.25,3.05) circle (1.05);
\draw[orange!85!black,very thick] (3.25,3.05) circle (.81);
\draw[black!55,dashed,thick] (3.25,3.05) circle (.60);
\node[align=center,font=\scriptsize] at (3.25,3.05)
{cold\\packet\\$j>N$};
\node[fill=white,inner sep=2pt,text=orange!85!black,
font=\footnotesize] at (3.25,2.00) {selected colour $N$};
\node[fill=white,inner sep=2pt,text=blue!75!black,
font=\footnotesize] at (3.25,1.20) {receiver $N-1$};
\node[fill=white,inner sep=2pt,font=\footnotesize] at (3.25,.22)
{older colours $j,orange!85!black,very thick] (2.08,3.05)--(1.52,3.05);
\draw[->,blue!75!black,very thick] (1.25,3.05)--(.57,3.05);
\node[align=center,font=\footnotesize,fill=white,inner sep=2pt] at (1.15,3.65)
{transmission\\to larger scales};
\node[info,anchor=north west] at (6.50,5.80) {
\textbf{One fixed datum.}\\[3pt]
$A_j:=\beta^{j-1}$,\quad $R_j:=q^{j-1}$,\quad $\alpha:=q^K$.\\[5pt]
$\displaystyle\omega_0:=\sum_{j\ge1} A_j
\bigl[W(\cdot/R_j)+\alpha\Phi_{\vartheta_j}(\cdot/R_j)\bigr]$.\\[8pt]
\textbf{Viscosity chooses a depth.}\\[3pt]
$\nu_N:=q^{3/2}A_NR_N^2$.\\[5pt]
$\displaystyle\kappa_j(\nu_N)
:=\frac{\nu_N}{A_jR_j^2}
=q^{3/2}(\beta q^2)^{N-j}$.\\[8pt]
\textbf{Activation descends in index.}\\[3pt]
$N\longrightarrow N-1\longrightarrow\cdots\longrightarrow1$.\\[5pt]
In physical space the corresponding radii increase:
$R_NN$ form the
deep diffusing packet; they are controlled collectively rather than
discarded. The seed phases in $\omega_0$ are fixed before the final
vanishing-viscosity subsequences are extracted.}
\label{fig:reader-scales}
\end{figure}
\paragraph{Physical time, local time, and rotation.}
Each colour has its own normalized clock. Define
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-clocks}
\begin{split}
s_j&:=A_jt_{\rm phys},\qquad y_j:=x/R_j,\\
w_j(s_j,y)&:=A_j^{-1}\omega_j^\nu(s_j/A_j,R_jy),\\
U_j(s_j,y)&:=(A_jR_j)^{-1}u^\nu(s_j/A_j,R_jy),\qquad
\kappa_j(\nu):=\frac{\nu}{A_jR_j^2}.
\end{split}
\end{equation}
Thus $\partial_{s_j}w_j+\operatorname{div}(U_jw_j)
=\kappa_j\Delta w_j$. For a receiver $i$ and its child $c=i+1$,
$s_c=\beta s_i$ at the same physical time. The viscosity selecting $N$ is
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-viscosity}
\nu_N:=q^{3/2}A_NR_N^2,
\qquad \kappa_j(\nu_N)=q^{3/2}(\beta q^2)^{N-j}.
\end{equation}
For $j\le N$ the normalized viscosity is at most $q^{3/2}$. For $j>N$
it increases geometrically with depth. This separates the chosen source
from the younger diffusing packet.
To specify the older-core rotating frame, let $\mathsf R_\eta$ be
counterclockwise rotation through $\eta$. The scalar and vector pattern
actions are, respectively,
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-pattern-action}
(\mathcal T_\theta f)(x):=f(\mathsf R_{\theta/4}x),\qquad
(\mathcal T_\theta V)(x):=
\mathsf R_{-\theta/4}V(\mathsf R_{\theta/4}x).
\end{equation}
They act on the whole function or field, rather than on one formal
coefficient. The phase $\theta$ rotates a physical pattern through
$-\theta/4$. Put
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-rotating-frame}
\Omega_{0$.
Here $\delta_{\rm ref}$ is fixed, whereas $\delta=L^{-4}$ is the
construction's shrinking cap. Define its negative-time cap by
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-canonical-cap}
s_q:=\inf\{u\le0:|\mathcal A(\Omega_{\rm ref}(u))|\ge\delta\}.
\end{equation}
The small ancient branch is the interval on which the protected growing
coordinate has positive radial derivative. For sufficiently small $q$
this definition gives $s_q<0$. If the actual child has exact cap time
$\tau_c$, its matching phase and reference clock are
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-reference-clock}
\begin{split}
e^{i\phi}&:=
\frac{\mathcal A(w_c(\tau_c))}
{\mathcal A(\Omega_{\rm ref}(s_q))},\\
t_{\rm ref}&:=\tau_c-s_q,\qquad
u:=s_c-t_{\rm ref},\qquad t_0:=t_{\rm ref}/\beta.
\end{split}
\end{equation}
Both numerator and denominator in the phase ratio have modulus $\delta$.
Thus $u=s_q$ at the actual small cap and $u=0$ at its deterministic
reference time. The latter is the time corresponding to the reference
comparison, rather than an assumed exact crossing of
$\delta_{\rm ref}$ by the actual colour. A protected crossing version
differs by the small time shift specified in the receiving proof.
\paragraph{The three source-history intervals.}
For a controlled child horizon $U_q\ge0$, the phase-aligned history is
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-history}
\mathcal B_q(u):=
\begin{cases}
B_4(\mathcal T_{-\phi}w_c(t_{\rm ref}+u)),
&-t_{\rm ref}\le u\le U_q,\\
0,&\text{otherwise},
\end{cases}
\qquad
\mu_\beta:=\frac{\sigma+i(\tau-4/5)}\beta.
\end{equation}
This is the history denoted $B_q$ in
Lemma~\ref{repair:prepared-child-history}. Its decomposition is
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-history-pieces}
I_{\rm past}:=[-t_{\rm ref},s_q],\qquad
I_{\rm advance}:=[s_q,0],\qquad
I_{\rm future}:=[0,U_q].
\end{equation}
The past uses the cap-relative envelope, the advance uses comparison
with the fixed ancient segment, and the future uses moments and the
parent-radius tail under the parent's density stop.
Figure~\ref{fig:reader-history} distinguishes these three estimates.
Zero extension defines the controlled history beyond its endpoints;
it makes no assertion about the actual solution there.
\begin{figure}[H]
\centering
\begin{tikzpicture}[x=1cm,y=1cm,>=Stealth,
every node/.style={font=\small},
piece/.style={draw,rounded corners=2pt,align=center,
text width=3.45cm,minimum height=1.82cm,inner sep=5pt}]
\node[piece,draw=blue!75!black] at (2.00,2.00)
{\textbf{Discounted past}\\[4pt]
$-t_{\rm ref}\le u\le s_q$\\[4pt]
Cap-relative exponential envelope};
\node[piece,draw=orange!85!black] at (6.45,2.00)
{\textbf{Reference advance}\\[4pt]
$s_q\le u\le0$\\[4pt]
Exact-cap reset and one-sided comparison};
\node[piece,draw=blue!75!black] at (10.90,2.00)
{\textbf{Controlled future}\\[4pt]
$0\le u\le U_q$\\[4pt]
Positive moments and parent-radius Gaussian tails};
\draw[->,thick] (-.05,.15)--(13.02,.15)
node[right] {$u$};
\foreach \xx/\lab in {.10/{-t_{\rm ref}},4.10/{s_q},8.80/{0},12.70/{U_q}}
{\draw (\xx,.02)--(\xx,.28);
\node[below] at (\xx,-.02) {$\lab$};}
\draw[blue!75!black,line width=2pt] (.10,.15)--(4.10,.15);
\draw[orange!85!black,line width=2pt] (4.10,.15)--(8.80,.15);
\draw[blue!75!black,line width=2pt] (8.80,.15)--(12.70,.15);
\draw[densely dashed,black!55] (4.10,.35)--(4.10,1.02);
\draw[densely dashed,black!55] (8.80,.35)--(8.80,1.02);
\node[below,align=center,font=\footnotesize] at (4.10,-.72)
{actual child cap\\$|\mathcal A(w_c(\tau_c))|=\delta$};
\node[below,align=center,font=\footnotesize] at (8.80,-.72)
{fixed canonical reference\\$\mathcal A(\Omega_{\rm ref}(0))=\delta_{\rm ref}$};
\node[align=center] at (6.45,-2.23)
{$u:=s_c-t_{\rm ref}$,\quad
$t_{\rm ref}:=\tau_c-s_q$,\quad
$\mu_\beta:=\dfrac{\sigma+i(\tau-4/5)}{\beta}$};
\node[align=center,text width=12.5cm,font=\footnotesize] at (6.45,-3.75)
{The actual moment history $B_q$ is zero outside
$[-t_{\rm ref},U_q]$. The comparison history
$B_4(\Omega_{\rm ref}(u))$ is defined for every $u\in\mathbb R$.
Discounted absolute errors are integrated with weight
$|e^{-\mu_\beta u}|=e^{-\sigma u/\beta}$.};
\end{tikzpicture}
\caption{The three pieces of the source-history argument, in the
child's translated canonical clock $s_c$. The colour $w_c$ is expressed
in its declared older-core rotating frame. Here $s_q$ is the canonical
shrinking-cap time and $\tau_c$ is the actual child's cap time; therefore
the actual cap is at $u=s_q$, while the reference is at $u=0$.
The endpoint $U_q$ is the end of a controlled prospective parent
interval. Zero extension beyond it does not describe the actual
infinite-time future. Segment lengths are schematic.}
\label{fig:reader-history}
\end{figure}
For comparison the canonical transform and transfer constant are
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-transform}
\begin{split}
\mathcal F_{\rm ref}(\mu)&:=
\int_{\mathbb R}e^{-\mu u}B_4(\Omega_{\rm ref}(u))\,\mathrm du,\\
\gamma_\epsilon&:=\mathcal A(F_\epsilon(r)e^{4i\varphi}),
\qquad F_\epsilon(r):=-\frac{iW_\epsilon'(r)}{4\pi r^5}
\quad(r>0),\\
C_*&:=\gamma_\epsilon\mathcal F_{\rm ref}(\mu_\beta)\ne0.
\end{split}
\end{equation}
Set $F_\epsilon(0):=0$; the derivative of $W_\epsilon$ vanishes near
zero. The transform is defined for $0<\operatorname{Re}\mu<\sigma$,
as proved in Section~\ref{sec:canonical}. The factor $\beta$ in the receiver's
instantaneous forcing cancels with $\mathrm dt=\mathrm du/\beta$;
there is no additional $\beta$ in $C_*$. The receiver-frame reference
phase and its gauged history are
\[
\phi_c:=\phi+4t_0/5\pmod{2\pi},\qquad
B_c(u):=e^{i\phi_c}\mathcal B_q(u).
\]
This includes the solid-core rotation change in
Section~\ref{sec:actual-receiver}; the remaining time-dependent factor
in receiver time is $e^{4i(t-t_0)/5}$.
\paragraph{Receiver density stop and coordinate cap.}
In receiver time $t=s_i$ define
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-receiver-stops}
\begin{split}
\varepsilon&:=q^6,\qquad
a(t):=\varepsilon e^{\sigma(t-t_0)},\qquad
W_{\kappa_i}(t):=e^{\kappa_it\Delta}W,\\
T_s&:=\inf\{t\ge0:
\|w_i(t)-W_{\kappa_i}(t)\|_X=C_s\delta\},\\
S_q^*&:=\sigma^{-1}\log\frac{\delta}{q^6|C_*|},\qquad
H_+:=t_0+S_q^*+L_0,\qquad \widehat H:=\min(H_+,T_s).
\end{split}
\end{equation}
Here $C_s$ is a finite trial constant, $L_0$ is a fixed prospective
half-width, and $\inf\varnothing:=+\infty$.
The forcing amplitude $\varepsilon$ differs from the fixed smoothing
length $\epsilon$ in \eqref{eq:guide-profile}.
The density stop $T_s$ concerns an $X$ norm. The first coordinate cap is
instead
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-receiver-cap}
t_i:=\inf\{t\ge0:|\mathcal A(w_i(t))|\ge\delta\}.
\end{equation}
Upper estimates on $[0,\widehat H]$ first prove $T_s>H_+$. Only then is
the completed retained forcing $b_J$ used to define
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-complete-amplitude}
C_q:=\frac\alpha\varepsilon e^{\lambda t_0}\mathcal A(\Phi)
-\frac1\varepsilon\int_0^{H_+}e^{-\lambda(t-t_0)}
\left[\int T_{\rm adj}(x)b_J(t,x)\cdot\nabla W(x)
\,\mathrm dx\right]\mathrm dt.
\end{equation}
Here $\Phi$ is the receiver's own seed and $b_J$ is the finite retained
actual foreign field defined in Sections~\ref{sec:finite-receiver}
and~\ref{sec:actual-receiver}. The lower bound
$|C_q|\ge|C_*|/2$ then locates the cap, and the instantaneous estimates
protect its first occurrence. Figure~\ref{fig:reader-receiver} records
this order. The positive radial slope is required only in the protected
late interval; the earlier interval has its own strict margin.
\begin{figure}[H]
\centering
\begin{tikzpicture}[x=1cm,y=1cm,>=Stealth,
every node/.style={font=\small},
box/.style={draw,rounded corners=2pt,align=center,
text width=11.80cm,inner sep=6pt},
bluebox/.style={box,draw=blue!75!black},
orangebox/.style={box,draw=orange!85!black}]
\node[box] (def) at (6.25,0) {
\textbf{Define the prospective interval before proving transfer.}\\[3pt]
$T_s:=\inf\{t\ge0:\|w_i(t)-W_{\kappa_i}(t)\|_X=C_s\delta\}$,\quad
$\inf\varnothing:=+\infty$.\\[3pt]
$S_q^*:=\sigma^{-1}\log\!\dfrac{\delta}{q^6|C_*|}$,\quad
$H_+:=t_0+S_q^*+L_0$,\quad
$\widehat H:=\min\{H_+,T_s\}$.};
\node[bluebox,below=6mm of def] (upper) {
\textbf{Use upper bounds on $[0,\widehat H]$.}\\[3pt]
Actual core control $+$ absolute child-history bound
$+$ finite coefficient recursion\\[3pt]
$\displaystyle\Longrightarrow\quad
\|w_i(t)-W_{\kappa_i}(t)\|_X\le C_a a(t)$,\qquad
$a(t):=q^6e^{\sigma(t-t_0)}$.};
\node[bluebox,below=6mm of upper] (close) {
\textbf{Choose constants, then close the density stop.}\\[3pt]
$\displaystyle C_s>
\max\{1,2C_a e^{\sigma L_0}/|C_*|\}$; then take $q$ small.\\[3pt]
$\displaystyle\Longrightarrow\quad T_s>H_+$:
the whole prospective interval is reached.};
\node[orangebox,below=6mm of close] (signed) {
\textbf{Only now use the complete signed history.}\\[3pt]
Define $C_q$ by the full actual integral on $[0,H_+]$
in \eqref{eq:ar-full-Cq}.\\[3pt]
$\displaystyle C_q=e^{i\phi_c}C_*+o(1)$,\qquad
$|C_q|\ge |C_*|/2$.};
\node[orangebox,below=6mm of signed] (cap) {
\textbf{Protect the first coordinate cap and reset its state.}\\[3pt]
Early strict margin $+$ positive radial slope in the late window\\[3pt]
$\displaystyle\Longrightarrow\quad
|\mathcal A(w_i(t_i))|=\delta$,\qquad
$t_i=t_0+S_q^*+o(1)$.};
\foreach \from/\to in {def/upper,upper/close,close/signed,signed/cap}
{\draw[->,thick] (\from.south)--(\to.north);}
\end{tikzpicture}
\caption{Logical order of the actual receiver argument.
Here $i$ is the receiver, $c=i+1$ is its child, $t$ is receiver time,
$t_0$ is the child's reference time in receiver units, $w_i$ is in its
declared older-core rotating frame, and
$W_{\kappa_i}(t):=e^{\kappa_i t\Delta}W$.
The density stop $T_s$ and the coordinate cap $t_i$ have different
definitions. Upper input bounds close $T_s$ before a signed lower
bound on $C_q$ is used; thus the prospective interval is not justified
by a coefficient that itself requires that interval. The positive
slope is asserted only in the protected late window.}
\label{fig:reader-receiver}
\end{figure}
\paragraph{The fixed observable and the two limiting paths.}
At the outer physical scale $A_1=R_1=1$, define
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-outer-phase}
\begin{split}
a^\nu(t)&:=\int T_{\rm adj}(x)\omega_1^\nu(t,x)\,\mathrm dx,\\
\tau(a)&:=\inf\{t\in[0,T_f]:|a(t)|\ge\delta\},\qquad
\mathcal P(a):=a(\tau(a))/\delta.
\end{split}
\end{equation}
The phase $\mathcal P$ is defined when the cap exists. For the homotopy
in which the selected seed has phase $\theta$ and all other seeds are
multiplied by $r\in[0,1]$, define the initial data explicitly by
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-homotopy-datum}
\begin{split}
\xi_j^{N,r}&:=\begin{cases}1,&j=N,\\r,&j\ne N,\end{cases}\qquad
\theta_j^{N,\theta}:=\begin{cases}\theta,&j=N,\\
\vartheta_j,&j\ne N,\end{cases}\\
\omega_0^{N,r,\theta}(x)&:=\sum_{j\ge1}A_j
\bigl[W(x/R_j)+\alpha\xi_j^{N,r}
\Phi_{\theta_j^{N,\theta}}(x/R_j)\bigr].
\end{split}
\end{equation}
For $N\ge2$, let $\omega^{\nu_N}_{N,r,\theta}$ be its unique
Navier--Stokes solution and put
\[
u^{\nu_N}_{N,r,\theta}:=K*\omega^{\nu_N}_{N,r,\theta},\qquad
\omega_{1;N,r,\theta}^{\nu_N}(t):=
\mathsf S_{u^{\nu_N}_{N,r,\theta}}^{\nu_N}(t)
[W+\alpha r\Phi_{\vartheta_1}].
\]
Define the observable and its phase map by
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-phase-map}
a_{N,r,\theta}(t):=
\int T_{\rm adj}(x)\omega_{1;N,r,\theta}^{\nu_N}(t,x)\,\mathrm dx,
\qquad \mathcal P_{N,r}(\theta):=\mathcal P(a_{N,r,\theta}).
\end{equation}
The colour on the right is the actual outer colour of that homotopy's
initial stack. At $r=0$, covariance gives
$\mathcal P_{N,0}(\theta)=e^{i\theta}\mathcal P_{N,0}(0)$.
At $r=1$ the map still has degree one and is onto; this topological
conclusion supplies the chosen phases without asserting a pointwise
rotation formula for the fully interacting stack.
Finally define the target phases and selected sparse viscosities by
\begin{equation}\label{eq:guide-sparse-targets}
\zeta_k:=(-1)^k,\qquad
\widehat\nu_k:=\nu_{N_k},\qquad 2\le N_10$ for the
desired tolerance $2^{-i}$; \eqref{eq:reader-continuity-radius} gives an
explicit definition. The next depth is chosen to satisfy the
precise inequality
\[
\Delta_{\rm tail}(N_{k+1})<\min_{1\le i\le k}r_i.
\]
Subsequences of its even and odd indices give $\omega^+$ and $\omega^-$.
The corresponding limiting first-cap coordinates are $+\delta$ and
$-\delta$, possibly at different times. Passive-colour uniqueness for
a prescribed limiting velocity then separates the total Euler paths.
Figure~\ref{fig:reader-selection} illustrates this last step.
\begin{figure}[H]
\centering
\begin{tikzpicture}[x=1cm,y=1cm,>=Stealth,
every node/.style={font=\small},
smallbox/.style={draw,rounded corners=2pt,align=center,
text width=3.85cm,inner sep=5pt}]
\draw[blue!75!black,thick] (2.35,4.95) circle (.72);
\draw[->,blue!75!black,very thick]
(2.35,5.67) arc[start angle=90,end angle=385,radius=.72];
\node[align=center] at (2.35,3.55)
{$r=0$\\$\mathcal P_{N,0}(\theta)=e^{i\theta}\mathcal P_{N,0}(0)$\\degree one};
\draw[->,thick] (3.65,4.95)--(8.98,4.95)
node[midway,above,align=center] {protected-cap homotopy\\$0\le r\le1$}
node[midway,below,font=\footnotesize] {cap coordinate stays on $|a|=\delta$};
\draw[orange!85!black,thick] (10.35,4.95) circle (.72);
\draw[->,orange!85!black,very thick]
(10.35,5.67) arc[start angle=90,end angle=385,radius=.72];
\node[align=center] at (10.35,3.55)
{$r=1$\\$\deg\mathcal P_{N,1}=1$\\hence $\mathcal P_{N,1}$ is onto};
\node[align=center,text width=12.3cm] at (6.35,2.25)
{Choose sparse depths $2\le N_1,thick] (.45,.80)--(12.55,.80)
node[midway,below=13pt,font=\footnotesize]
{selected viscosities decrease: $\nu_{N_k}\downarrow0$};
\foreach \xx/\ind/\sgn/\col in
{1.55/1/{-1}/orange!85!black,
4.55/2/{+1}/blue!75!black,
7.55/3/{-1}/orange!85!black,
10.55/4/{+1}/blue!75!black}
{\draw[\col,thick] (\xx,.67)--(\xx,.93);
\node[above,text=\col] at (\xx,1.03)
{$\nu_{N_{\ind}}$};
\node[below,text=\col] at (\xx,.61)
{$\mathcal P\simeq\sgn$};}
\node[smallbox,draw=orange!85!black] at (3.00,-1.12)
{odd subsequence\\limiting first-cap coordinate $-\delta$\\Euler limit $\omega^-$};
\node[smallbox,draw=blue!75!black] at (9.70,-1.12)
{even subsequence\\limiting first-cap coordinate $+\delta$\\Euler limit $\omega^+$};
\node[align=center,font=\footnotesize,text width=12.2cm] at (6.35,-3.05)
{The initial datum is the same along both subsequences.
If the total Euler paths agreed, passive-colour uniqueness would
give the same first-cap observable, contradicting the two coordinates.};
\end{tikzpicture}
\caption{Phase shooting and the final sparse diagonal construction.
For the homotopy datum with the $N$th seed phase $\theta$ and all
other seed amplitudes multiplied by $r$, let
$a_{N,r,\theta}(t):=\int T_{\rm adj}(x)
\omega_{1;N,r,\theta}^{\nu_N}(t,x)\dd x$,
$\tau_{N,r,\theta}:=\inf\{t\in[0,T_f]:
|a_{N,r,\theta}(t)|\ge\delta\}$,
and $\mathcal P_{N,r}(\theta):=
a_{N,r,\theta}(\tau_{N,r,\theta})/\delta$.
The circles depict degree, not a claimed pointwise formula for the map
at $r=1$. The signs below the viscosity axis are final outputs within
vanishing tolerances; limits have the exact signs. The two limiting
cap times need not coincide.}
\label{fig:reader-selection}
\end{figure}
\subsection{Logical dependencies and organization}
Table~\ref{tab:dependencies} records the dependencies used in the final
proof. Conditional estimates are applied only after their actual
hypotheses have been supplied. The passage from one prepared child to its
parent is separated from the final induction over the depth.
\begin{table}[htbp]
\centering\small
\begin{tabular}{>{\raggedright\arraybackslash}p{.28\textwidth}>{\raggedright\arraybackslash}p{.31\textwidth}>{\raggedright\arraybackslash}p{.32\textwidth}}
\hline
Result & Required inputs & Role in the proof\\\hline
Kernel, transport and compactness
(Section~\ref{sec:preliminaries})
& Fixed $X_p$ datum; bounded Sobolev limiting velocity
& Strong limits and recovery of fixed passive colours\\
Profile and isolated activation
(Section~\ref{sec:profile})
& Smooth fixed profile; finite modal spectrum
& Selected seed, growing coordinate and finite expansions\\
Canonical orbit and signed coupling
(Section~\ref{sec:canonical})
& Isolated activation and finite jets
& One common reference orbit and a nonzero transform\\
Cores, cold tails and inactive prefix
(Sections~\ref{sec:core-cold}--\ref{sec:inactive})
& Actual scalar contractions and positive envelopes
& Unconditional older control and small deep impulse\\
Source and reference history
(Section~\ref{sec:source-history})
& Prepared child; actual older control; provisional parent stop
& Uniform input norm and reference reset\\
Finite forced recursion
(Section~\ref{sec:finite-receiver})
& Actual finite harmonic histories and derivative reserve
& Exact-cap jet independent of the incoming waveform\\
Actual receiving stage
(Section~\ref{sec:actual-receiver})
& Prepared-child history and finite recursion
& Protected cap and invariant outgoing preparation\\
Uniform induction and phase selection
(Section~\ref{sec:selection})
& Selected source; receiver; compactness; passive uniqueness
& Theorem~\ref{thm:main}\\\hline
\end{tabular}
\caption{Dependency map for the fixed-datum selection theorem.}
\label{tab:dependencies}
\end{table}
Section~\ref{sec:preliminaries} collects the classical analytical inputs
and proves the compactness and protected-cap tools in the form used here.
Sections~\ref{sec:profile} and~\ref{sec:canonical} construct the fixed
profile and canonical orbit. Sections~\ref{sec:core-cold}
and~\ref{sec:inactive} control the actual surrounding colours.
Section~\ref{sec:source-history} proves the source estimates.
Sections~\ref{sec:finite-receiver} and~\ref{sec:actual-receiver} establish
the nonlinear transmission step. Section~\ref{sec:selection} makes all
constants independent of depth and proves Theorem~\ref{thm:main}.
\subsection{Frequently used notation}
\begin{table}[H]
\centering\small
\begin{tabular}{>{\raggedright\arraybackslash}p{.24\textwidth}>{\raggedright\arraybackslash}p{.67\textwidth}}
\hline
Symbol & Meaning\\\hline
$X_p$, $X$ & $L^1\cap L^p$ with sum norm; $p>2$ fixed\\
$K$, $Jx$ & Planar Biot--Savart kernel; $Jx=x^\perp$\\
$\omega^\nu$, $w_j$ & Total vorticity; its normalized actual scalar colour at depth $j$\\
$A_j$, $R_j$, $\kappa_j$ & Amplitude, radius and normalized viscosity $\nu/(A_jR_j^2)$\\
$W$, $W_\epsilon$ & The fixed smoothed zero-circulation radial profile\\
$\Phi_\vartheta$, $\alpha$ & Neutral fourfold seed of phase $\vartheta$; its amplitude $q^K$\\
$\lambda=\sigma+i\tau$ & Unstable eigenvalue of the fixed profile, $\sigma>0$\\
$\Prad$, $B_m$ & Angular average; entire moment $\int\bar z^m f$ when absolutely integrable\\
$\mathcal T_\theta$ & Scalar rotation $f(r,\varphi+\theta/4)$\\
$T_{\rm adj}$, $\mathcal A$ & Bounded growing adjoint test; $\mathcal A(f)=\int T_{\rm adj}f$\\
$L$, $\delta$ & $\log(1/q)$ and its shrinking cap $L^{-4}$\\
$\Omega_{\rm ref}$, $s_q$ & Fixed canonical orbit; its exact $\delta$-cap time\\
$\nu_N$, $T_f$ & Viscosity selecting depth $N$; final common physical time\\
$\beta$, $\betaG$ & Geometric amplitude ratio $\beta>1$; Gaussian weight $\betaG=3/10$\\
$\epsilon$, $\varepsilon$ & Fixed profile smoothing length; receiver forcing scale $q^6$\\
$P_j^\nu$, $P_{\rm rad}$ & Positive transported envelope; angular averaging operator\\
$\tau_c$, $t_{\rm ref}$, $t_0$ & Child cap and reference times; reference time in receiver units $t_0=t_{\rm ref}/\beta$\\
$T_s$, $H_+$, $t_i$ & Density stop; prospective receiver endpoint; first coordinate cap\\
$C_*$, $C_q$ & Canonical nonzero transfer; complete actual growing coefficient\\
$M$, $N$ in Section~\ref{sec:finite-receiver} & Finite coefficient and viscosity truncation orders; local $N$ differs from selected depth\\\hline
\end{tabular}
\caption{Notation used throughout. Local normalized clocks are declared when introduced.}
\label{tab:notation}
\end{table}
\section{Preliminaries}\label{sec:preliminaries}
\subsection{Equations, solution classes, and symmetries}
All spatial Lebesgue and Sobolev spaces are over $\mathbb R^2$.
For $20$ define
\[
H_\tau(x):=(4\pi\tau)^{-1}e^{-|x|^2/(4\tau)},\qquad
S_\tau f:=H_\tau*f,\qquad S_0:=I.
\]
For exponents $1\le r\le s\le\infty$ and each integer $a\ge0$,
\[
\|D^aS_\tau f\|_s
\le C_{a,r,s}\tau^{-a/2-(1/r-1/s)}\|f\|_r.
\]
In particular $S_\tau$ is a contraction in every $L^r$, and
\[\|\nabla S_\tau f\|_X\le C\tau^{-1/2}\|f\|_X.\]
If $f,\Delta f,\ldots,\Delta^{N+1}f\in L^r$,
then
\[
\left\|S_\tau f-\sum_{l=0}^N\frac{\tau^l}{l!}\Delta^lf\right\|_r
\le\frac{\tau^{N+1}}{(N+1)!}\|\Delta^{N+1}f\|_r.
\]
For smooth compact profiles this also holds after taking any fixed
number of derivatives or replacing $L^r$ by $H^k$.
If $f$ is supported in $F$ and $\operatorname{dist}(E,F)\ge d>0$,
then
\[
\|\mathbf1_E D^aS_\tau f\|_r
\le C_a\tau^{-a/2}e^{-d^2/(8\tau)}\|f\|_r
\qquad(1\le r\le\infty).
\]
At $\tau=0$ the separated-support value is zero directly.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Scaling the Gaussian and applying Young's convolution inequality
give the first estimates. Repeated integration of
$\partial_\tau S_\tau f=S_\tau\Delta f$ gives the Taylor remainder
\[
\frac{\tau^{N+1}}{N!}\int_0^1(1-s)^N
S_{s\tau}\Delta^{N+1}f\,\mathrm ds;
\]
contraction gives its bound. In the off-diagonal estimate only
$|x-y|\ge d$ contributes. The $L^1$ norm of the corresponding
Gaussian derivative tail is at most
$C_a\tau^{-a/2}e^{-d^2/(8\tau)}$, after absorbing its polynomial
factor into half the exponential. Young's inequality finishes the
proof.
\end{proof}
\begin{lemma}[Sobolev energy and Nash estimates]\label{pre:sobolev}
For every integer $k\ge3$, $H^k\subset W^{1,\infty}$ and
\[
\|fg\|_{H^k}\le C_k\|f\|_{H^k}\|g\|_{H^k}.
\]
The Biot--Savart derivative satisfies
$\|\nabla K*g\|_{H^j}\le C\|g\|_{H^j}$ for every integer $j\ge0$.
For smooth bounded $v$ and $g\in H^k$,
\[
\sum_{|a|\le k}\|D^a(v\cdot\nabla g)-v\cdot\nabla D^ag\|_2
\le C_k\bigl(\|\nabla v\|_\infty\|g\|_{H^k}
+\|\nabla v\|_{H^{k-1}}\|\nabla g\|_\infty\bigr).
\]
If $v$ is divergence free and
$\partial_tg+v\cdot\nabla g=\kappa\Delta g+F$, $\kappa\ge0$,
its $H^k$ energy estimate follows by pairing each differentiated
equation with the corresponding derivative of $g$; the undifferentiated
transport has zero pairing and diffusion has nonpositive pairing.
Finally, for $g\in L^1\cap H^1$,
\[
\|g\|_2^4\le C\|g\|_1^2\|\nabla g\|_2^2.
\]
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Fourier inversion and Cauchy--Schwarz give the stated embeddings;
the integrability of $(1+|\xi|^2)^{-k}$ for $k>1$ also gives the
Sobolev product bound by Fourier convolution. The multiplier of
$\nabla K*$ is bounded, so Plancherel gives its $H^j$ estimate.
Leibniz's rule gives the transport commutator. Its endpoint terms
put one derivative in $L^\infty$ and the other factor in $L^2$;
the intermediate terms are bounded by Sobolev interpolation between
these endpoints in dimension two. Integration by parts gives the
energy assertion, with expanding cutoffs justified by bounded $v$
and integrability of $|D^ag|^2$.
For Nash's inequality split the Fourier integral at radius $\rho$:
\[
\|g\|_2^2\le C\rho^2\|g\|_1^2
+C\rho^{-2}\|\nabla g\|_2^2.
\]
Optimizing $\rho$ and squaring proves the last assertion; zero norms
are handled by approximation.
\end{proof}
\subsection{Classical Euler continuation}
\begin{proposition}[Finite-Sobolev planar Euler evolution]\label{pre:Euler}
Let $k\ge3$ be an integer, and let $\omega_0$ be real, compactly
supported, in $H^k$, and have zero circulation. Then there is a unique
global Euler solution in the finite-Sobolev class
\[
\omega\in C([0,\infty);H^k)\cap C^1([0,\infty);H^{k-1}),
\qquad
u=K*\omega\in C([0,\infty);H^{k+1})
\cap C^1([0,\infty);H^k).
\]
Its vorticity is transported by the volume-preserving classical flow,
so its $L^r$ norms, $1\le r\le\infty$, and its circulation are
preserved. Its velocity energy is conserved. If
$\operatorname{supp}\omega_0\subset B_{R_0}$, then
\[
\|u(t)\|_\infty\le V,
\qquad\operatorname{supp}\omega(t)\subset B_{R_0+Vt},
\qquad V=C(\|\omega_0\|_1+\|\omega_0\|_\infty).
\]
All Sobolev norms in the statement are bounded on each finite time
interval. Uniqueness here is in the indicated finite-Sobolev class.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
Compact support gives $\omega_0\in L^1$, and zero circulation gives
$u_0\in L^2$ by Lemma~\ref{pre:kernel}. The order-zero derivative
multiplier in Lemma~\ref{pre:sobolev} then gives $u_0\in H^{k+1}$.
The classical finite-Sobolev local Euler construction is obtained by
regularization and the energy commutator estimates; see
\cite{MB02} for this standard local construction.
For $G(t)=\|u(t)\|_{H^{k+1}}$, its velocity energy estimate is
\[
\frac{\mathrm d^+}{\mathrm dt}G
\le C_k\|\nabla u\|_\infty G.
\]
Indeed, the divergence-free transport and pressure have zero energy
pairing, and the commutator estimate of Lemma~\ref{pre:sobolev} at
order $k+1$ bounds the remaining terms by
$C_k\|\nabla u\|_\infty G^2$. In particular $G'\le C_kG^2$
gives a local existence time controlled by $G(0)$, and the same
construction can restart while $G$ stays bounded. The difference of
two such solutions satisfies the $L^2$ energy inequality with
coefficient $\|\nabla u\|_\infty$, giving uniqueness.
The local solution has a $C^1$ spatial flow. Its Jacobian is one,
and the scalar vorticity is constant along trajectories. Thus
$m=\|\omega_0\|_1$ and $M=\|\omega_0\|_\infty$ bound the same
norms throughout its existence interval. The near--far split of
Biot--Savart gives $\|u\|_\infty\le C(m+M)$ and hence the displayed
support bound.
We give the continuation estimate explicitly. The off-origin kernel
of $\nabla K*$ has size $C|y|^{-2}$ and zero angular mean; a possible
local multiple of $\omega$ contributes at most $CM$.
For $0<\rho<1$, cancellation in the ball of radius $\rho$, the
intermediate annuli, and the exterior region give
\[
\|\nabla u\|_\infty
\le C\bigl([\omega]_{C^{1/2}}\rho^{1/2}
+M(1+\log(1/\rho))+m\bigr).
\]
Sobolev embedding bounds $[\omega]_{C^{1/2}}$ by $C_kG$.
Take $\rho=(2+G)^{-2}$ to obtain
\[
\|\nabla u\|_\infty
\le C_{k,m,M}\bigl(1+\log(2+G)\bigr).
\]
Thus $Y=\log(2+G)$ satisfies
$Y'\le C_{k,m,M}(1+Y)$. Its integrating-factor bound prevents
finite-time growth of $G$ to infinity, so the local solution extends
globally. The vorticity and velocity equations give the asserted
time-derivative regularity. Their strong Sobolev time continuity is
part of the local construction and is preserved under restart.
\end{proof}
\subsection{The classical viscous solution and its dependence on data}
\begin{proposition}[Planar Navier--Stokes inputs]\label{pre:NS}
For $\nu>0$ and real $\omega_0\in L^1$, equation \eqref{cont-NS}
has a unique global mild solution in
\[
C([0,\infty);L^1)\cap C((0,\infty);L^\infty).
\]
It preserves circulation and is smooth at positive times. For
$1\le r\le\infty$,
\[
\|\omega^\nu(t)\|_r
\le C_r(\nu t)^{-(1-1/r)}\|\omega_0\|_1
\qquad(t>0).
\]
Whenever $\omega_0\in L^r$, the solution also satisfies the
$L^r$ contraction $\|\omega^\nu(t)\|_r\le\|\omega_0\|_r$.
If $\omega_0\in X_p$, then $\omega^\nu\in C([0,\infty);X_p)$,
and on each finite interval the solution map is locally Lipschitz
in $X_p$ for this fixed $\nu$.
For $\omega_0\in X_p$, if additionally $u_0=K*\omega_0\in L^2$,
its velocity satisfies
\[
\|u^\nu(t)\|_2^2+2\nu\int_0^t\|\nabla u^\nu(s)\|_2^2\,\mathrm ds
\le\|u_0\|_2^2.
\]
For $\omega_0\in X_p$ and its bounded drift $u^\nu$, a prescribed
colour $f_0\in L^1\cap L^r$, $10$ with
$2C_pM\sqrt{\ell/\nu}\le1/2$. On each such interval the supremum
of $d$ is at most $2d(a)$. Iteration over $[0,T]$ proves
\[
\sup_{t\le T}d(t)\le C_{\nu,T,M}d(0).
\]
This is a fixed-viscosity estimate.
The linear colour mild equation has the same integrable
heat-gradient kernel. If $Y=L^1\cap L^r$, two colour paths satisfy
on a short restarted interval
\[
d_f(t)\le d_f(a)+\frac C{\sqrt\nu}
\int_a^t(t-s)^{-1/2}
\bigl(Vd_f(s)+M_f\|u_1(s)-u_2(s)\|_\infty\bigr)\,\mathrm ds,
\]
where $V$ bounds the drifts and $M_f$ bounds the second colour in
$Y$. Iteration and the total-path estimate prove the asserted colour
continuity and well-posedness. The convex scalar calculation justifies
all its contractions and comparison statements by approximation.
Under the additional finite-energy assumption, mollify $u_0$ and
its vorticity together. Smooth finite-energy solutions satisfy the
velocity energy identity by divergence freedom and integration by
parts. Their uniform $L^2$ bound and dissipation pass to the mild
solution by weak lower semicontinuity, using the already established
initial-data continuity. This proves the stated energy inequality.
\end{proof}
For a countable decomposition $\omega_0=\sum_l f_{l,0}$ with
$\sum_l\|f_{l,0}\|_{X_p}<\infty$, define every colour by the linear
equation with the actual common velocity $u^\nu$.
Contraction gives absolute convergence of $\sum_l f_l$ in
$C([0,T];X_p)$. Its sum solves that same linear equation with datum
$\omega_0$, so linear uniqueness gives $\sum_l f_l=\omega^\nu$.
These are the actual colours used in the interaction estimates.
Positive envelopes are defined by the same linear equation with
nonnegative initial data; comparison gives $|f_l|\le P_l$ when
$P_l(0)=|f_{l,0}|$.
\subsection{Scalar comparison}
\begin{lemma}[Scalar and positive-majorant comparison]\label{pre:scalar-comparison}
Let $v$ be smooth and divergence free, with at most linear growth:
$|v(t,x)|\le C(t)(1+|x|)$, where $C$ is integrable on the time
interval. A smooth solution of
\[
\partial_tz+\operatorname{div}(vz)=\kappa\Delta z+F,
\qquad\kappa\ge0,
\]
satisfies, whenever $z\in L^\infty_tL^r$ and $F\in L^1_tL^r$,
\[
\|z(t)\|_r\le\|z(a)\|_r+\int_a^t\|F(s)\|_r\,\mathrm ds,
\qquad1\le r\le\infty.
\]
These estimates and positivity extend to the standard mild viscous
solutions by approximation. If $P$ solves the same scalar equation
with datum $|z(a)|$ and source $|F|$, then $|z|\le P$.
Consequently, for $X=X_p$, an error equation with source
$-(K*z)\cdot\nabla W_*+R$ satisfies
\[
\|z(t)\|_X\le\|z(a)\|_X+
\int_a^t\bigl(C_p\|\nabla W_*(s)\|_X\|z(s)\|_X
+\|R(s)\|_X\bigr)\,\mathrm ds.
\]
For a finite nonnegative system, suppose
\[
x_i(t)\le b_i e^{\lambda t}+
\int_0^te^{\lambda(t-s)}
\left(\sum_jk_{ij}(s)x_j(s)+F_i(s)\right)\,\mathrm ds,
\]
with $b_i,F_i,k_{ij}\ge0$, locally integrable coefficients, and
continuous $x_i\ge0$. If $Y'=(\lambda I+K)Y+F$, $Y(0)=b$,
then $x\le Y$. For fixed weights $\rho_i>0$, put
$r(s)=\max_i\sum_jk_{ij}(s)\rho_j/\rho_i$.
Then
\[
\max_i\frac{x_i(t)}{\rho_i}
\le e^{\lambda t+\int_0^t r}\max_i\frac{b_i}{\rho_i}
+\int_0^t e^{\lambda(t-s)+\int_s^t r}
\max_i\frac{F_i(s)}{\rho_i}\,\mathrm ds.
\]
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Convex regularization gives the local inequality
$\partial_t|z|+\operatorname{div}(v|z|)
\le\kappa\Delta|z|+|F|$.
On a cutoff annulus of radius $R\ge1$, the drift flux for $|z|^r$
is at most $C_rC(t)\int_{|x|>R}|z(t,x)|^r$.
Its time integral tends to zero by dominated convergence. Thus
expanding cutoffs give the global $L^1$ estimate and positive
envelope comparison even with this linear growth.
Regularized powers and H\"older's inequality give the finite-$r$
estimates. For $r=\infty$, use the maximum principle with a barrier
$\epsilon A(t)(1+|x|^2)$, choosing the positive factor $A$ to dominate
the integrable drift growth and diffusion, and then send
$\epsilon\downarrow0$. Sum the estimates at $r=1,p$ and use
Lemma~\ref{pre:kernel} for the error-equation conclusion.
For the nonnegative system, iterate its Volterra inequality.
The remainder after $n$ iterations tends to zero on bounded time
intervals by the factorial bound for an iterated integrable kernel.
The resulting positive series is the solution $Y$.
Its weighted maximum obeys the scalar inequality with coefficient
$\lambda+r(s)$; the integrating-factor formula gives the last bound.
\end{proof}
For completeness, a divergence-free drift with the same at-most-linear
growth gives its standard viscous
scalar evolution the $L^1\to L^\infty$ bound $C/(\kappa(t-a))$,
$\kappa>0$. The $L^2$ energy identity and Nash's inequality give
$L^1\to L^2$ norm $C/\sqrt{\kappa(t-a)}$. The backward adjoint has
the same estimate because its drift is also divergence free.
Duality gives $L^2\to L^\infty$; composition at the midpoint proves
the claim. Initial-data approximation justifies it for the mild
colour paths used here.
\subsection{Physical and local colour normalization}
Let $\omega_j^\nu(t_{\rm phys},x)$ denote a physical colour
transported and diffused by the common total velocity $u^\nu$.
At vorticity amplitude $A_j>0$ and length $R_j>0$, define
\[
s_j:=A_jt_{\rm phys},\qquad y:=x/R_j,\qquad
w_j(s_j,y):=A_j^{-1}\omega_j^\nu(s_j/A_j,R_jy),
\]
\[
U_j(s_j,y):=(A_jR_j)^{-1}u^\nu(s_j/A_j,R_jy),\qquad
\kappa_j:=\frac\nu{A_jR_j^2}.
\]
The normalized colour satisfies
\[
\partial_{s_j}w_j+\operatorname{div}_y(U_jw_j)
=\kappa_j\Delta_yw_j.
\]
The self-induced part of $U_j$ is $K*w_j$; its other parts are all
foreign colours expressed in this same receiving frame. If
$w_l^{(l)}$ is colour $l$ in its own frame, its expression in frame
$j$ is
\[
w_l^{(j)}(s_j,y):=\frac{A_l}{A_j}
w_l^{(l)}\left(\frac{A_l}{A_j}s_j,\frac{R_j}{R_l}y\right).
\]
Thus its own clock is $s_l=(A_l/A_j)s_j$.
Translated clocks $s_j=A_j(t_{\rm phys}-t_*)$ have the same diffusivity.
At corresponding times the norm, velocity, and moment scalings are
\[
\|\omega_j^\nu\|_r=A_jR_j^{2/r}\|w_j\|_r,
\qquad\|K*\omega_j^\nu\|_\infty=A_jR_j\|K*w_j\|_\infty,
\qquad B_m(\omega_j^\nu)=A_jR_j^{m+2}B_m(w_j).
\]
The last equality is asserted only when the absolute moment is finite.
Statements in a local frame use these normalized quantities; field
bounds in physical variables include their displayed amplitude and
length factors.
\begin{lemma}[The velocity estimates used below]\label{cp:velocity}\label{pre:kernel}
Let $p>2$, $\alpha=1-2/p$, and $w\in L^1(\mathbb R^2)\cap L^p(\mathbb R^2)$.
Then
\[
\|K*w\|_\infty+\|K*w\|_p\le C_p(\|w\|_1+\|w\|_p),\qquad
[K*w]_{C^\alpha}\le C_p\|w\|_p,\qquad
\|\nabla K*w\|_p\le C_p\|w\|_p.
\]
If $w$ has compact support and zero integral, then $K*w\in L^2$.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
For the supremum norm split $K$ at radius one: its near part is in
$L^{p'}$ since $p'<2$, and its far part is bounded. For the $L^p$ norm the
near part is in $L^1$ and the far part is in $L^p$; apply Young's inequality.
For a velocity difference at points a distance $d$ apart, the two radius-$2d$
disks contribute at most $C_p\|w\|_p d^\alpha$. On their complement use
$|K(x-z)-K(y-z)|\le Cd|x-z|^{-2}$ and H\"older's inequality; the same power
$d^\alpha$ follows.
We recall a direct proof of the derivative bound to specify the analytic
input. Each component $T$ of $\nabla K*$ has a Fourier multiplier bounded
in absolute value, and hence is bounded on $L^2$ by Plancherel. Its off-origin
kernel satisfies $|t(x)|\le C|x|^{-2}$, $|\nabla t(x)|\le C|x|^{-3}$ and
has zero angular average; a possible multiple of the identity is harmless.
For $f\in L^1\cap L^2$ decompose at height $\lambda$ into $g+\sum b_Q$
using maximal dyadic squares with average of $|f|$ larger than $\lambda$.
The squares are disjoint, and
\[
\|g\|_\infty\le4\lambda,\quad \|g\|_1\le\|f\|_1,\quad
\sum |Q|\le\|f\|_1/\lambda,\quad
\int b_Q=0,\quad \sum\|b_Q\|_1\le2\|f\|_1.
\]
The $L^2$ bound controls the level set of $Tg$ by $C\|f\|_1/\lambda$.
Cancellation and the kernel derivative estimate give
\[
\int_{\mathbb R^2\setminus5Q}|Tb_Q(x)|\,\mathrm dx
\le\int_Q|b_Q(y)|\int_{\mathbb R^2\setminus5Q}
|t(x-y)-t(x-c_Q)|\,\mathrm dx\,\mathrm dy
\le C\|b_Q\|_1.
\]
The last inner integral is bounded by
$C|y-c_Q|\int_{C\ell(Q)}^\infty r^{-3}r\,\mathrm dr$.
This proves weak type $(1,1)$, first for finite sums and then by their
$L^2$ convergence. Splitting $f$ above and below a height proportional to
$\lambda$ consequently gives
\[
|\{|Tf|>\lambda\}|\le C\left[
\lambda^{-1}\int_{|f|>c\lambda}|f|
+\lambda^{-2}\int_{|f|\le c\lambda}|f|^2\right].
\]
Integration against $s\lambda^{s-1}\,\mathrm d\lambda$, with $11$.
For each compactly supported $f_0\in L^1\cap L^\infty$ there is at most one
distributional solution of
\[
\partial_tf+\operatorname{div}(uf)=0,\qquad f(0)=f_0,
\]
in $L^\infty([0,T];L^1\cap L^\infty)$ with its weak initial trace.
Every such solution is renormalized and has a representative in
$C([0,T];L^1\cap L^2)$; its $L^1$ and $L^2$ norms are conserved.
Suppose that the bounded measurable drifts $u_n$ are divergence free,
$u_n\to u$ uniformly on $[0,T]\times\mathbb R^2$,
$\sup_n\|u_n\|_\infty\le V$, and $\nu_n\to0$, with $0\le\nu_n\le1$.
Let
$f_n\in C([0,T];L^1\cap L^2)\cap L^\infty([0,T];L^\infty)$ solve
\[
\partial_tf_n+\operatorname{div}(u_nf_n)=\nu_n\Delta f_n,
\qquad f_n(0)=f_0,
\]
in the weak sense, with the $L^1$, $L^2$, and $L^\infty$ contraction
bounds at every time. Then the transport limit $f$ is unique and
\[
f_n\longrightarrow f\quad\hbox{in }C([0,T];L^1\cap L^2).
\]
This includes transported colours with $\nu_n=0$ under the same
continuity, weak-equation, and contraction hypotheses.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
We first prove renormalization, including the prescribed trace.
The transport equation and the uniform $L^2$ bound give a weakly
continuous $L^2$ representative: compact smooth pairings are absolutely
continuous in time, and density extends their continuity to all $L^2$
tests. Its values at every time retain the $L^1$ and $L^\infty$ bounds,
by approaching that time through bounded slices, taking weak limits on
finite balls, and then enlarging the balls.
\paragraph{Renormalization at the prescribed trace.}\label{proofread:passive-trace}
Extend the solution to $-12$, Lemma~\ref{pre:kernel} gives the useful bound
\begin{equation}\label{ph:kernel}
\|K*h\|_\infty\le C_p(\|h\|_1+\|h\|_p):
\end{equation}
strong convergence of total vorticity paths in
$C_t(L^1\cap L^p)$ therefore implies uniform convergence of their
velocities. Whenever the limiting velocities have the Sobolev
regularity in Proposition~\ref{ph:colour}, that proposition applies
to every fixed bounded compactly supported initial colour. Equal total
Euler paths then have equal recovered fixed colours.
Fix finitely many bounded compactly supported initial colours
$f_{1,0},\ldots,f_{k,0}$, complex coefficients $c_l$, and complex tests
$\psi_l\in C_b^2(\mathbb R^2)$, where the function and its derivatives
through order two are bounded. These choices define the one fixed functional
\begin{equation}\label{ph:observable}
a_u(t)=\sum_{l=1}^k c_l\int\psi_l(x)f_l[u](t,x)\,\mathrm dx.
\end{equation}
Expanding spatial cutoffs in the weak equation justify these bounded
noncompact tests: the new drift and diffusion errors are bounded by
$C\|f_0\|_1(V/R+\nu/R+\nu/R^2)$ and vanish. In particular
\[
\left|\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}\int\psi_l f_l\right|
\le\|f_{l,0}\|_1
\bigl(V\|\nabla\psi_l\|_\infty+\nu\|\Delta\psi_l\|_\infty\bigr).
\]
Thus the observable is uniformly Lipschitz for bounded drifts and
$0\le\nu\le1$, and strong $C_tL^1$ convergence makes its pairings
converge uniformly. Proposition~\ref{ph:colour} therefore makes it
continuous under the strong total-path convergence specified above.
For degree shooting we use tests with the covariance
\[
\psi_l(\mathsf R_{\theta/4}x)=e^{-i\theta}\psi_l(x),
\]
where $\mathsf R$ is the planar rotation matrix. This includes a fixed
bounded adjoint-coordinate test and the compact moment tests
$\psi_l(x)=\Phi_l(x)=\chi_l(|x|)\bar z^4$ with fixed smooth radial
compact cutoffs. These compact tests cover one smooth outer colour or
several patch colours. To recover uncut fourth moments in an Euler
limit, choose their cutoffs equal to one on the common support ball
supplied by finite propagation.
\subsection{Protected first caps and phase shooting}
We use the first crossing of one fixed observable. Its continuity is
controlled by a strict early margin and a positive radial slope in a
fixed neighbourhood of that crossing.
\begin{lemma}[Continuity of a protected first-cap phase]\label{ph:first-cap}
Fix $T,\delta,c,e,h,L>0$, with $2e0$. Before $\tau(a)-e$ the strict margin excludes a cap
of $b$. On $[\tau(a)-e,\tau(a)]$, the radial lower-slope inequality gives
\[
|a(t)|\le\delta-c(\tau(a)-t).
\]
Thus $b$ cannot cap before $\tau(a)-2\varepsilon/c$. At
$\tau(a)+2\varepsilon/c$ its modulus is at least
$\delta+\varepsilon$, so it has capped by that time. Both comparison
times lie inside the protected interval and inside $[0,T]$.
This proves the time estimate. Both first-cap values have modulus
$\delta$, and
\[
|a(\tau(a))-b(\tau(b))|
\le L|\tau(a)-\tau(b)|+\|a-b\|_\infty
\]
proves the phase estimate.
For a uniformly convergent protected sequence, extract a convergent
subsequence of cap times. The common Lipschitz bound, early margin,
and integrated radial lower-slope inequality pass to the limit; for
interval endpoints first pass on strict interior intervals and then
use continuity. The limiting time has modulus $\delta$, every earlier
time has strictly smaller modulus, and it is the first cap. The
limiting path satisfies the same protection conditions. This applies
to every subsequence, giving the closure and continuity assertions.
\end{proof}
\begin{corollary}[Separation of total inviscid paths]\label{ph:separation}
Consider one fixed total initial datum and fixed bounded compactly
supported initial colours. On both subsequences use the same initial
colours $f_{l,0}$, coefficients $c_l$, tests $\psi_l$, and cap level
$\delta$, so that \eqref{ph:observable} defines one common functional.
Suppose two Navier--Stokes subsequences converge strongly in
$C_t(L^1\cap L^p)$, $p>2$, their limits satisfy the velocity regularity
of Proposition~\ref{ph:colour}, and the approximating observables have
first caps protected by common constants on $[0,T]$.
If the two limiting first-cap phases of this common functional differ,
the total Euler paths differ. The cap times may differ.
\end{corollary}
\begin{proof}
Proposition~\ref{ph:colour} and Lemma~\ref{ph:first-cap} pass the fixed
colours, observable paths, and first-cap phases to the limit. Equal
total paths would have equal velocities and recovered colours, hence
equal observable paths and first-cap phases. This contradicts the
assumed phase separation.
\end{proof}
\begin{proposition}[Conditional degree shooting]\label{ph:degree}
Fix $\nu>0$ and an active index $N\ge2$. Suppose a continuous coloured
initial-data family is indexed by $(r,\theta)\in[0,1]\times\mathbb S^1$:
the active seed at $N$ has phase $\theta$, and all other seed amplitudes
are multiplied by $r$. Assume the total and passive-colour solution
paths at this viscosity depend continuously on these parameters.
Use fixed coefficients, tests $\psi_l\in C_b^2$ satisfying
$\psi_l(\mathsf R_{\theta/4}x)=e^{-i\theta}\psi_l(x)$, and cap level in
\eqref{ph:observable}, and assume the observable paths have first caps
protected by common constants from Lemma~\ref{ph:first-cap}.
At $r=0$, assume the full coloured initial datum at phase $\theta$ is
the spatial rotation through angle $-\theta/4$ of the datum at phase
zero. This covariance holds when only the active seed rotates and all
background profiles and other initial colours are radial. Then the
output first-cap phase map at $r=1$ is surjective
onto $\mathbb S^1$.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
The first-cap phase map is continuous by Lemma~\ref{ph:first-cap}.
Rotational covariance of the full equation and the fixed tests give
\[
a_{0,\theta}(t)=e^{i\theta}a_{0,0}(t),\qquad
\mathcal P(a_{0,\theta})=e^{i\theta}\mathcal P(a_{0,0}).
\]
Its degree is one. To see directly that degree is invariant along the
homotopy, lift its continuous argument on
$[0,1]\times[0,2\pi]$. The endpoint difference is $2\pi d(r)$ for an
integer $d(r)$; continuity makes this integer constant. A circle map
omitting a point has a periodic continuous argument and degree zero.
The map at $r=1$ therefore cannot omit a point.
\end{proof}
Fixed-positive-viscosity continuity follows from the mild equations.
In $X=L^1\cap L^p$, $p>2$, \eqref{ph:kernel} makes $(K*w)w$ locally
Lipschitz on bounded $X$ balls. If two total paths are bounded there by
$M$, their difference satisfies
\[
d(t)\le d(0)+\frac{C_pM}{\sqrt\nu}
\int_0^t(t-s)^{-1/2}d(s)\,\mathrm ds.
\]
Take short intervals on which the integral coefficient is at most
$1/2$ and iterate to obtain continuity for each fixed $\nu$.
The passive mild equation has the same heat-gradient kernel; its
additional source is bounded by the uniform drift difference times
the bounded colour norm. It gives continuity of colours in
$C_t(L^1\cap L^2)$ when their initial data vary in $L^1\cap L^2$.
For indicator colours, continuity in symmetric-difference measure of
the initial domains supplies precisely this initial-data continuity.
Uniform cap protection across the homotopy remains a substantive
coupled PDE hypothesis.
\begin{proposition}[Conditional sparse-phase construction]\label{ph:sparse}
Fix $p>2$ and $\beta q^{2/p}<1$. Let a family of infinitely seeded,
zero-circulation compact initial data be indexed by a phase at every
depth. Assume its defining series has a summable bound in
$X=L^1\cap L^p$ uniform in all phases, that changing only the phase at
depth $N$ changes the datum by at most $\eta_N\to0$ uniformly in the
other phases, and that depths $N\ge2$ leave the fixed outer initial
colours unchanged. Fix the coefficients, tests, and cap level of
one outer observable \eqref{ph:observable} throughout the family.
Suppose $\nu_N\downarrow0$, and at every depth $N\ge2$, for every
choice of the other phases, Proposition~\ref{ph:degree} applies at
$\nu_N$ with common cap-protection constants on $[0,T]$.
Suppose also that for each datum in the family its Navier--Stokes
paths are relatively compact in $C([0,T];X)$ as $\nu\downarrow0$, and
every limit satisfies the velocity hypothesis of
Proposition~\ref{ph:colour}. Then one single datum in this family has
two distinct vanishing-viscosity accumulation paths on $[0,T]$.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
Start with default phases at all depths. At step $k$, choose a new
depth $N_k>N_{k-1}$, $N_k\ge2$, with
$\nu_{N_k}<\nu_{N_{k-1}}/2$ when $k>1$, and
\[
\eta_{N_k}<2^{-k}\min(1,r_1,\ldots,r_{k-1}),
\]
where at $k=1$ the minimum is $1$. Shoot its phase to give first-cap
output $(-1)^k$ at $\nu_{N_k}$, and call the resulting datum $g_k$.
Fixed-positive-viscosity continuity gives $r_k>0$ such that an
admissible datum within $r_k$ of $g_k$ changes that output by less than
$1/4$. All later admissible phase choices have protected caps by the
common hypothesis.
The summable changes give a limit $g_\infty\in X$. Each coordinate is
changed at most once, and uniform absolute convergence of the defining
series identifies the limit with the resulting phase sequence in the
assumed family. For every $k$,
\[
\|g_\infty-g_k\|_X
\le\sum_{l>k}2^{-l}r_k0$.
\emph{Local velocity compactness.}
Project the velocity equation onto divergence-free fields. The
projection has a bounded matrix Fourier multiplier and is bounded on
every $H^s$. Since $\|u_n\otimes u_n\|_2\le VE$, the equation implies
\[
\|\partial_tu_n\|_{H^{-2}}\le CE(V+1).
\]
For a spatial mollifier $\eta_h$, $01$.
For each $C^1$ function $\beta$ with bounded derivative the chain
rule for the mollified equation therefore passes to
\[
\partial_t\beta(\omega)+
\operatorname{div}\bigl(u\beta(\omega)\bigr)=0.
\]
This equation has the renormalized trace $\beta(\omega(t))$ at every
prescribed time $t$, including zero. Indeed, the spatially mollified
weakly continuous path has
\[
\partial_t\omega_\varepsilon
=-\operatorname{div}\bigl(\eta_\varepsilon*(u\omega)\bigr),\qquad
\|\partial_t\omega_\varepsilon\|_{L^\infty_tL^p_x}
\le\|\nabla\eta_\varepsilon\|_1VP.
\]
For each fixed $\varepsilon>0$, it therefore has a Lipschitz
$L^p$ representative. This representative agrees at every time with
$\eta_\varepsilon*\omega(t)$: the two agree almost everywhere in time
and are both weakly continuous. Integrate its mollified chain-rule identity
between any fixed $s,t$.
At each endpoint the spatial approximate-identity property gives
$\omega_\varepsilon(s)\to\omega(s)$ and
$\omega_\varepsilon(t)\to\omega(t)$ strongly in $L^p$.
The Lipschitz function $\beta$ passes these endpoint terms in local
$L^1$, and the commutator error vanishes. This proves the
renormalized identity with the indicated traces between every pair
of times.
For $\beta(0)=0$, use cutoffs equal to one on $B_R$ and vanishing
outside $B_{2R}$. Their flux error is at most
$CTVm\|\beta'\|_\infty/R$. Sending $R\to\infty$ gives
\[
\int\beta(\omega(t))=\int\beta(\omega_0)
\qquad(0\le t\le T).
\]
To recover the $L^p$ norm use the convex tangent truncations
\[
\beta_M(s)=\begin{cases}
|s|^p,&|s|\le M,\\
pM^{p-1}|s|-(p-1)M^p,&|s|>M.
\end{cases}
\]
They are $C^1$ with bounded derivative, nonnegative, and increasing
to $|s|^p$: on $|s|>M$ their derivative in $M$ is
$p(p-1)M^{p-2}(|s|-M)\ge0$. Monotone convergence proves
\begin{equation}\label{cp:norm}
\|\omega(t)\|_p=\|\omega_0\|_p\qquad(0\le t\le T).
\end{equation}
The functions $\sqrt{s^2+\epsilon^2}-\epsilon$ followed by
$\epsilon\downarrow0$ give conservation of $\|\omega(t)\|_1$.
Taking $\beta(s)=s$ gives conservation of circulation.
The renormalized equation for $|\omega|$ gives finite propagation
exactly by an exterior test
$\psi(|x|-R_0-Vt)$ with nonnegative derivative and zero initial
pairing. Its material derivative is nonpositive, and its bounded
exterior test is justified by expanding cutoffs and the global
$L^1$ bound. Sending the transition width to zero yields
$\operatorname{supp}\omega(t)\subset B_{R_0+Vt}$ at every time.
\emph{Uniform strong convergence.}
For $p\ge2$, Clarkson's inequality reads
\[
\left\|\frac{f+g}{2}\right\|_p^p+
\left\|\frac{f-g}{2}\right\|_p^p
\le\frac{\|f\|_p^p+\|g\|_p^p}{2}.
\]
Weak time continuity and the constant norm \eqref{cp:norm} imply
$\omega\in C_tL^p$ by this inequality and lower semicontinuity.
If uniform strong $L^p$ convergence failed, choose bad times
$t_n\to t$. Equation~\eqref{cp:weak} gives
$\omega_n(t_n)\rightharpoonup\omega(t)$, while contraction gives
\[
\limsup_n\|\omega_n(t_n)\|_p\le P=\|\omega(t)\|_p.
\]
The same inequality gives strong convergence to $\omega(t)$;
continuity of $\omega$ contradicts the bad times. Thus convergence
is strong in $C_tL^p$.
Choose $R>R_0+VT$. The conserved limiting $L^1$ norm and the
approximating contraction imply the tail estimate
\begin{equation}\label{cp:tail}
\int_{B_R^c}|\omega_n(t)|
\le m-\int_{B_R}|\omega_n(t)|
\le\int_{B_R}|\omega_n(t)-\omega(t)|.
\end{equation}
Consequently
\[
\sup_{t\le T}\|\omega_n(t)-\omega(t)\|_1
\le2|B_R|^{1-1/p}
\sup_{t\le T}\|\omega_n(t)-\omega(t)\|_p\longrightarrow0.
\]
The common support ball also makes the limiting path continuous in
$L^1$. This proves strong convergence in $C_t(L^1\cap L^p)$.
Finally Lemma~\ref{cp:velocity} gives uniform global convergence
$u_n=K*\omega_n\to K*\omega$. The previously obtained local limit
is therefore $u=K*\omega$. The transport equation is the Euler
vorticity equation, with all the stated regularity and conservation
properties. For one subsequence on all finite windows, perform the
extractions on $T=1,2,\ldots$ and take a diagonal subsequence.
\end{proof}
\begin{corollary}\label{cp:sparse-input}
For the compact zero-circulation initial-data class of
Theorem~\ref{cp:compact}, the relative compactness as $\nu\downarrow0$
and Sobolev-velocity assumptions in Proposition~\ref{ph:sparse} hold
automatically. The remaining substantive hypotheses are uniform
protected caps and phase shooting for the actual coupled system.
\end{corollary}
\section{The fixed profile, datum and isolated activation}\label{sec:profile}
\begin{lemma}[Admissibility of a fixed infinite smooth stack]
\label{cont-stack-data}
Let $W$ be a fixed real smooth compactly supported radial density with
zero integral, and let $\Phi_\theta$ be a bounded smooth family with common
compact support, zero integral, and $B_4(\Phi_\theta)=0$.
Suppose $\Phi_\theta$ is fourfold symmetric. Fix $\alpha>0$,
$A_j=A_1\beta^{j-1}$, $R_j=R_1q^{j-1}$, and
$A_1,R_1>0$, $\beta>1$, $00$, and a nonzero complex number $b_\epsilon$, with the
following property. For every $20$ there is $q_0>0$
such that the conclusions below hold for $00$ and $\eta>0$ such that, for every
$0<\epsilon<\epsilon_0$, $0<\eta<\sigma_\epsilon/4$ and the
following modal conclusions hold. For each $m\in4\mathbb N$ and each
integer $k\ge0$, realize \eqref{smooth-active-generator} as a bounded
operator on $H^k(I)$, using the Green potential of the zero extension
from a fixed interval $I\Subset(0,\infty)$ containing both derivative
collars strictly in its interior. The only spectral value of any of
these individual operators with real part greater than $\eta$ is the
algebraically simple $m=4$ eigenvalue
$\lambda_\epsilon=\sigma_\epsilon+i\tau_\epsilon$. Its radial
eigenfunction $f_\epsilon$ is smooth and supported in the two derivative
collars. For negative sectors use the conjugate operators; their only
spectral value with real part greater than $\eta$ is
$\overline{\lambda_\epsilon}$ in sector $m=-4$. The radial generator
is zero. Moreover
\[
\lambda_\epsilon\longrightarrow \rho^5/2+3i/10
\quad\hbox{as }\epsilon\downarrow0.
\]
For each fixed finite set $S\subset4\mathbb Z$ and integer $k\ge0$,
let $X_{k,S}=\bigoplus_{m\in S}H^k(I)$ and let $\mathcal L_S$ be
its bounded direct-sum generator. Its propagator has the decomposition
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-semigroup}
e^{t\mathcal L_S}=e^{\lambda_\epsilon t}P_+
+e^{\overline{\lambda_\epsilon}t}P_-
+\mathcal R_{k,S}(t),\qquad
\|\mathcal R_{k,S}(t)\|_{X_{k,S}\to X_{k,S}}
\le C_{k,S} e^{2\eta t},\quad t\ge0.
\end{equation}
The growing terms are included only if their sectors are present.
The constants may depend on $\epsilon,k,S$. Smooth inputs supported in the fixed derivative collars remain supported
in the union of those two collars. No assertion is made about the spectrum or
propagator of an infinite angular direct sum.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Fix $0<\eta<\rho^5/8$ before the angular cutoff is chosen.
First consider an eigenvalue $\lambda$ in an individual sector with
$\Re\lambda>0$.
The eigenvalue equation forces $f=0$ off the derivative collars and gives
\[
f(r)r\dd r=g(r)W_\epsilon'(r)\dd r,\qquad
g(r)=\frac{im\psi_f(r)}{\lambda+im\Omega_\epsilon(r)}.
\]
There is no division by $W_\epsilon'$ here. In the Hilbert space
$L^2(|W_\epsilon'|\dd r)$ the equation for $g$ is
\[
\lambda g=-im\Omega_\epsilon g
-\frac i2\int h_m(r,s)g(s)W_\epsilon'(s)\dd s.
\]
Each same-collar block is skew-adjoint, since the sign of $W_\epsilon'$
is constant there and $h_m(r,s)$ is real and symmetric. Angular
multiplication is also skew-adjoint. The two opposite-collar blocks have
operator norms at most their Hilbert--Schmidt norms, bounded by
\[
C a_*^m,\qquad a_*=(\rho+\epsilon_*)/(1-\epsilon_*)<1,
\]
because their two weighted masses are $1$ and $\rho^2$ and their kernels
are bounded by $a_*^m$. Consequently
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-highmode}
\Re\lambda\le C a_*^m.
\end{equation}
This fixes a finite angular cutoff in any half-plane
$\Re\lambda\ge\eta>0$, independently of $\epsilon$.
For one of the finitely many positive sectors, eliminate $f$ to obtain
the equation on the two collars
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-evans}
\psi(r)=-\frac i2\int h_m(r,s)
\frac{W_\epsilon'(s)\psi(s)}
{\lambda+im\Omega_\epsilon(s)}\dd s
=:\mathcal T_\epsilon(\lambda)\psi(r).
\end{equation}
Work first in the sup-norm space of continuous functions on the two
collars. Let $P$ evaluate at $r_1,r_2$ and let $E$ extend a vector to
constants on the two collars, so $PE=I$. The receiving-radius derivative
of the kernel is bounded there for fixed $m$. Hence
\[
\|(I-EP)\mathcal T_\epsilon(\lambda)\|\le C\epsilon
\]
uniformly on compact subsets of $\Re\lambda\ge\eta$.
For $\psi=Ep+w$, $Pw=0$, solve the $w$ equation by an analytic Neumann
series. The remaining two-dimensional equation has a determinant converging
uniformly on these compact sets to the determinant of
\[
p_i=\frac i2\sum_j
\frac{c_jh_m(r_i,r_j)}{\lambda+im\Omega_0(r_j)}p_j,
\qquad (c_1,c_2)=(-1,\rho^2).
\]
The sign follows from $W_0'=-\sum c_j\delta_{r_j}$.
Using interface variables $f(r)r\dd r=\sum c_ir_i^2q_i\delta_{r_i}$,
this equation is equivalent to the matrix eigenvalue problem
\[
M_m q=\lambda q,\qquad
M_m=\frac i2
\begin{pmatrix}2m/5-1&\rho^m\\-\rho^{m+2}&3/5\end{pmatrix}.
\]
For $m=4$ its roots are $\pm\rho^5/2+3i/10$, both simple. For
$m=8,12,\ldots$ they are imaginary, since the real-matrix discriminant is
\[
\left(\frac{2(m-4)}5\right)^2-4\rho^{2m+2}>0.
\]
At $m=8$ the first term is $64/25$ and the second is
$4(3/5)^9<1$; thereafter the first increases and the second decreases.
Large $|\lambda|$ gives no omitted roots: once
$|\lambda|>C_m$, the operator in \eqref{smooth-active-evans} has norm
less than one, uniformly in $\epsilon$, because the denominator then has
size comparable with $|\lambda|$. Uniform determinant convergence and
Rouch\'e's theorem therefore give one simple root near the growing
$m=4$ root and no other roots in $\Re\lambda\ge\eta$. Combined with
\eqref{smooth-active-highmode}, this proves the claimed positive spectrum
for all sufficiently small $\epsilon$. By the growing-root limit,
decrease $\epsilon_0$ so that $4\eta<\sigma_\epsilon$ throughout
$0<\epsilon<\epsilon_0$. The chosen $\eta$ is unchanged in this step.
We give the operator-domain and multiplicity details needed for the
propagator claim. Choose a closed interval $I\Subset(0,\infty)$ containing
both collars strictly in its interior. On $H^k(I)$ define $\psi_f$ by the
Green integral against the zero extension of $f$ from $I$. This extension
need not be globally $H^k$: multiplication of the potential by $W_\epsilon'$
restricts output strictly inside $I$. The radial elliptic equation, or
direct differentiation of its Green kernel, gives two local derivatives.
Thus the coupling in \eqref{smooth-active-generator} is compact on
$H^k(I)$ and the angular multiplier is bounded there. The angular
multiplication operator has purely imaginary spectrum: off its value
range the inverse is multiplication
by $(\lambda+im\Omega_\epsilon)^{-1}$. The compact-operator Fredholm
alternative consequently reduces all spectrum in $\Re\lambda>0$ to
eigenfunctions. The equation bootstraps such eigenfunctions to smoothness
and forces their support into the collars, so the roots already found
are exactly the positive spectrum on every $H^k(I)$.
To check algebraic simplicity independently of a sup-norm determinant,
start on $X_0=L^2(I)$. Write $A f=-im\Omega_\epsilon f$,
$C f=\psi_f|_{\text{collars}}$ and
$B\psi=imW_\epsilon'\psi/r$. Then $\mathcal L_m=A+BC$ and
$\mathcal T_\epsilon=C(\lambda-A)^{-1}B$. Off the imaginary multiplier
range, the resolvent identity is
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-woodbury}
(\lambda-\mathcal L_m)^{-1}
=(\lambda-A)^{-1}
+(\lambda-A)^{-1}B
(I-\mathcal T_\epsilon)^{-1}C(\lambda-A)^{-1}.
\end{equation}
Here $C:X_0\to C(\text{collars})$ is bounded by its elliptic gain, and
$B:C(\text{collars})\to X_0$ is bounded. The invertible complementary
Schur factor and the simple two-by-two determinant zero imply a
rank-one simple pole in \eqref{smooth-active-woodbury}. The residue is
nonzero, since an eigenfunction exists. On $X_k=H^k(I)$ the resolvent
equation and its radial elliptic bootstrap give, locally uniformly for
$\lambda$ off the imaginary multiplier range,
\[
\|v\|_{H^k(I)}\le C_k
(\|f\|_{H^k(I)}+\|v\|_{L^2(I)}),\qquad
(\lambda-\mathcal L_m)v=f.
\]
The $X_k$ resolvent is the restriction of the $X_0$ resolvent; the simple
pole has no higher-order singularity by this estimate and has the same
nonzero smooth one-dimensional range. This proves algebraic simplicity
on every space used below. The $m=-4$ conclusion follows by conjugation;
$m=0$ is the identity propagator.
After removing the growing Riesz projections, the remaining bounded
generator has spectral bound at most $\eta$. More precisely, put
$Q=I-P_+-P_-$, $Y=\operatorname{ran}Q$, and
$\mathcal L_c=\mathcal L_S|_Y$, omitting projections whose sectors
are absent. The Riesz decomposition gives
$\sigma(\mathcal L_c)\subset\{\Re z\le\eta\}$.
Choose $B>\|\mathcal L_c\|+2\eta+1$ and let $\Gamma$ be the
positively oriented boundary of
$\{z:-B\le\Re z\le2\eta,\ |\Im z|\le B\}$.
Its boundary lies in the resolvent set: the right edge is strictly to
the right of the spectrum, and all other edges lie outside the
operator-norm disk. Thus
\[
M_\Gamma:=\sup_{z\in\Gamma}\|(z-\mathcal L_c)^{-1}\|<\infty,
\qquad
\|e^{t\mathcal L_c}Q\|
\le\frac{|\Gamma|M_\Gamma\|Q\|}{2\pi}e^{2\eta t},\qquad t\ge0.
\]
Here the exponential on $Y$ is followed by its natural inclusion in
$X_{k,S}$. The contour formula follows from the norm-convergent
resolvent series on a larger circle and Cauchy's theorem. The continuous
spectrum on the imaginary axis is enclosed by $\Gamma$; the contour
never crosses it. This argument uses a bounded generator on the fixed
finite-sector space, rather than a spectral-growth assertion for an
unbounded generator. Its constants may depend on $\epsilon,k,S$.
The finitely many sectors and derivative orders give
\eqref{smooth-active-semigroup}. Coefficients initially smooth and
supported in the collars remain so under this propagator: multiplication
preserves that support and the coupling has smooth output flat at the
collar endpoints. This proves the lemma.
\end{proof}
\subsubsection{An exactly neutral smooth seed}
Normalize the growing radial eigenfunction $f_\epsilon$ so that its first
collar mass tends to $c_1r_1^2=-\rho^2$. The finite-dimensional reduction
then implies
\[
f_\epsilon(r)r\dd r\ \rightharpoonup
-\rho^2\delta_\rho-i\rho^3\delta_1.
\]
Indeed its interface vector tends to $(1,-i\rho)$, the growing eigenvector
of $M_4$. Define
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-b}
b_\epsilon:=2\pi\int_0^\infty r^5 f_\epsilon(r)\dd r.
\end{equation}
The weak convergence on the two compact collars gives
\[
b_\epsilon\longrightarrow2\pi(-\rho^6-i\rho^3)\ne0.
\]
Consequently $b_\epsilon\ne0$ for every sufficiently small
$\epsilon$. This condition is included in the final fixed choice of
the smoothing length. Since $\mathcal L_4$ is $i$
times a real operator, $\overline{f_\epsilon}$ is an eigenfunction of
$\mathcal L_4$ with eigenvalue
$-\overline{\lambda_\epsilon}=-\sigma_\epsilon+i\tau_\epsilon$.
Define the real seed
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-neutral-seed}
\Phi_\vartheta(r,\theta):=
e^{i\vartheta}\left(f_\epsilon(r)
-\frac{b_\epsilon}{\overline{b_\epsilon}}
\overline{f_\epsilon(r)}\right)e^{4i\theta}
+\text{complex conjugate}.
\end{equation}
Its circulation is zero and its only initial sectors are $\pm4$.
For the convention $B_4=\int\bar z^4\omega$, angular integration gives
$B_4(f(r)e^{4i\theta})=2\pi\int r^5f(r)\dd r$. Therefore
$B_4(\Phi_\vartheta)=0$ exactly, while the growing coefficient is
$e^{i\vartheta}$. The stable coefficient has modulus one.
\subsubsection{The finite seed--viscosity expansion}
For the rest of the proof abbreviate the fixed profile to $W$, and write
$\sigma=\sigma_\epsilon$, $\tau=\tau_\epsilon$,
$W_\kappa(t)=e^{\kappa t\Delta}W$ and $U_\kappa=K*W_\kappa$.
The latter is an exact radial heat solution. Put $X=L^1\cap L^p$ with
the sum norm. Splitting the Biot--Savart convolution at radius one gives
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-KX}
\|K*g\|_\infty\le C_p\|g\|_X.
\end{equation}
On the near part use H\"older and $|x|^{-1}\in L^{p'}(B_1)$,
which holds because $p'<2$. On the far part use its bounded kernel and
the $L^1$ norm. This estimate requires no zero-circulation assumption.
The frozen full linear operator is
$\mathcal L f=-(K*W)\cdot\nabla f-(K*f)\cdot\nabla W$.
Its sectors are those in \eqref{smooth-active-generator}. Choose integers
$M,N\ge1$, to be fixed below, and construct
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-app}
f_{\rm app}=\sum_{j=1}^M\sum_{\ell=0}^N
\alpha^j\kappa^\ell f_{j,\ell},\qquad
\omega_{\rm app}=W_\kappa+f_{\rm app}.
\end{equation}
Set $f_{1,0}(0)=\Phi_\vartheta$ and all other initial coefficients zero.
With $W_r(t)=t^r\Delta^rW/r!$, solve the triangular recursion
\begin{align}
(\partial_t-\mathcal L)f_{j,\ell}
={}&\mathbf1_{\ell\ge1}\Delta f_{j,\ell-1}
-\sum_{r=1}^{\ell}
\big[(K*W_r)\cdot\nabla f_{j,\ell-r}
+(K*f_{j,\ell-r})\cdot\nabla W_r\big]
\nonumber\\
&-\sum_{\substack{j_1+j_2=j,\ j_1,j_2\ge1\\
\ell_1+\ell_2=\ell}}
(K*f_{j_1,\ell_1})\cdot\nabla f_{j_2,\ell_2}.
\label{smooth-active-recursion}
\end{align}
Every right-hand side uses earlier coefficients in the order $j+\ell$.
They are smooth and supported in the fixed collars: Laplacians preserve
the support of smooth flat functions; $\Delta^rW$, $r\ge1$, has that
support; and every advective factor differentiates such a supported
function. The linear source is supported where $W'$ is supported.
Each coefficient has zero circulation, because each forcing is a
Laplacian or divergence of an integrable vector field. Its frequencies
belong to $4\mathbb Z$ and satisfy $|m|\le4j$.
\begin{lemma}[Coefficient bounds and seeded residual]
\label{smooth-active-residual}
For every finite derivative order $k$, the finitely many coefficients in
\eqref{smooth-active-recursion} satisfy
\begin{align}
\|f_{j,0}(t)\|_{H^k}&\le C_{j,k}e^{j\sigma t},
\label{smooth-active-pure-bound}\\
\|f_{j,\ell}(t)\|_{H^k}
&\le C_{j,\ell,k}(1+t)^D e^{j\sigma t},\qquad \ell>0.
\label{smooth-active-visc-bound}
\end{align}
There is a finite $D$, enlarged as needed, such that if
$a(t)=\alpha e^{\sigma t}\le\delta_0\le1$ on $[0,H]$ and
$\kappa(1+H)^D\le c$, the residual
\[
R_{\rm app}=\partial_t\omega_{\rm app}
+(K*\omega_{\rm app})\cdot\nabla\omega_{\rm app}
-\kappa\Delta\omega_{\rm app}
\]
satisfies
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-residual-bound}
\|R_{\rm app}(t)\|_X
\le C\big[a(t)^{M+1}
+\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^D a(t)\big].
\end{equation}
All constants are uniform in $\vartheta$.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
The first coefficient is the exact growing-plus-decaying solution from
\eqref{smooth-active-neutral-seed}. For $j\ge2$, $\ell=0$, induction
and Sobolev multiplication bound its forcing by $C e^{j\sigma t}$.
Convolution against the growing exponent $\sigma$, or the remaining
exponent $2\eta<\sigma$, is bounded by a constant times
$e^{j\sigma t}$, because $j\sigma-\sigma\ge\sigma$.
This proves \eqref{smooth-active-pure-bound} with no polynomial factor.
For positive $\ell$ the same induction applies, with finite polynomial
losses from $W_r(t)$ and possible resonance with the first growing mode.
This proves \eqref{smooth-active-visc-bound}. Derivative loss causes no
infinite iteration: the coefficient set is finite and the profile is
smooth in every order. At each induction step apply the preceding
coefficient estimates in a sufficiently higher fixed order and the
propagator lemma in the requested order. Compact support and zero
circulation also control $K*f$ and its needed derivatives, including
low frequencies. More explicitly $|\widehat f(\xi)|\le C|\xi|$
near zero, from its zero mass and finite first absolute moment, while
the high-frequency multiplier has order minus one.
Expand the radial heat base only in its couplings to $f_{\rm app}$.
The integral Taylor formula and heat contraction in $L^1,L^p$ give
\[
G_N(t):=W_\kappa(t)-\sum_{r=0}^N\kappa^r W_r(t),\qquad
\|G_N(t)\|_X+\|\nabla G_N(t)\|_X
\le C\kappa^{N+1}t^{N+1}.
\]
Its residual couplings obey
\[
\|(K*G_N)\cdot\nabla f_{\rm app}
+(K*f_{\rm app})\cdot\nabla G_N\|_X
\le C\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^D a(t)
\]
by \eqref{smooth-active-KX} and the coefficient bounds. These are the
only noncompact factors. Every other coefficient is supported in one
fixed bounded set, where its high Sobolev norms control the required
$L^1,L^p$ product norms. The recursion cancels exactly all monomials
with $1\le j\le M$, $0\le\ell\le N$. Terms of seed order $j>M$
are bounded by $C a^{M+1}$: the pure-seed bounds contain no time
polynomial, and each positive-viscosity polynomial is absorbed after
enlarging $D$ and using $\kappa(1+H)^D\le c$. Terms of viscosity
order $\ell>N$, including the diffusion of $f_{j,N}$, have the second
bound in \eqref{smooth-active-residual-bound}; $a^j\le a$ for
$a\le1$ absorbs their higher seed powers. Crucially the exact radial
heat base is part of \eqref{smooth-active-app}, so no residual term
without a seed factor occurs. Finally rotations of
\eqref{smooth-active-neutral-seed} change only unit complex phases;
all bounds are uniform in $\vartheta$.
\end{proof}
\subsubsection{Nonlinear closure in the actual vorticity norm}
Let $\omega^\kappa$ be the NS solution from $W+\alpha\Phi_\vartheta$
and put $\zeta=\omega^\kappa-\omega_{\rm app}$.
Its exact equation, with zero initial data, is
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-error-equation}
\partial_t\zeta+(K*\omega^\kappa)\cdot\nabla\zeta
=\kappa\Delta\zeta
-(K*\zeta)\cdot\nabla\omega_{\rm app}-R_{\rm app}.
\end{equation}
Kato's inequality gives its $L^1$ estimate, and multiplication by
$|\zeta|^{p-2}\zeta$ gives its $L^p$ estimate; transport disappears
by divergence freedom and diffusion is nonpositive in both inequalities.
Using \eqref{smooth-active-KX} and adding gives
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-X-gronwall}
\frac{\dd^+}{\dd t}\|\zeta\|_X
\le C_p\|\nabla\omega_{\rm app}\|_X\|\zeta\|_X
+\|R_{\rm app}\|_X.
\end{equation}
These inequalities follow first with smooth convex regularizations of
the norm and compact cutoffs, then by their limits. All solutions here
are smooth at positive time, have finite $X$ norm, and are continuous
in that norm at time zero, so the integrated inequality starts at zero.
No derivative bound on the actual NS vorticity enters its coefficient.
We choose parameters without circular dependence. Fix
\[
C_1=C_p(\|\nabla W\|_X+1),\qquad
r_1=(C_1/\sigma-1)_+,
\]
before choosing expansion orders. Choose $M$ with
$(M+1)\sigma>C_1$ and $N$ with
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-N-choice}
\frac32(N+1)>K_*r_1.
\end{equation}
Construct the finite coefficients, then fix a cap threshold
$\delta_0$ using the pure-seed coefficients alone and reduce the
positive-viscosity threshold so that
$\|\nabla f_{\rm app}\|_X\le1$ whenever $a\le\delta_0$ and
$\kappa(1+H)^D$ is sufficiently small. This is possible by the
finite coefficient bounds: make the pure-seed gradient at most $1/2$
by the cap choice, and the finitely many positive-viscosity contributions
at most $1/2$ by the later viscosity threshold. Thus a later increase
of $N$ need not reduce a previously fixed pure-seed cap.
The exact heat gradient obeys
$\|\nabla W_\kappa\|_X\le\|\nabla W\|_X$, so $C_1$ is the
already fixed exponent in \eqref{smooth-active-X-gronwall}.
The coefficient constants affect only the later cap threshold; they
do not change the previous choice of $M,N$.
Convolving \eqref{smooth-active-residual-bound} against $e^{C_1(t-s)}$
gives the all-time estimate
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-X-error}
\|\zeta(t)\|_X
\le C a(t)^{M+1}
+C\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^{D+1}a(t)
e^{(C_1-\sigma)_+t}.
\end{equation}
The first integral has denominator $(M+1)\sigma-C_1>0$.
For the second use a bound by $e^{\max(C_1,\sigma)t}$ and an
additional polynomial factor if the two exponents coincide.
At $H=\sigma^{-1}\log(\delta/\alpha)$ this yields
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-X-endpoint}
\|\zeta(H)\|_X
\le C\delta^{M+1}
+C\kappa^{N+1}(1+H)^{D+1}
\delta(\delta/\alpha)^{r_1}.
\end{equation}
For the theorem's parameters, \eqref{smooth-active-N-choice} implies
that the second bound is $o(\delta_q)$: a strict positive power of $q$
beats every fixed power of $\log(1/q)$. Also
$\kappa_q(1+H_q)^D\to0$, $\delta_q\to0$, and
$\alpha_q/\delta_q\to0$.
The coefficient estimates and \eqref{smooth-active-X-error} therefore
prove \eqref{smooth-active-density}, including uniformity through the
entire interval. They also give the actual nonradial density bound
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-NR}
\|(I-\Prad)\omega^\kappa(t)\|_1
\le C a(t)+C a(t)^{M+1}
+C\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^{D+1}a(t)e^{(C_1-\sigma)_+t}.
\end{equation}
Indeed radial averaging contracts $L^1$, and the heat base is radial.
This estimate concerns the actual density; it is not inferred from a
contour coordinate.
Similarly \eqref{smooth-active-KX}, the coefficient bounds and
\eqref{smooth-active-X-error} imply
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-integrated-drift}
\int_0^H\|K*(\omega^\kappa-W_\kappa)\|_\infty\dd t
\le C\delta+C\delta^{M+1}
+C\kappa^{N+1}(1+H)^{D+1}
\delta(\delta/\alpha)^{r_1}.
\end{equation}
To integrate the approximate terms use
$\int_0^H a(t)^j\dd t\le\delta^j/(j\sigma)$.
The error terms grow at a fixed positive exponential rate; their
nondecreasing polynomial factor can be evaluated at $H$, so there
is no additional factor $H$. This proves
\eqref{smooth-active-drift}.
\subsubsection{Whole-moment control and the cap}
We verify the tails needed to remove the moment cutoff.
Write $u^\kappa=U_\kappa+v^\kappa$, with $U_\kappa$ tangential, and
$B_H=\int_0^H\|v^\kappa\|_\infty\dd t$. By
\eqref{smooth-active-integrated-drift}, $B_{H_q}=O(\delta_q)$.
Let $d(x)=\sqrt{1+|x|^2}$. Then $|\nabla d|\le1$, $\Delta d\le2$,
and $U_\kappa\cdot\nabla d=0$. Kato's inequality with
$e^{\lambda d}$ gives, for every $\lambda>0$,
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-active-exponential-tail}
\int e^{\lambda d(x)}|\omega^\kappa(t,x)|\dd x
\le m\exp\{\lambda d_0+\lambda B_H
+2\kappa\lambda t+\kappa\lambda^2t\},
\end{equation}
where $m=\|\omega^\kappa(0)\|_1$ and
$d_0=\sqrt{1+(1+\epsilon)^2}$. No initial exponential tail is
presupposed beyond compact support. To justify the unbounded test use
\[
F_L(d)=\frac{e^{\lambda d}}{1+e^{\lambda d}/L}.
\]
It has $F_L'\le\lambda F_L$ and $F_L''\le\lambda^2F_L$;
therefore $\Delta F_L(d)\le(\lambda^2+2\lambda)F_L(d)$.
For fixed $L$ add a compact cutoff and let its radius tend to infinity.
Finite mass and bounded drift make the cutoff errors vanish. Gronwall
then gives \eqref{smooth-active-exponential-tail} uniformly in $L$,
and monotone convergence removes $L$. The drift is bounded here by
\eqref{smooth-active-KX} and the scalar $L^1,L^p$ contractions.
Choose a fixed $R>1+\epsilon$ with
$d_R-d_0>2c_*>0$. For small $q$, $B_{H_q}s}|\omega^\kappa(t,x)|\dd x
\le m\exp\left\{-\frac{(d_s-d_0-B_H-2\kappa t)^2}
{4\kappa t}\right\},\qquad s\ge R,\quad 0R}|x|^4
|\omega^{q,\vartheta}(t,x)|\dd x
\le C e^{-c/(\kappa_qH_q)}.
\end{equation}
For example the weighted tail equals $R^4$ times the mass tail plus
$4\int_R^\infty s^3$ times the lower-radius mass tail. The displayed
Gaussian estimate bounds both terms after reducing $c$. This also
proves finiteness of the required absolute moments.
Let $\xi$ be a smooth radial cutoff equal to one on $B_R$ and supported
in $B_{R+1}$. Every formal nonradial coefficient is supported in $B_R$;
the exact heat base pairs to zero with both $\bar z^4$ and
$\xi\bar z^4$, since it is radial. At the cap the first coefficient
has growing moment
\[
\alpha e^{\lambda_\epsilon H}e^{i\vartheta}b_\epsilon
=\delta e^{i(\vartheta+\tau_\epsilon H)}b_\epsilon
\]
and stable moment of size $C\alpha^2/\delta$.
The remaining pure-seed coefficients have compactly tested moment
$O(\delta^2)$; positive-viscosity coefficients have moment
$O(\kappa(1+H)^D\delta)$. The actual error pairs against
$\xi\bar z^4$ with bound
$\|\xi\bar z^4\|_\infty\|\zeta(H)\|_1$.
Using \eqref{smooth-active-X-endpoint} and
\eqref{smooth-active-fourth-tail} proves
\begin{align*}
|B_4(\omega^\kappa(H))-
\delta e^{i(\vartheta+\tau_\epsilon H)}b_\epsilon|
\le{}&C\delta^2+C\alpha^2/\delta
+C\kappa(1+H)^D\delta+C\delta^{M+1}\\
&+C\kappa^{N+1}(1+H)^{D+1}\delta(\delta/\alpha)^{r_1}
+C e^{-c/(\kappa H)}.
\end{align*}
For $\delta=\delta_q$, every bound divided by $\delta_q$ tends to
zero. This proves \eqref{smooth-active-cap} and completes the theorem.
\begin{remark}[Scaling and scope]\label{smooth-active-scope}
Let $A,R>0$ and set
\[
\omega_{A,R}(t,x)=A\omega^{q,\vartheta}(At,x/R),\qquad
W_{A,R}^{\nu}(t,x)=A(e^{\kappa_qAt\Delta}W_\epsilon)(x/R),
\qquad \nu=\kappa_qAR^2.
\]
Homogeneity of Biot--Savart gives
$K*\omega_{A,R}(t,x)=AR(K*\omega^{q,\vartheta})(At,x/R)$, so the
physical cap time is $H_q/A$. For $1\le r<\infty$, change of variables
gives
\[
\|\omega_{A,R}(t)-W_{A,R}^{\nu}(t)\|_r
=AR^{2/r}\|\omega^{q,\vartheta}(At)
-e^{\kappa_qAt\Delta}W_\epsilon\|_r.
\]
Thus the separate density bounds are $CAR^2\delta_q$ in $L^1$ and
$CAR^{2/p}\delta_q$ in $L^p$, and their sum is
\[
\sup_{0\le t\le H_q/A}
\|\omega_{A,R}(t)-W_{A,R}^{\nu}(t)\|_{L^1\cap L^p}
\le CA(R^2+R^{2/p})\delta_q.
\]
The cap moment and integrated perturbation velocity satisfy
\[
B_4(\omega_{A,R}(H_q/A))
=AR^6\delta_q e^{i(\vartheta+\tau_\epsilon H_q)}b_\epsilon
+o(AR^6\delta_q),
\]
\[
\int_0^{H_q/A}\|K*(\omega_{A,R}(t)-W_{A,R}^{\nu}(t))\|_\infty\dd t
=R\int_0^{H_q}\|K*(\omega^{q,\vartheta}(s)
-e^{\kappa_qs\Delta}W_\epsilon)\|_\infty\dd s
\le CR\delta_q.
\]
All constants are independent of $A,R$. These are isolated-colour
estimates. Coupled use also requires bounds for the foreign-colour terms
in the coefficient and error equations.
\end{remark}
\section{The canonical ancient orbit and signed coupling}\label{sec:canonical}
\subsection{The canonical ancient profile of the isolated smooth activation}
\label{smooth-ancient-section}
We retain the fixed profile, eigenvalue and seeds constructed in
Section~\ref{smooth-active-section}. Abbreviate them to
$W=W_\epsilon$, $\lambda=\sigma+i\tau=\lambda_\epsilon$,
$b=b_\epsilon\ne0$, and $\Phi_\vartheta$. In this section the cap
$\delta>0$ is fixed and sufficiently small. It does not decrease with the
vanishing parameter. An additional Sobolev estimate permits identification
of a unique isolated ancient profile. This identification requires no
convergence of an infinite formal series.
Here $\delta$ specifies the ancient growing amplitude and the linear
preparation level. It does not assert that $s=0$ is the exact first
hitting time of $|\mathcal A(\Omega_\delta)|=\delta$; at that time
$\mathcal A(\Omega_\delta(0))=\delta+O(\delta^2)$.
\begin{theorem}[The isolated ancient limit]\label{smooth-ancient-theorem}
Fix an integer $k\ge3$ and $20$ such that, for $0<\delta<\delta_*$, there is a real
quarter-turn invariant Euler solution $\Omega_\delta(s)$ on
$-\infty0$, put
\[
\alpha_q=q^{K_*},\qquad \kappa_q=q^{3/2},\qquad
H_q=\sigma^{-1}\log(\delta/\alpha_q),\qquad
\vartheta_q=-\tau H_q.
\]
Let $\omega^q$ be the isolated Navier--Stokes solution with viscosity
$\kappa_q$ and initial vorticity
$W+\alpha_q\Phi_{\vartheta_q}$. For every $J<\infty$ and every
$0<\varepsilon1+\epsilon$ with a positive gap in
$d(x)=\sqrt{1+|x|^2}$, for example $R=3+\epsilon$. This radius and
the corresponding compact-support norm constants are fixed before the
energy exponent or expansion orders. The later cap smallness condition
will make the integrated perturbation drift smaller than this fixed gap.
For this proof let
\[
\|g\|_{Z_k}=\|g\|_1+\|g\|_{H^k}.
\]
The finite expansion from \eqref{smooth-active-app} and
\eqref{smooth-active-recursion} can be constructed in every finite
derivative order. In particular, the residual estimate holds in $Z_k$.
A useful version separates its pure-seed constant from constants depending
on the viscosity order:
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-ancient-high-residual}
\|R_{\rm app}(t)\|_{Z_k}
\le [C_M+C_{M,N}\kappa(1+t)^D]a(t)^{M+1}
+C_{M,N}\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^Da(t),
\qquad a(t)=\alpha e^{\sigma t}\le1.
\end{equation}
Here $C_M$ is independent of $N$. To verify the additional norm and
this separation, the pure-seed products are estimated by their compactly
supported coefficient Sobolev bounds. Every other omitted seed-order
product contains at least one positive power of $\kappa$, and its finite
time polynomial is incorporated in $D$. The noncompact heat remainder
products are
\[
(K*G_N)\cdot\nabla f_{\rm app}
+(K*f_{\rm app})\cdot\nabla G_N.
\]
The heat Taylor formula gives
\[
\|K*G_N\|_{W^{k,\infty}}
+\|\nabla G_N\|_1+\|\nabla G_N\|_{H^k}
\le C_{k,N}\kappa^{N+1}t^{N+1}.
\]
For the first term use heat Taylor on the smooth initial velocity
$K*W$ and contraction of each bounded derivative. For the other terms
use heat contraction on $\nabla\Delta^{N+1}W$ in $L^1$ and $H^k$.
The coefficient bounds give
$\|K*f_{\rm app}\|_{W^{k,\infty}}
+\|\nabla f_{\rm app}\|_1+\|\nabla f_{\rm app}\|_{H^k}
\le Ca(t)$ after the positive-viscosity threshold is made small.
Leibniz's rule proves the claimed seeded remainder in both norms.
Let $\zeta=\omega^\kappa-\omega_{\rm app}$ and
$u_{\rm app}=K*\omega_{\rm app}$. Rewriting
\eqref{smooth-active-error-equation} gives
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-ancient-high-error-pde}
\partial_t\zeta+u_{\rm app}\cdot\nabla\zeta
+(K*\zeta)\cdot\nabla\zeta
=\kappa\Delta\zeta-(K*\zeta)\cdot\nabla\omega_{\rm app}
-R_{\rm app}.
\end{equation}
We record the estimates that avoid a quasilinear derivative loss.
Sobolev embedding and the near--far kernel split give, for $k\ge3$,
\begin{align}
\|K*g\|_\infty&\le C_k(\|g\|_1+\|g\|_{H^k}),
\label{smooth-ancient-kernel-high}\\
\|\nabla K*g\|_{H^j}&\le C_j\|g\|_{H^j},\qquad j\ge0.
\label{smooth-ancient-kernel-derivative}
\end{align}
The second is Plancherel's theorem for a bounded order-zero Fourier
multiplier. In particular $\|\nabla K*g\|_\infty\le C_k\|g\|_{H^k}$.
For each integer derivative order up to $k$, the undifferentiated
transport term has zero energy pairing. The commutator with
$(K*\zeta)\cdot\nabla$ is bounded by
\[
C_k\left(\|\nabla K*\zeta\|_\infty\|\zeta\|_{H^k}
+\|\nabla\zeta\|_\infty
\|\nabla K*\zeta\|_{H^{k-1}}\right)
\le C_k\|\zeta\|_{H^k}^2.
\]
This commutator inequality follows from Leibniz's rule: the endpoint
terms put the first derivative in $L^\infty$ and the last derivative in
$L^2$, and the intermediate terms follow by Sobolev interpolation in
dimension two. The embeddings for both displayed endpoint terms hold
because $k>2$. No derivative beyond order $k$ of $\zeta$ occurs.
Similarly,
\[
\|(K*\zeta)\cdot\nabla\omega_{\rm app}\|_{H^k}
\le C\bigg(\|\nabla\omega_{\rm app}\|_{H^k}
+\sum_{j=1}^{k}\|\nabla^j\omega_{\rm app}\|_\infty\bigg)
\|\zeta\|_{Z_k}.
\]
For the term where no derivative lands on $K*\zeta$, use
\eqref{smooth-ancient-kernel-high}; for every term with a positive
number of such derivatives use \eqref{smooth-ancient-kernel-derivative}
in $L^2$ and put the corresponding derivative of the smooth approximation
in $L^\infty$. The $H^k$ transport estimate with $u_{\rm app}$ uses
only its fixed $W^{k,\infty}$ bounds. Its coefficients are bounded,
independently of $\alpha,\kappa,H$, by fixed norms of $W$ plus one,
once the approximate perturbation is made small in the finitely many
required norms.
Together with Kato's $L^1$ inequality this gives, for
$Y=\|\zeta\|_{Z_k}$,
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-ancient-high-gronwall}
\frac{\dd^+Y}{\dd t}
\le C_kY+C_kY^2+\|R_{\rm app}\|_{Z_k},\qquad Y(0)=0.
\end{equation}
Diffusion has a nonpositive energy contribution. The constant $C_k$
can be fixed before $M,N$: the pure-seed approximation is made small
by choosing its cap after $M$, and each positive-viscosity coefficient
is made small by choosing its viscosity threshold after $N$.
Set $E_k=2C_k$, increasing it if necessary to dominate
$C_p(\|\nabla W\|_{L^1\cap L^p}+1)$ and the compact-support
$L^1\cap L^p$ stability constant used below. Choose one finite $M$
with
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-ancient-M-choice}
(M+1)\sigma>E_k.
\end{equation}
After its pure-seed coefficients are known, choose $\delta_*>0$ small
enough for all their required norms and their pure-seed remainder. For
each subsequently prescribed $K_*$ choose $N$ so that, with
$r_k=(E_k/\sigma-1)_+$,
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-ancient-N-choice}
\tfrac32(N+1)>K_*r_k.
\end{equation}
The $N$-dependent coefficients are controlled by decreasing the threshold
for $q$, not by changing $\delta_*$. In particular arrange
$C_{M,N}\kappa(1+H)^D\le1$ in
\eqref{smooth-ancient-high-residual}. On a bootstrap interval $Y\le1$,
\eqref{smooth-ancient-high-gronwall} now gives
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-ancient-high-error}
Y(t)\le C_M a(t)^{M+1}
+C_{M,N}\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^{D+1}a(t)
e^{(E_k-\sigma)_+t}.
\end{equation}
At the cap, the second term is
\[
C_{M,N}\kappa^{N+1}(1+H)^{D+1}
\delta(\delta/\alpha)^{r_k}=o(1)
\]
in the prescribed polynomial window. The first is smaller than $1/2$
after reducing $\delta_*$. Continuity contradicts a first bootstrap exit,
so the estimate holds through the full cap interval. It also yields
a uniform $H^k$ bound for the actual vorticity. This bound is obtained
from the actual error equation, rather than assumed from the formal
approximation.
\subsubsection{Finite homological coefficients and compactness}
For a real angle $\theta$ define the rotation
\[
(\mathcal T_\theta f)(r,\varphi)=f(r,\varphi+\theta/4),
\qquad \mathcal L_{\rm rot}=\mathcal L-(\tau/4)\partial_\varphi.
\]
It acts isometrically on every radial or full-plane Sobolev norm,
commutes with the radial linearization, and respects Biot--Savart
advection. The pure-seed coefficient $f_{j,0}$ with seed phase zero
has a limit
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-ancient-coefficient-limits}
e^{-j\sigma t}\mathcal T_{-\tau t}f_{j,0}(t)
\longrightarrow F_j
\quad\hbox{in every finite }H^m\hbox{ as }t\to\infty.
\end{equation}
For $j=1$ the decaying part is $O(e^{-2\sigma t})$ after this
normalization, so
\[
F_1=f_\epsilon(r)e^{4i\varphi}+\text{complex conjugate}.
\]
For $j\ge2$, put
$g_j=e^{-j\sigma t}\mathcal T_{-\tau t}f_{j,0}$.
Its equation is
\[
\partial_tg_j=(\mathcal L_{\rm rot}-j\sigma)g_j
-\sum_{j_1+j_2=j}(K*g_{j_1})\cdot\nabla g_{j_2}.
\]
On its finite set of sectors, the homogeneous propagator decays at
least as $Ce^{-(j-1)\sigma t}$ by
\eqref{smooth-active-semigroup}. Induction, the coefficient bounds,
and dominated convergence in Duhamel's integral prove
\eqref{smooth-ancient-coefficient-limits} and the finite homological
relations
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-ancient-homological}
F_j=-(j\sigma-\mathcal L_{\rm rot})^{-1}
\sum_{j_1+j_2=j}(K*F_{j_1})\cdot\nabla F_{j_2},
\qquad 2\le j\le M.
\end{equation}
The inverse is the integral of the exponentially decaying propagator.
All these functions are smooth and supported in the fixed collars.
Only the finitely many sectors in $4\mathbb Z$ with $|m|\le4M$
are used. No all-mode Sobolev spectral-growth assertion is needed.
Define the fixed polynomial ancient profile
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-ancient-polynomial}
P_M(s)=W+\sum_{j=1}^M\delta^j e^{j\sigma s}
\mathcal T_{\tau s}F_j,
\qquad s\le0.
\end{equation}
For the phase $\vartheta_q=-\tau H_q$,
\eqref{smooth-ancient-coefficient-limits} shows that every pure-seed
term of the cap-shifted approximation converges to the corresponding
term in \eqref{smooth-ancient-polynomial}. The positive-viscosity
terms tend to zero because $\kappa_q(1+H_q)^D\to0$, while
$e^{\kappa_q(H_q+s)\Delta}W\to W$. For each fixed $s\le0$,
\eqref{smooth-ancient-high-error} gives the asymptotic error
$C_M(\delta e^{\sigma s})^{M+1}$, since its viscosity remainder
tends to zero by \eqref{smooth-ancient-N-choice}.
We justify actual compactness separately. The kernel bound and
\eqref{smooth-ancient-high-error}, integrated as in
\eqref{smooth-active-integrated-drift}, give
\[
\int_0^{H_q}\|K*(\omega^q(t)-W_{\kappa_q}(t))\|_\infty\dd t
\le C_M\delta+o(1).
\]
Choose $\delta_*$ so this is less than the positive radial gap fixed
before the expansion orders.
The exponential Kato proof of
\eqref{smooth-active-fourth-tail}, with this fixed cap and the already
fixed radius $R$, gives
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-ancient-tight-tail}
\sup_{0\le t\le H_q}\int_{|x|>R}|x|^4|\omega^q(t,x)|\dd x
\le Ce^{-c/(\kappa_qH_q)}.
\end{equation}
Initial velocities have uniformly bounded finite energy, since the
initial vorticities are compactly supported and have zero circulation.
The NS velocity energy inequality and the uniform vorticity $H^k$
bound therefore bound the velocities in $H^{k+1}$. The equation bounds
$\partial_t\omega^q$ uniformly in $H^{k-2}$ on the cap interval.
On each shifted interval $[-J,0]$, Rellich compactness and interpolation
give local compactness in $C(H^{k-\varepsilon})$. The tail bound and
the uniform $H^k$, hence $L^\infty$, bound give global $L^2$ tightness.
Interpolation applied to a smooth exterior cutoff then gives global
$H^{k-\varepsilon}$ tightness; the cutoff is chosen outside the same
fixed $B_R$. Thus compactness holds globally in that norm. The mass tail
gives global $L^1$ tightness, and local convergence plus uniform
$L^\infty$ bounds gives compactness in $C(L^1\cap L^p)$ for every
finite $p$. A diagonal subsequence over $J$ gives an ancient Euler
solution: the transport term passes by the stated strong convergence,
and $\kappa_q\Delta\omega^q\to0$ on every compact shifted interval.
The solution is supported in $B_R$ on $s\le0$, since the right side
of \eqref{smooth-ancient-tight-tail} tends to zero.
By lower semicontinuity of the $H^k$ norm and the strong $L^1$ convergence,
every such limit satisfies, for all $s\le0$,
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-ancient-polynomial-error}
\|\Omega(s)-P_M(s)\|_{Z_k}
\le C_M(\delta e^{\sigma s})^{M+1}.
\end{equation}
One may first take rational times; continuity in the weaker compactness
norm and weak $H^k$ continuity extend the bound to every time.
\subsubsection{Uniqueness of the ancient subsequential limit}
We use a norm in which no extra derivative of a comparison orbit is
required. If $\Omega_1,\Omega_2$ are two ancient subsequential limits,
their compact supports and uniform $H^k$ bounds imply a uniform bound
for $\|\nabla\Omega_j\|_{L^1\cap L^p}$. Indeed compact support
controls the $L^1$ norm by the $L^2$ derivative norm, and $H^k$,
$k\ge3$, controls every finite $L^p$ derivative norm. Their
perturbations from $W$ are small in these norms after reducing
$\delta_*$, so the stability coefficient is bounded by the fixed
constant dominated by $E_k$ above.
For $D=\Omega_1-\Omega_2$ the exact Euler equation is
\[
\partial_sD+(K*\Omega_1)\cdot\nabla D
=-(K*D)\cdot\nabla\Omega_2.
\]
The same Kato and $L^p$ argument as
\eqref{smooth-active-X-gronwall} gives, for $s_0\le s_1\le0$,
\[
\|D(s_1)\|_{L^1\cap L^p}
\le e^{E_k(s_1-s_0)}\|D(s_0)\|_{L^1\cap L^p}.
\]
Both limits have the same polynomial \eqref{smooth-ancient-polynomial}.
Using \eqref{smooth-ancient-polynomial-error} at $s_0=-T$ yields
\[
\|D(0)\|_{L^1\cap L^p}
\le C_M\delta^{M+1}
e^{-[(M+1)\sigma-E_k]T}\longrightarrow0.
\]
The same comparison with any fixed endpoint $s_1\le0$ proves equality
throughout the ancient interval. The strict inequality
\eqref{smooth-ancient-M-choice} uses one finite $M$ only. Thus every
subsequence has the same limit, proving the full convergence in
\eqref{smooth-ancient-convergence}. Repeating the argument for any
different $K_*$ gives the same limit; only its permissible viscosity
expansion order and small-$q$ threshold change.
For clarity, a direct $H^k$ difference stability estimate would require
an $H^{k+1}$ bound on the comparison vorticity because it differentiates
$(K*D)\cdot\nabla\Omega_2$ $k$ times. The $L^1\cap L^p$ comparison
above deliberately avoids this extra hypothesis. The high Sobolev
estimate is used for compactness and for the available first derivatives.
\subsubsection{Forward extension and the whole-moment asymptotics}
The ancient construction initially gives compactly supported $H^k$
vorticity at zero and finite-energy velocity in $H^{k+1}$, with $k\ge3$,
and preserves zero circulation by strong $L^1$ convergence.
Lemma~\ref{pre:Euler} therefore extends this same solution uniquely to
every $s\ge0$, with $H^k$ vorticity and $H^{k+1}$ velocity on each
fixed interval. This first extension uses only the finite order $k$;
the all-order regularity of the fixed orbit is proved separately below.
Its conserved $L^1$ and $L^p$ norms and
\eqref{smooth-active-KX} give a time-independent velocity bound $V$.
The bounded velocity transports its support into $B_{R+Vs}$.
Consequently
\[
\int|x|^4|\Omega_\delta(s,x)|\dd x
\le\|\Omega_\delta(0)\|_1(R+Vs)^4\qquad(s\ge0),
\]
which proves \eqref{smooth-ancient-positive-moment}. On $s\le0$, its
support is in the fixed $B_R$. Pairing
\eqref{smooth-ancient-polynomial-error} with $\bar z^4$ is therefore
bounded by its $L^1$ error times $R^4$. The first homological coefficient
has moment $b$, rotation multiplies it by $e^{i\tau s}$, and every
higher term is $O(\delta^2e^{2\sigma s})$. This proves
\eqref{smooth-ancient-negative-moment} and completes the theorem.
\begin{corollary}[Every fixed source window, including after the cap]
\label{smooth-ancient-positive-window}
For the isolated family in Theorem~\ref{smooth-ancient-theorem}, every
fixed $J<\infty$ satisfies
\[
\omega^q(H_q+\cdot)\longrightarrow\Omega_\delta
\quad\hbox{in }C([-J,J];L^1\cap L^p),
\]
\[
\sup_{|s|\le J}
|B_4(\omega^q(H_q+s))-B_4(\Omega_\delta(s))|\longrightarrow0.
\]
Write $B_q(s)=B_4(\omega^q(H_q+s))$ and
$B_\delta(s)=B_4(\Omega_\delta(s))$. For fixed $0\le S,U<\infty$ and
$a\in\R$, its source moment therefore satisfies
\[
\int_{-S}^Ue^{-as}|B_q(s)-B_\delta(s)|\dd s\longrightarrow0.
\]
\end{corollary}
\begin{proof}
The negative window follows from
\eqref{smooth-ancient-convergence} and
\eqref{smooth-ancient-tight-tail}. On $0\le s\le J$, let
$\zeta_q(s)=\omega^q(H_q+s)-\Omega_\delta(s)$. Its exact equation is
\[
\partial_s\zeta_q+(K*\omega^q(H_q+s))\cdot\nabla\zeta_q
=\kappa_q\Delta\zeta_q-(K*\zeta_q)\cdot\nabla\Omega_\delta
+\kappa_q\Delta\Omega_\delta.
\]
The global Euler extension has bounded $H^k$ norm and compact support
on this fixed interval. Since $k\ge3$, its second derivatives belong
to $H^1$, which embeds in every finite $L^p$ in dimension two;
compact support also bounds their $L^1$ norms. Thus
$\|\nabla\Omega_\delta\|_{L^1\cap L^p}
+\|\Delta\Omega_\delta\|_{L^1\cap L^p}\le C_J$.
Kato's inequality, the $L^p$ inequality and
\eqref{smooth-active-KX} give
\[
\sup_{0\le s\le J}\|\zeta_q(s)\|_{L^1\cap L^p}
\le e^{C_JJ}\bigl(\|\zeta_q(0)\|_{L^1\cap L^p}
+C_J\kappa_q\bigr)
\longrightarrow0.
\]
No actual NS derivative bound is used in this comparison.
We remove the moment cutoff separately. Scalar norm contraction gives
one uniform post-cap velocity bound $V$. Choose a fixed radius
$R'>R+VJ+d$, also enclosing the Euler support on $[0,J]$, with $d>0$.
The positive post-cap propagator has a forward diffusion with
$|X_s-y|\le VJ+\sqrt{2\kappa_q}|B_s|$. For $|y|\le R$, its terminal
fourth moment outside $B_{R'}$ is at most
$C_Je^{-c_J/\kappa_q}$ by Gaussian endpoint moments. For unrestricted
$y$ its full fourth moment is at most $C_J(1+|y|^4)$.
The positive domination of the signed solution by the propagation of
$|\omega^q(H_q)|$ therefore gives
\[
\sup_{0\le s\le J}\int_{|x|>R'}|x|^4
|\omega^q(H_q+s,x)|\dd x
\le C_Je^{-c_J/\kappa_q}
+C_J\int_{|y|>R}(1+|y|^4)|\omega^q(H_q,y)|\dd y
\longrightarrow0
\]
by \eqref{smooth-ancient-tight-tail}. A compact radial cutoff of
$\bar z^4$, the just-proved $L^1$ convergence, and this tail prove
uniform whole-moment convergence. On a fixed weighted time window the
weight is bounded, so its final assertion follows by integration.
\end{proof}
\begin{corollary}[A nonzero bilateral discounted moment]
\label{smooth-ancient-transform}
Define
\[
\mathcal F_\delta(z)=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}
e^{-zs}B_4(\Omega_\delta(s))\dd s.
\]
It is analytic and is not identically zero on
$0<\Re z<\sigma$. More precisely it extends meromorphically to
$0<\Re z<2\sigma$ as
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-ancient-pole}
\mathcal F_\delta(z)=\frac{\delta b}{\lambda-z}
+\mathcal G_\delta(z),
\end{equation}
where $\mathcal G_\delta$ is analytic on that larger strip. For every
fixed real $c$, the exceptional set
\[
\left\{\beta>1:
\mathcal F_\delta\bigl((\sigma-ic)/\beta\bigr)=0\right\}
\]
is discrete in $(1,\infty)$. In particular one can select arbitrarily
large $\beta$ outside it, including for $c=1/2$.
\end{corollary}
\begin{proof}
The negative-time estimate \eqref{smooth-ancient-negative-moment} and
the positive-time polynomial bound give absolute, locally uniform
convergence on $0<\Re z<\sigma$, including after any fixed number of
$z$ derivatives. Subtract the leading negative-time exponential. Its
integral is
\[
\int_{-\infty}^0\delta b e^{(\lambda-z)s}\dd s
=\frac{\delta b}{\lambda-z}.
\]
The remaining negative-time integral is analytic for $\Re z<2\sigma$,
and the positive-time integral is analytic for $\Re z>0$. This proves
\eqref{smooth-ancient-pole}. Its pole at $z=\lambda$ has nonzero
coefficient, so the transform cannot be identically zero on the smaller
strip. Its zeros there are isolated. The curve
$\beta\mapsto(\sigma-ic)/\beta$ is nonconstant, lies in that strip
for $\beta>1$, and has no interior accumulation of its zeros. Any
terminal interval of large $\beta$ contains values outside the zero
set, proving the last assertion. Accumulation as $\beta\to\infty$
is possible at the boundary $z=0$ and is not excluded or needed.
\end{proof}
\begin{corollary}[Changing the canonical cap]
\label{smooth-ancient-cap-translation}
If $0<\delta'<\delta<\delta_*$ and
$s_0=\sigma^{-1}\log(\delta'/\delta)$, then
\[
\Omega_{\delta'}(s)
=\mathcal T_{-\tau s_0}\Omega_\delta(s+s_0)
\qquad(-\infty0$. The exact Navier--Stokes family used in this construction,
with cap shift $H_q=\sigma^{-1}\log(\delta_\ell/\alpha_q)$ and seed
phase $-\tau H_q$, is precisely the isolated family already identified
by Theorem~\ref{smooth-ancient-theorem} at amplitude $\delta_\ell$.
Its full $L^1\cap L^p$ limit is unique. The order-$\ell$ construction
therefore gives the same $\Omega_{\delta_\ell}$ and a uniform
$H^\ell$ bound on negative times. Lemma~\ref{pre:Euler} yields
its $H^\ell$ bounds on every fixed
positive-time interval.
Let $s_\ell=\sigma^{-1}\log(\delta_\ell/\delta)<0$.
Corollary~\ref{smooth-ancient-cap-translation} and forward uniqueness give
\[
\Omega_{\delta_\ell}(v)
=\mathcal T_{-\tau s_\ell}\Omega_\delta(v+s_\ell)
\qquad(-\inftyE_\ell$, and choose a sufficiently small
$\delta_\ell<\delta$ for this finite construction. The same isolated
family and uniqueness again identify its limit with
$\Omega_{\delta_\ell}$. The pure-seed triangular recursion gives the
same $F_1,\ldots,F_J$ independently of $M$; passing its finite expansion
and actual-error estimate to the limit gives
\[
\left\|\Omega_{\delta_\ell}(v)-W-
\sum_{j=1}^{J}\delta_\ell^j e^{j\sigma v}\mathcal T_{\tau v}F_j
\right\|_{L^1\cap H^r}
\le C_{J,r}(\delta_\ell e^{\sigma v})^{J+1},\qquad v\le0.
\]
Indeed the error has degree $M+1$, and the finitely many discarded
degrees $J+1,\ldots,M$ have the displayed degree-$J+1$ bound.
Translate by $s_\ell$ and rotate by $\tau s_\ell$.
The amplitude identity
$\delta_\ell e^{\sigma(s-s_\ell)}=\delta e^{\sigma s}$ and addition
of the rotation phases give \eqref{smooth-ancient-finite-jet} for
$s\le s_\ell$. The constant and onset time may depend on the finite
target orders. This argument proves each finite jet and does not assume
convergence of an infinite formal series.
\end{proof}
\begin{remark}[Scope]\label{smooth-ancient-scope}
The profile and source transform in this section belong to the isolated
annulus. Their use in a coupled receiver requires the foreign-colour and
weighted source-history estimates in addition to this isolated limit.
\end{remark}
\subsection{The smooth receiver's protected coordinate and transfer coefficient}
\label{smooth-transfer-section}
Throughout this section $W=W_\epsilon$ is the one fixed profile of
Section~\ref{smooth-active-section}, $\lambda=\sigma+i\tau$
its growing fourth-sector eigenvalue, and $f_+=f_\epsilon$ its normalized
radial eigenfunction. All angular conventions are unchanged.
\begin{lemma}[A global growing-coordinate test]\label{smooth-transfer-adjoint}
There is a smooth bounded complex test
\[
T_{\rm adj}(x)=a(r)e^{-4i\theta}
\]
whose derivatives of every fixed order are bounded, such that
\[
\mathcal A(g):=\int_{\R^2}T_{\rm adj}(x)g(x)\dd x,
\qquad \mathcal A(f_+(r)e^{4i\theta})=1,
\qquad \mathcal A(\overline{f_+(r)}e^{4i\theta})=0,
\]
and $\mathcal A(\mathcal Lg)=\lambda\mathcal A(g)$ for smooth
integrable perturbations for which the pairings are defined.
Near the origin $T_{\rm adj}$ is a constant multiple of $\bar z^4$; outside a
fixed ball it is a constant multiple of $z^{-4}$. In particular,
$\Delta T_{\rm adj}$ is compactly supported away from the origin.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
On a fixed radial interval containing the derivative collars, the rank-one
Riesz projection in the positive fourth sector has form
$P_+g=f_+\ell(g)$ with $\ell(f_+)=1$ and
$\ell(\mathcal L_4g)=\lambda\ell(g)$. Represent this continuous
$L^2$ functional by a bilinear density $2\pi a(r)r\dd r$; complex
conjugation is included in the representing density rather than in the
pairing. Substitution of \eqref{smooth-active-generator} gives
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-transfer-adjoint-eq}
(\lambda+4i\Omega_\epsilon(s))a(s)
=-\frac i2\int_0^\infty
a(r)W_\epsilon'(r)h_4(r,s)\dd r.
\end{equation}
On the collars, the radial Green equation and this nonvanishing denominator
bootstrap $a$ to smoothness. Extend it to every $s>0$ by the right side
of \eqref{smooth-transfer-adjoint-eq} divided by its denominator.
This agrees with the original density where $W'$ is supported, so it
still satisfies the equation everywhere. Integration of the Green kernel
and Fubini then verify the global eigenfunctional identity.
For $s$ smaller than every derivative collar, the numerator is a constant
times $s^4$ and $\Omega_\epsilon$ is the constant core angular velocity
$-1/5$. Thus $a(s)=C s^4$ there and
$T_{\rm adj}=C\bar z^4$. Beyond the profile support the numerator is a constant
times $s^{-4}$ and $\Omega_\epsilon=0$ by zero circulation. Thus
$a(s)=C' s^{-4}$ and $T_{\rm adj}=C' z^{-4}$. These two extensions are harmonic;
on the remaining fixed annulus the test is smooth. This proves all the
regularity and Laplacian assertions. Normalize by
$2\pi\int a f_+r\dd r=1$. Since the stable eigenvalue is
$-\bar\lambda\ne\lambda$, the eigenfunctional identity annihilates
its eigenfunction. The angular test kills every sector other than $+4$.
\end{proof}
\begin{lemma}[Exact inverse-quintic forcing coefficient]
\label{smooth-transfer-coefficient}
Let a source $w$ be real, integrable, supported in $B_{R_s}$,
quarter-turn symmetric and of zero circulation. For each integer $m\ge0$
used below, write
\[
B_m(w)=\int_{\R^2}\bar y^m w(y)\dd y,
\qquad \int_{\R^2}|y|^m|w(y)|\dd y<\infty.
\]
These absolute moments are finite for this compactly supported source.
At points in the exterior region $|z|>R_s$ its complex velocity is
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-transfer-exterior-series}
U(z)=\frac{i}{2\pi}\sum_{\ell=1}^{\infty}
\frac{B_{4\ell}(w)}{\bar z^{4\ell+1}}.
\end{equation}
For every finite $L\ge1$, its remainder after degree $4L$ satisfies
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-transfer-exterior-remainder}
\left|U(z)-\frac{i}{2\pi}\sum_{\ell=1}^{L}
\frac{B_{4\ell}(w)}{\bar z^{4\ell+1}}\right|
\le\frac{1}{2\pi|z|^{4L+5}(1-(R_s/|z|)^4)}
\int|y|^{4L+4}|w(y)|\dd y.
\end{equation}
The first term forces the receiver's positive fourth vorticity sector by
$B_4F_\epsilon(r)e^{4i\theta}$, where
\[
F_\epsilon(r):=-\frac{iW_\epsilon'(r)}{4\pi r^5}.
\]
Its growing projection is $\gamma_\epsilon B_4$, with
$\gamma_\epsilon=\mathcal A(F_\epsilon e^{4i\theta})$. For the
mollified family before the smoothing length is fixed,
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-transfer-gamma-limit}
\gamma_\epsilon\longrightarrow
\gamma_0=\frac{i\rho^{-6}-\rho^{-1}}{8\pi}\ne0
\quad(\epsilon\downarrow0).
\end{equation}
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
In complex notation Biot--Savart is
$U(z)=\frac i{2\pi}\int(\bar z-\bar y)^{-1}w(y)\dd y$.
For $|z|>R_s$, the geometric series converges uniformly in $y$ on
the source support and absolutely after integration. Quarter-turn symmetry
gives $B_m=(-i)^mB_m$, eliminating every degree not divisible by four;
zero circulation eliminates $B_0$. This proves
\eqref{smooth-transfer-exterior-series}. Summing the absolute values of
the remaining degrees and using $|y|\le R_s$ proves
\eqref{smooth-transfer-exterior-remainder}. The exterior expansion is
not used in an inner hole of an annular support. For its first term,
\[
u_r=\Re(Ue^{-i\theta})
=\frac{iB_4}{4\pi r^5}e^{4i\theta}
+\text{complex conjugate}.
\]
The linearized forcing is $-u_rW'$, giving $F_\epsilon$.
We check nonvanishing without assuming an adjoint convergence theorem.
The inhomogeneous resolvent Schur reduction in the proof of
Lemma~\ref{smooth-active-spectrum} applies to this forcing. Its natural
radial measure has limit
\[
F_\epsilon(r)r\dd r
\rightharpoonup
\sum_{i=1}^2\frac{ic_i}{4\pi r_i^4}\delta_{r_i}.
\]
Thus in interface variables its forcing vector tends to
$h=(i/(4\pi\rho^6),i/(4\pi))$.
The growing dual of $M_4$, normalized on $(1,-i\rho)$, is
$\ell_0(q)=(q_1+iq_2/\rho)/2$. Its pairing with $h$ is
$\gamma_0$ in \eqref{smooth-transfer-gamma-limit}.
More explicitly, on a small fixed contour around the growing root the
inhomogeneous Schur equations converge uniformly to
$(z-M_4)q=h$. Integrating their resolvent in $z$ gives convergence of
the rank-one projected forcing coefficient. The eigenfunction
normalization agrees with that in Section~\ref{smooth-active-section}.
This proves the limit and nonvanishing for all sufficiently small
$\epsilon$. This condition is included in the final fixed choice of
the smoothing length.
\end{proof}
The direction of this interaction matters. A smaller source acts on the
larger receiver by the inverse-quintic exterior field above. A larger
annulus acts in its interior through a cubic harmonic field. They are
different coefficients and cannot be interchanged.
For comparison, an exterior annulus's interior harmonic field
$U(z)=c_3\bar z^3$ has positive fourth radial coefficient
$\bar c_3r^3/2$. Its frozen-base forcing is
$-\bar c_3r^3W'/2$, with growing projection
$\gamma^{\rm out}_\epsilon\bar c_3$. The same resolvent limit gives
\[
\gamma^{\rm out}_\epsilon\longrightarrow
(\rho^2+i/\rho)/4\ne0.
\]
Indeed its interface forcing vector is $(\rho^2/2,1/2)$, paired
against the same growing dual. Thus older cubic fields can genuinely
seed the growing coordinate; their size must be bounded, rather than
discarded by symmetry. All the required spectral and nonvanishing
conditions now hold for every sufficiently small smoothing length.
Fix once one $\epsilon$ for which Lemma~\ref{smooth-active-spectrum}
holds and $b_\epsilon,\gamma_\epsilon,\gamma^{\rm out}_\epsilon$ are
nonzero, and retain it in every later finite expansion and Sobolev order.
\begin{lemma}[Duhamel coefficient for a child source]
\label{smooth-transfer-duhamel}
Let $A_c=\beta A_r$, $R_c=qR_r$, and use receiver time
$s=A_rt$. Suppose, in a frame removing all common solid rotation, that
the source's normalized fourth moment is $B(u)$, with child time
$u=\beta s-s_*$. The receiver core has angular velocity $-A_r/5$;
this rotates the child's moment by $e^{4is/5}$ in the receiver frame.
The ideal linear growing receiver coefficient obeys
\[
a'(s)=\lambda a(s)
+\beta q^6\gamma_\epsilon e^{4is/5}B(\beta s-s_*).
\]
For the response with no independent growing coefficient at $s=-\infty$,
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-transfer-duhamel-formula}
e^{-\lambda s}a(s)
=q^6\gamma_\epsilon e^{-\mu_\beta s_*}
\int_{-\infty}^{\beta s-s_*}e^{-\mu_\beta u}B(u)\dd u,
\qquad
\mu_\beta=\frac{\sigma+i(\tau-4/5)}\beta.
\end{equation}
This integral exists whenever $B(u)=O(e^{\sigma u})$ at $-\infty$ and
has polynomial growth at $+\infty$, provided $\beta>1$.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
The dimensional fourth moment is $A_cR_c^6B$. Dividing the child velocity
by $A_rR_r$ leaves the factor $\beta q^6$, so
Lemma~\ref{smooth-transfer-coefficient} gives the forcing magnitude.
Rotation through angle $\Omega t$ multiplies $B_4$ by $e^{-4i\Omega t}$.
The parent constant core has vorticity $-2A_r/5$, hence angular velocity
$-A_r/5$, which gives the factor $e^{4is/5}$. Multiplication by the
integrating factor $e^{-\lambda s}$ and the substitution
$u=\beta s-s_*$ give \eqref{smooth-transfer-duhamel-formula}.
Its negative tail has exponential exponent $\sigma-\sigma/\beta>0$;
its positive tail has discount $\sigma/\beta>0$.
\end{proof}
\begin{lemma}[A nonzero bilateral source transform from an ancient orbit]
\label{smooth-transfer-transform}
Suppose a global Euler source trajectory has a fourth moment $B(u)$ with
\[
B(u)=c b_\epsilon e^{\lambda u}+O(e^{2\sigma u})
\quad(u\to-\infty),\qquad c\ne0,
\]
and $|B(u)|\le C(1+u)^4$ for $u\ge0$. Define
\[
\mathcal F(z)=\int_{\R}e^{-zu}B(u)\dd u,
\qquad 0<\Re z<\sigma.
\]
Then $\mathcal F$ is analytic and not identically zero. For every finite
interval $[B_*,B_*+1]\subset(1,\infty)$ there is a choice of $\beta$
in that interval such that $\mathcal F(\mu_\beta)\ne0$.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
The two explicit bounds give absolute locally uniform convergence of
the integral and of all complex derivatives, proving analyticity.
Split at zero and subtract the leading negative-time asymptotic. It gives
\[
\mathcal F(z)=\frac{c b_\epsilon}{\lambda-z}+\mathcal G(z),
\qquad 0<\Re z<\sigma,
\]
where $\mathcal G$ is analytic in $0<\Re z<2\sigma$: the remainder
on the negative half-line has rate $2\sigma$, and the positive half-line
has polynomial growth. Thus its meromorphic extension has a nonremovable
simple pole at $z=\lambda$. In particular it cannot vanish identically
on the original strip. The analytic nonconstant curve
$\beta\mapsto\mu_\beta$ lies inside that strip for real $\beta>1$.
If the transform vanished along any real interval, its zeros would have
an interior accumulation point and the identity theorem would force
identical vanishing. Its zeros along the displayed compact interval are
therefore discrete, and a nonzero choice exists.
\end{proof}
The canonical ancient Euler orbit of Theorem~\ref{smooth-ancient-theorem}
has precisely this negative-time estimate. It comes from the high-Sobolev
construction and not merely from the isolated $X$-norm cap theorem. Its
positive-time moment bound is elementary once a compactly supported
bounded-vorticity orbit exists: $L^1,L^p$ conservation bounds its velocity
by \eqref{smooth-active-KX}, its support radius grows at most linearly,
and its fourth absolute moment is therefore polynomial of degree at most
four. Lemma~\ref{smooth-transfer-transform} isolates the precise
ancient-orbit input needed for the noncancellation assertion.
\begin{lemma}[Quantitative window and source errors]
\label{smooth-transfer-window}
Let $\beta>1$ be fixed, $\mu=\mu_\beta$, and $S,U\ge0$. Suppose
$\mathcal F(\mu)\ne0$ and the source satisfies the bounds of
Lemma~\ref{smooth-transfer-transform}. Define the truncation budget
\[
E_{\rm tr}=\left|\mathcal F(\mu)
-\int_{-S}^{U}e^{-\mu u}B(u)\dd u\right|.
\]
It satisfies
\[
E_{\rm tr}\le
C e^{-(\sigma-\Re\mu)S}
+C_\beta(1+U)^4e^{-\Re\mu U}.
\]
Replacing the moment on that window by $\widetilde B$ has budget
\[
E_{\rm rep}=\int_{-S}^{U}e^{-\Re\mu u}
|\widetilde B(u)-B(u)|\dd u.
\]
Set $Q=q^6|\gamma_\epsilon|e^{-\sigma s_*/\beta}$. If the three
budgets satisfy
\[
E_{\rm tr}<\tfrac14|\mathcal F(\mu)|,\qquad
E_{\rm rep}<\tfrac14|\mathcal F(\mu)|,\qquad
|a_0|<\tfrac14Q|\mathcal F(\mu)|,
\]
then adding the independent old growing coefficient $a_0$ to the
modified source response leaves a growing coefficient of modulus
greater than $Q|\mathcal F(\mu)|/4$.
If $s_*=\sigma^{-1}\log(\delta/\alpha)$ and both old and child seed
amplitudes have size $\alpha=q^{K_*}$, the old-seed condition is
algebraically feasible when
\[
K_*(1-1/\beta)>6.
\]
Here $0<\delta\le1$ is fixed or decreases logarithmically in $1/q$;
the remaining source and transfer constants are fixed.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Put $a=\Re\mu=\sigma/\beta\in(0,\sigma)$. The negative tail is
bounded by $C e^{-(\sigma-a)S}/(\sigma-a)$. For the positive tail,
substitute $u=U+v$ and use
$ (1+U+v)^4\le(1+U)^4(1+v)^4$ for $U,v\ge0$. The integral of
$e^{-av}(1+v)^4$ is finite, giving the asserted positive-tail bound.
The negative and positive tails together constitute the single budget
$E_{\rm tr}$. By the triangle inequality,
\[
\left|\int_{-S}^{U}e^{-\mu u}\widetilde B(u)\dd u\right|
\ge |\mathcal F(\mu)|-E_{\rm tr}-E_{\rm rep}
>\tfrac12|\mathcal F(\mu)|.
\]
Equation~\eqref{smooth-transfer-duhamel-formula} multiplies this transform
by a factor of modulus $Q$. A further triangle inequality subtracting
$|a_0|$ leaves a modulus greater than $Q|\mathcal F(\mu)|/4$.
Finally $e^{-\sigma s_*/\beta}=(\alpha/\delta)^{1/\beta}$, so
\[
\frac{\alpha}{q^6(\alpha/\delta)^{1/\beta}}
=q^{K_*(1-1/\beta)-6}\delta^{1/\beta}\longrightarrow0
\]
under the stated power inequality. Fixed logarithmic cap factors do not
alter this strict inequality.
\end{proof}
\subsubsection{Exact heat shielding and the remaining coupled terms}
The neutral seed \eqref{smooth-active-neutral-seed} has only sectors
$\pm4$ and $B_4=0$. Its velocity is zero outside $B_{1+\epsilon}$:
in the exterior angular Green formula its coefficient is exactly its
fourth moment. Thus its velocity $V_\vartheta=K*\Phi_\vartheta$ is
smooth and compactly supported. Heat commutes with Biot--Savart, so a
passive physical seed of amplitude $A\alpha$ and radius $r$ has exterior
heat velocity bounded, for $|x|\ge R>2(1+\epsilon)r$, by
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-transfer-heat-shield}
|e^{\nu t\Delta}[A\alpha r V_\vartheta(\cdot/r)](x)|
\le C A\alpha r\exp[-cR^2/(\nu t)].
\end{equation}
Indeed convolution integrates a bounded function supported in that ball,
and the Gaussian mass at distance at least $R/2$ has the displayed bound.
No damping estimate of a conserved harmonic moment is invoked. The bound
concerns a passive heat evolution; its nonlinear moment generation is
an additional term.
For precision, the actual foreign-colour equation yields an exact
protected-coordinate identity. Suppose a receiver colour $w$ solves
\[
w_t+(K*w+b)\cdot\nabla w=\kappa\Delta w,
\qquad \operatorname{div}b=0,
\]
and put $f=w-W_\kappa$. Remove any common rigid rotation first.
Testing with Lemma~\ref{smooth-transfer-adjoint} gives
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-transfer-actual-ODE}
\frac{\dd}{\dd t}\mathcal A(f)
=\lambda\mathcal A(f)-\int T_{\rm adj} b\cdot\nabla W\dd x
+\mathcal E(t),
\end{equation}
where the exact error is the sum of
\begin{align*}
&\kappa\int\Delta T_{\rm adj} f\dd x,\qquad
-\int T_{\rm adj}\big[(K*(W_\kappa-W))\cdot\nabla f
+(K*f)\cdot\nabla(W_\kappa-W)\big]\dd x,\\
&\int f(K*f)\cdot\nabla T_{\rm adj}\dd x,\qquad
\int f b\cdot\nabla T_{\rm adj}\dd x,\qquad
-\int T_{\rm adj} b\cdot\nabla(W_\kappa-W)\dd x.
\end{align*}
There is no derivative of the actual $f$ after integrating its transport
terms by parts. Smooth heat Taylor and \eqref{smooth-active-KX} give
\begin{equation}\label{smooth-transfer-actual-error}
|\mathcal E(t)|
\le C[\kappa(1+t)\|f\|_X+\|f\|_X^2]
+\int|f||b||\nabla T_{\rm adj}|\dd x
+\left|\int T_{\rm adj} b\cdot\nabla(W_\kappa-W)\dd x\right|.
\end{equation}
For the term with $\nabla f$, integration by parts bounds it by
$\|\nabla T_{\rm adj}\|_\infty\|K*(W_\kappa-W)\|_\infty\|f\|_1$;
the other heat term uses $\|\nabla(W_\kappa-W)\|_1=O(\kappa t)$.
The quadratic self term uses \eqref{smooth-active-KX}. If
$b=\Omega(t)Jx$ is a rigid rotation, its base forcing vanishes and
its perturbation contribution is exactly $-4i\Omega(t)\mathcal A(f)$;
it can be removed by its integrating phase.
Equation \eqref{smooth-transfer-actual-ODE} identifies the estimates
required for coupled use. On the receiver collars one must approximate $b$ by the
inverse-quintic child field of
Lemma~\ref{smooth-transfer-coefficient}; its projected error is bounded
by the collar sup error times $\|T_{\rm adj}\nabla W\|_1$. One must also control
the two weighted foreign terms in
\eqref{smooth-transfer-actual-error} and prove a nonlinear density bound
for this actual colour. The canonical source transform must be approximated
in the weighted norm of Lemma~\ref{smooth-transfer-window}, including
its post-cap history. The actual foreign-colour estimates and weighted source-history control
are additional inputs to a coupled receiver argument.
\subsubsection{A nonlinear receiver theorem for the concrete canonical input}
The following theorem uses the moment of the canonical isolated Euler
orbit and realizes its exterior harmonic field through a prescribed
smooth divergence-free extension. Its equation has this auxiliary drift;
the source and receiver are not asserted here to solve a jointly unforced
system.
Fix an ancient orbit $\Omega_{\delta_c}$ from
Theorem~\ref{smooth-ancient-theorem}, with fixed small $\delta_c>0$,
and put $B(u)=B_4(\Omega_{\delta_c}(u))$. Choose $\beta>1$ for which
\[
C_*:=\gamma_\epsilon\mathcal F(\mu_\beta)\ne0.
\]
Such a choice is possible in every sufficiently large fixed interval by
Lemma~\ref{smooth-transfer-transform}. Take a smooth radial cutoff
$\zeta_0$ equal to zero near the origin and equal to one on and outside
the two receiver derivative collars. For $c\in\C$ set
\[
\Psi_c(r,\theta)=-\frac{\zeta_0(r)}{16\pi r^4}
(ce^{4i\theta}+\bar c e^{-4i\theta}),
\qquad \mathcal V_c=\nabla^\perp\Psi_c.
\]
This is a smooth real divergence-free field with every fixed spatial
derivative bounded by a constant times $|c|$. On the receiver collars
it agrees exactly with the inverse-quintic field of a source moment $c$.
\begin{theorem}[Transmission for a prescribed canonical harmonic input]
\label{smooth-transfer-prescribed}
Fix $K_*>0$ such that $K_*(1-1/\beta)>6$. For small $q$ put
\[
\alpha=q^{K_*},\quad \varepsilon_q=q^6,\quad
\delta_q=[\log(1/q)]^{-4},\quad
t_0=\frac1{\beta\sigma}\log\frac{\delta_c}{\alpha},\quad
S_q=\frac1\sigma\log\frac{\delta_q}{\varepsilon_q|C_*|},\quad
H_q=t_0+S_q.
\]
For $0<\kappa\le q^{3/2}$ define the prescribed foreign drift
\[
b_q(t,x)=\beta\varepsilon_q
\mathcal V_{\,e^{4i(t-t_0)/5}B(\beta(t-t_0))}(x),
\qquad 0\le t\le H_q.
\]
Let $w^q$ solve the coloured equation
\[
\partial_tw^q+(K*w^q+b_q)\cdot\nabla w^q=\kappa\Delta w^q,
\qquad w^q(0)=W+\alpha\Phi_0.
\]
Then uniformly in $0<\kappa\le q^{3/2}$,
\begin{align*}
\sup_{0\le t\le H_q}\|w^q(t)-e^{\kappa t\Delta}W\|_X
&\le C\delta_q,\\
\mathcal A(w^q(H_q))
&=\delta_q e^{i(\tau S_q+\arg C_*)}+o(\delta_q),\\
B_4(w^q(H_q))
&=b_\epsilon\delta_q e^{i(\tau S_q+\arg C_*)}+o(\delta_q).
\end{align*}
The whole fourth moment is finite. Multiplying the source moment in
$b_q$ by a fixed unit complex phase multiplies the leading cap phase
by the same phase; all bounds are uniform in that phase.
\end{theorem}
\begin{proof}
For completeness, the positive-viscosity solution with this prescribed
drift exists on the whole displayed window. On a short interval its mild
equation is a contraction in $C_t(L^1\cap L^p)$: the heat-gradient estimate
is $\|\nabla e^{\kappa t\Delta}\|_{L^r\to L^r}\le C(\kappa t)^{-1/2}$,
the Biot--Savart map sends $X$ to $L^\infty$, and $b_q$ is bounded there.
Scalar convex-energy estimates give the $L^1,L^p$ contractions and hence
a time-uniform velocity bound. Iterating the local construction prevents
finite-time loss of the mild solution. Smoothing follows by the same mild
equation from the smooth spatial coefficients. This argument uses only
bounded drift on the finite window, not the conclusion of the theorem.
Use $s=t-t_0$ and write $b_q=\varepsilon_q b_1(s)$.
The ancient and future moment bounds give
\[
\|b_1(s)\|_{C^j}\le
\begin{cases}C_j e^{\beta\sigma s},&s\le0,\\
C_j(1+s)^4,&s\ge0.
\end{cases}
\]
In particular this is bounded by $C_j e^{\sigma s}$ for all $s$,
and its growing-mode weighted time integral is finite, uniformly in
the initial time $-t_0$. The first seed-order coefficient solves
\[
(\partial_t-\mathcal L)g_{1,0}=-b_1(t-t_0)\cdot\nabla W,
\qquad g_{1,0}(0)=(\alpha/\varepsilon_q)\Phi_0.
\]
Its growing coordinate is
\[
e^{-\lambda s}\mathcal A(g_{1,0}(t))
=\frac{\alpha}{\varepsilon_q}e^{\lambda t_0}
+\gamma_\epsilon
\int_{-\beta t_0}^{\beta s}e^{-\mu_\beta u}B(u)\dd u.
\]
The first term tends to zero in modulus because
$K_*(1-1/\beta)>6$. The integral tends to $\mathcal F(\mu_\beta)$
as $t_0,s\to\infty$. Thus its growing coefficient tends to $C_*$.
The complementary propagator has exponent $2\eta<\sigma$;
integrating its ancient exponential forcing and its future polynomial
forcing gives a complementary bound $C e^{2\eta s}$ for $s\ge0$.
For $s\le0$ the whole first coefficient is bounded by $Ce^{\sigma s}$.
Indeed its forcing has ancient rate $\beta\sigma>\sigma$ and
$(\alpha/\varepsilon_q)e^{\sigma t_0}$ is bounded. All bounds are
uniform in $q$.
Expand in $\varepsilon_q$ and $\kappa$ exactly as in
\eqref{smooth-active-app}, replacing $\alpha$ there by $\varepsilon_q$.
In the recursion add $-b_1\cdot\nabla g_{j-1,\ell}$ for $j\ge2$
and add $-b_1\cdot\nabla W_\ell$ for $j=1$. The initial first
coefficient is the one above and the other initial coefficients vanish.
The support and finite angular-sector properties are unchanged. Induction
gives pure-seed bounds $Ce^{j\sigma s}$ and positive-viscosity bounds
$C(1+t)^D e^{j\sigma s}$, uniformly in $t_0$: the first coefficient
has just been estimated, and for $j\ge2$ the external forcing is at
most $C e^{\sigma s}e^{(j-1)\sigma s}$, leaving the same nonresonant
gap $j\sigma-\sigma$. Positive-viscosity resonances produce only the
finite absolute-time polynomial. Consequently the residual estimate
\eqref{smooth-active-residual-bound} holds with
\[
a(t)=\varepsilon_q e^{\sigma(t-t_0)},\qquad
a(0)=q^{6+K_*/\beta}\delta_c^{-1/\beta},\qquad
a(H_q)=\delta_q/|C_*|.
\]
The residual contains no forcing-free term: the exact heat base is
retained, and $b_1\cdot\nabla$ of its heat Taylor remainder has the
seed factor $\varepsilon_q$. Its bound is
$C\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^Da(t)$ by the displayed input estimate.
The prescribed drift is identical in the actual and approximate equations,
so it disappears from the transport part of their Kato comparison. Choose
$M$ using the fixed exponent $C_1$ as before, and choose $N$ with
\[
\frac32(N+1)>(6+K_*/\beta)r_1.
\]
The exact same $X$ error calculation yields $C a^{M+1}$ plus a
viscosity remainder $o(\delta_q)$ at the cap. It is uniform for
$\kappa\le q^{3/2}$. The higher pure-seed terms contribute
$O(\delta_q^2)$ and the positive-viscosity correctors contribute
$O(\kappa(1+H_q)^D\delta_q)$. The complementary first-coefficient
response at $S_q$ is $\varepsilon_q e^{2\eta S_q}=o(\delta_q)$.
Its growing response gives exactly the asserted protected-coordinate
cap. These estimates also give the density bound.
For the whole moment, the integrated self-perturbation velocity is
$O(\delta_q)$ as in \eqref{smooth-active-integrated-drift}.
The additional prescribed drift has integral at most
$C q^6(1+H_q)^5=o(\delta_q)$, by its ancient and future bounds.
The radial exponential Kato tail argument therefore applies unchanged.
All formal coefficients are supported in the fixed collars, and the
leading growing coefficient has moment $b_\epsilon$. The complementary,
nonlinear and viscosity errors estimated above, followed by the Gaussian
tail bound, prove the whole-moment cap. This completes the proof.
\end{proof}
For coupled use of Theorem~\ref{smooth-transfer-prescribed}, the actual
Biot--Savart field must satisfy bounds for the harmonic remainder, core
leakage and feedback. Over a logarithmic stage, a finite
harmonic expansion must be carried to an order whose omitted remainder
beats the comparison exponent. The exterior remainder in
\eqref{smooth-transfer-exterior-remainder} records the spatial estimate;
the time-dependent coupled estimates are additional requirements.
\section{Actual cores, localization and the cold packet}\label{sec:core-cold}
\subsection{Actual viscous outer cores and the local harmonic field}
\label{sec:continuation-outer-core}
This section proves a conditional estimate for the actual coloured
Navier--Stokes evolution. Its nonradial-density hypothesis is explicit;
it is not deduced from material contours or from named unstable coordinates.
We identify $x=(x_1,x_2)$ with $z=x_1+ix_2$ and identify a velocity with
$u_1+iu_2$. Thus
\[
K(z)=\frac{i}{2\pi\bar z},\qquad Jz=iz.
\]
Let $P$ denote circular averaging. For $f\in L^1\cap L^\infty$, splitting
the Biot--Savart integral at distance $d$ and optimizing $d$ gives
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cont-kernel-interpolation}
\norm{K*f}_\infty\le C\sqrt{\norm f_1\norm f_\infty}.
\end{equation}
Indeed the near integral is at most $Cd\norm f_\infty$ and the far
integral is at most $C\norm f_1/d$.
\begin{lemma}[Fourfold growth at the origin]\label{lem:cont-C4-origin}
If $f\in L^1(\R^2)\cap L^\infty(\R^2)$ is invariant under $z\mapsto iz$,
then
\[
|K*f(z)|\le4\norm f_\infty |z|.
\]
The numerical constant is independent of support, mass, scale and
viscosity. Neither zero circulation nor regularity of $f$ is required.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Put $M=\norm f_\infty$ and $r=|z|>0$. Split the convolution into
$|y|\le2r$ and $|y|>2r$. The near contribution is at most
\[
\frac M{2\pi}\int_{|\zeta|\le3r}|\zeta|^{-1}\dd\zeta=3Mr.
\]
The far region is invariant under quarter turns. Averaging its kernel
using the symmetry of $f$ gives the exact identity
\[
\frac14\sum_{k=0}^3\frac1{\bar z-(-i)^k\bar y}
=\frac{\bar z^3}{\bar z^4-\bar y^4}.
\]
For $|y|>2r$ its modulus is at most
$(16/15)r^3|y|^{-4}$. The entire infinite tail satisfies
\[
\int_{|y|>2r}\frac{|f(y)|}{|y|^4}\dd y
\le2\pi M\int_{2r}^\infty s^{-3}\dd s
=\frac{\pi M}{4r^2}.
\]
The far contribution is therefore at most $(2/15)Mr$, and the sum is
at most $(47/15)Mr\le4Mr$. All changes of variables are legitimate:
the original convolution is absolutely convergent by the local
integrability of $|y|^{-1}$ and $f\in L^1\cap L^\infty$.
At $z=0$ the same rotational averaging gives zero directly.
\end{proof}
\begin{lemma}[Exit controlled only by radial drift]
\label{lem:cont-radial-exit}
Let a diffusion satisfy
\[
\dd X_s=v(s,X_s)\dd s+\sqrt{2\nu}\dd B_s,
\qquad X_0=x,
\]
and let $\sigma$ be its first exit from $B_b$, where $|x|0$ set $\phi(y)=\cosh(\lambda|y|)$. Its even power series
shows that it is smooth at zero. In dimension two,
\[
\Delta\phi
=\lambda^2\cosh(\lambda r)+\frac\lambda r\sinh(\lambda r)
\le2\lambda^2\phi,
\qquad v\cdot\nabla\phi\le\lambda V(s)\phi,
\]
using $\sinh a\le a\cosh a$ for $a\ge0$. Therefore It\^o's formula
shows that
\[
e^{-2\nu\lambda^2(s\wedge\sigma)
-\lambda\int_0^{s\wedge\sigma}V(\tau)\dd\tau}
\phi(X_{s\wedge\sigma})
\]
is a nonnegative supermartingale. Stopping at $T$ gives
\[
\mathbb P(\sigma\le T)
\le\frac{\cosh(\lambda|x|)}{\cosh(\lambda b)}
e^{2\nu\lambda^2T+\lambda D}
\le2e^{-\lambda(b-|x|-D)+2\nu\lambda^2T}.
\]
Choose $\lambda=(b-|x|-D)/(4\nu T)$.
The stopped calculation remains valid for bounded drifts smooth for
positive times: stop first before their time endpoint and then pass to
that endpoint. No approximation of a radial drift bound is used.
\end{proof}
Consider real, fourfold symmetric colours solving
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cont-colour-evolution}
\partial_t w_l+u^\nu\cdot\nabla w_l=\nu\Delta w_l,
\qquad u^\nu=K*\sum_l w_l,
\end{equation}
with geometric scales
\[
A_l=A_1\beta^{l-1},\qquad R_l=R_1q^{l-1},
\qquad 1<\beta_{\min}\le\beta\le\beta_{\max},
\qquad q\le\tfrac14,\quad\beta q\le\tfrac12.
\]
Assume
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cont-colour-initial-bounds}
\norm{w_l(0)}_1\le C_0A_lR_l^2,
\qquad\norm{w_l(0)}_\infty\le C_0A_l.
\end{equation}
In the countable case assume that the initial series converges absolutely
in $L^1\cap L^p$, $p>2$, and use its mild Navier--Stokes solution and
the associated linear coloured evolutions. The common velocity is
bounded and smooth for positive times. Norm contraction identifies its
vorticity with the sum of the colours, and
\eqref{eq:cont-kernel-interpolation} implies uniform convergence of the
velocity series because $\sum_lA_lR_l<\infty$.
Fix an index $i$, a window $T=H/A_i$, and
\[
\kappa_i=\frac\nu{A_iR_i^2}.
\]
Suppose that for some fixed $a_0>0$ every $l\le i$ has an initial
constant core,
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cont-initial-core}
w_l(0)=c_l\quad\hbox{on }B_{a_0R_l},
\qquad |c_l|\le C_0A_l.
\end{equation}
Write $h_l=(I-P)w_l$ and impose the actual density hypothesis
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cont-NR}
\sup_{0\le t\le T}\norm{h_l(t)}_1
\le\delta A_lR_l^2\qquad(l\le i),\qquad0<\delta\le1.
\end{equation}
No nonradial hypothesis is imposed on $l>i$.
The scalar stochastic representation used below is
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cont-backward-representation}
w_l(t,x)=\mathbb E[w_l(0,X_t)],\qquad
\dd X_s=-u^\nu(t-s,X_s)\dd s+\sqrt{2\nu}\dd B_s,
\qquad X_0=x.
\end{equation}
Its sign is verified by applying It\^o's formula to $w_l(t-s,X_s)$:
the drift is $-\partial_tw_l-u^\nu\cdot\nabla w_l+\nu\Delta w_l=0$.
For completeness, first stop at $t-\varepsilon$, where the coefficients
are smooth. Boundedness of the drift gives a continuous limiting process
at $t$. Its transition densities away from starting time are bounded by
$C/[\nu s]$. This bound follows by $L^1$ contraction, the Nash inequality
$\norm f_2^4\le C\norm f_1^2\norm{\nabla f}_2^2$, the $L^2$ energy
identity, and the corresponding adjoint estimate, composed at the
midpoint. Thus $w_l(\varepsilon)\to w_l(0)$ in $L^1$ suffices to pass
to the endpoint in expectation. Approximation of the bounded initial
colour in $L^1$ by continuous functions also justifies evaluation at the
limiting endpoint. This verifies \eqref{eq:cont-backward-representation}
for the actual colours without smoothing an asserted radial bound.
\begin{proposition}[Uniform persistence of actual constant cores]
\label{prop:cont-outer-core}
Consider the finite or countable coloured evolution and geometric scales
specified above, with $\nu,H>0$. Assume
\eqref{eq:cont-colour-initial-bounds}, \eqref{eq:cont-initial-core}, and
\eqref{eq:cont-NR} on $[0,T]$, where $T=H/A_i$.
There is $C\ge1$, depending only on $C_0,a_0,\beta_{\min},\beta_{\max}$,
with the following property. Set
\[
\mathcal D=\sqrt\delta+\frac{\delta q^2}{\beta-q^2}
+\frac{\beta q}{1-\beta q},
\qquad c_*:=\frac9{512},
\qquad \varepsilon_*:=\frac{a_0(\beta-1)}{16CH}.
\]
If
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cont-core-margins}
CH\mathcal D\le\frac{a_0}{16},
\qquad
4C_0e^{-c_*a_0^2/(\kappa_iH)}\le\frac{\varepsilon_*}{2},
\end{equation}
then, with $a=a_0/2$, for $l\le i$ and $0l}\norm{K*w_k}_\infty
\le CA_lR_l\frac{\beta q}{1-\beta q}.
\end{equation}
Temporarily assume that all probe-core defects satisfy
\[
\norm{w_k-c_k}_{L^\infty(B_{aR_k})}\le\varepsilon A_k.
\]
For $k0$ such that
\[
\sup_{t\le T}\int_{|x|\ge R_*}|f(t,x)|\,dx
\le Cm\exp\left(-\frac{cR_*^2}{\nu T}\right).
\]
For each fixed integer $k\ge0$ there are constants $c,C_k>0$ such that
\[
\int_{|x|\ge R_*}|x|^k|f(T,x)|\,dx
\le C_km e^{C_kLT}R_*^k
\exp\left(-\frac{cR_*^2}{\nu T}\right),
\]
provided additionally $\sqrt{\nu T}\le cR_*$.
The conclusion holds for smooth drifts and for limits for which the
parabolic solution and the corresponding diffusion representation
are obtained by smooth approximation.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Kato's inequality bounds $|f|$ by the positive scalar solution from
$|f(0)|$. Normalize this initial mass and represent the positive
solution by the diffusion
\[
dX_t=U(t,X_t)\,dt+\sqrt{2\nu}\,dB_t.
\]
A time-dependent rotation removes $\Omega(t)x^\perp$; the rotated
Brownian motion remains standard and all norm assumptions are unchanged.
Let $\sigma$ be the first exit from $B_{R_*}$. Before that exit,
deterministic Gronwall applied to the integral stochastic equation gives
\[
\sup_{s\le t\wedge\sigma}|X_s|
\le e^{C_3R_*^2t+\int_0^t\ell}
\left[r+2C_0\frac m\nu\sqrt{\nu t}
+\sqrt{2\nu}\sup_{s\le t}|B_s|\right].
\]
The stated margins imply that $\sigma\le T$ requires
$\sup_{s\le T}|B_s|\ge cR_*/\sqrt\nu$. The coordinate reflection
bound for planar Brownian motion yields
\[
\mathbb P(\sigma\le T)
\le C\exp\left(-\frac{cR_*^2}{\nu T}\right).
\]
An endpoint outside $B_{R_*}$ requires this exit, proving the mass bound.
For the moment assertion, condition at $\sigma$. The remaining drift
has linear growth bounded by $L|x|$ plus $\norm{V(t)}_\infty$.
Its integrated bounded contribution is at most
$2C_0(m/\nu)\sqrt{\nu T}\le R_*/4$. Gronwall and Brownian moments
therefore give, uniformly in the exit time,
\[
\mathbb E\bigl[|X_T|^k\mid\mathcal F_\sigma\bigr]
\le C_ke^{C_kLT}R_*^k
\quad\hbox{on }\{\sigma\le T\}.
\]
Multiply by the indicator of this event and use its probability bound.
Finally restore the initial mass, which is at most $m$.
\end{proof}
For a receiver with $\kappa_i=\nu/(A_iR_i^2)$ and stage duration
$T=H/A_i$, the choice $R_*=\kappa_i^{1/4}R_i$ gives
\[
\frac{R_*^2}{\nu T}=\frac1{\kappa_i^{1/2}H},\qquad
C_3R_*^2T\le Cx_i\kappa_i^{1/2}H
\quad\hbox{if }C_3\le CA_ix_i/R_i^2.
\]
A global bound $L\le CA_i$ costs only $e^{C_kH}$, independent of
depth. The exponential exit factor dominates that cost as
$\kappa_i\downarrow0$ for logarithmic stage lengths. This parameter
calculation does not verify the required local cubic hypothesis for
the actual foreign field.
\subsection{Nonlinear inner-tail suppression through a receiver window}
\label{sec:resume-tail}
The estimate in this section is conditional on quantitative information
about the actual foreign velocity. It closes a longer-time nonlinear
subproblem than the isolated-tail and first-diffusion-time estimates.
It does not establish the required nonradial-density bound for the active
and older outer colours.
Write $J(x_1,x_2)=(-x_2,x_1)$, $z=x_1+ix_2$, and
\[
K(x)=\frac{Jx}{2\pi|x|^2},\qquad
B_4(f)=\int_{\R^2}\bar z^4 f(z)\,\dd z.
\]
A scalar is fourfold symmetric if $f(Jx)=f(x)$; a vector field has the
corresponding covariance if $b(t,Jx)=Jb(t,x)$.
Constants denoted by $C$ can change from line to line.
\subsubsection{A Gaussian-energy estimate for a globally weak foreign field}
\begin{proposition}[Weak foreign field through a finite window]
\label{prop:resume-gaussian}
There are universal constants $c,\lambda_0,C>0$ with the following
property. Let $p>2$, and let $f_0\in L^1\cap L^p$ be real, fourfold
symmetric, supported in $B_1$, and satisfy
\[
\int f_0=0,\qquad B_4(f_0)=0,\qquad m=\norm{f_0}_1.
\]
Suppose $b$ is divergence free, has fourfold covariance, and, after
removal of a time-dependent solid rotation, satisfies
\[
|b(s,x)|\le \ell(s)|x|,\qquad
|b(s,x)|\le d|x|^3,
\qquad (1+s)\ell(s)\le\lambda_0.
\]
Let $f$ solve
\[
\partial_s f+(K*f+b)\cdot\nabla f=\Delta f.
\]
For $S\ge2$, assume the displayed hypotheses on $0\le s\le S-1$ and
\begin{equation}\label{eq:resume-gaussian-small}
mS^{1/25}\sqrt{1+\log S}\le c.
\end{equation}
Then
\begin{equation}\label{eq:resume-gaussian-B}
\sup_{0\le s\le S-1}|B_4(f(s))|
\le C\left[m^2S^{7/50}(1+\log S)+mdS^{102/25}\right].
\end{equation}
The constants are independent of a decomposition of the datum into
smaller scales. The assertion holds for smooth drifts and for the
parabolic limits obtained by approximation with the stated bounds.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
Scalar contraction and the divergence-free Nash estimate give
\[
\norm{f(s)}_1\le m,\qquad
\norm{f(s)}_\infty\le Cm/s,\qquad
\norm{K*f(s)}_\infty\le Cm/\sqrt{s}.
\]
The last estimate follows by splitting Biot--Savart at a radius and
optimizing. Take $s_0=1/100$. The positive scalar solution from $|f_0|$
dominates $|f|$. Its diffusion representation, after removing solid
rotation, obeys
\[
|X_s|\le e^{\lambda_0s}
\left[1+Cm\sqrt{s}+\sqrt2\sup_{a\le s}|B_a|\right]
\quad(0\le s\le s_0).
\]
The Gaussian exponential moment of the Brownian supremum is finite at
this fixed small time. Define the Gaussian weight parameter by
\[\betaG:=3/10.\]
It follows that
\[
\int e^{\betaG|x|^2/(1+s_0)}|f(s_0,x)|\,\dd x\le Cm.
\]
Multiplication by the Nash $L^\infty$ bound gives a weighted $L^2$ norm
$O(m)$. Fixed polynomial absolute moments are $O(m)$ on $[0,s_0]$.
The exact harmonic-moment equation and symmetrization of self-advection
therefore yield
\begin{equation}\label{eq:resume-initial-B}
|B_4(f(s_0))|\le C(m^2+md).
\end{equation}
For clarity, the self contribution is bounded by
$Cm\int|x|^2|f|$, because
$|\bar z^3-\bar y^3|/|z-y|\le C(|z|^2+|y|^2)$;
the foreign contribution is bounded by $d\int|x|^6|f|$.
These bounds also prove the result directly if the final time is
smaller than $s_0$.
For $s\ge s_0$ put
\[
\tau=\log(1+s),\quad y=x/\sqrt{1+s},\quad
w(\tau,y)=(1+s)f(s,x),\quad
E(\tau,y)=\sqrt{1+s}\,b(s,\sqrt{1+s}\,y).
\]
Then
\[
w_\tau=\mathcal Lw-(K*w+E)\cdot\nabla w,\quad
\mathcal L=\Delta+\tfrac12y\cdot\nabla+1,
\]
with $|E|\le\lambda(\tau)|y|$, $\lambda\le\lambda_0$, and
$|E|\le a(\tau)|y|^3$, where $a(\tau)=de^{2\tau}$.
Let
\[
F_{\betaG}:=\norm{e^{\betaG|y|^2/2}w}_2,
\qquad D_{\betaG}:=\norm{e^{\betaG|y|^2/2}\nabla w}_2^2.
\]
Before using the full Gaussian weight, we establish membership in its
energy space. Put $\tau_0=\log(1+s_0)$ and, for $R\ge1$, set
\[
\Phi_R(t)=\frac{R^2t}{R^2+t},\qquad
\theta_R(t)=\Phi_R'(t)=\frac{R^4}{(R^2+t)^2},\qquad
\rho_R(y)=e^{\betaG\Phi_R(|y|^2)},\qquad
g_R=\rho_R^{1/2}w.
\]
These weights are bounded and smooth, $0\le\theta_R\le1$, and
$\rho_R\uparrow e^{\betaG|y|^2}$. The short-time exponential moment and
Nash bound proved above give
$\int\rho_R w(\tau_0)^2\le Cm^2$, uniformly in $R$.
For each bounded weight, spatial cutoffs and integration by parts give
the exact identity
\[
\langle w,\mathcal Lw\rangle_{\rho_R}
=-\norm{\nabla g_R}_2^2+\tfrac12\norm{g_R}_2^2
-\betaG\int |y|^2\theta_R(|y|^2)
\bigl(\tfrac12-\betaG\theta_R(|y|^2)\bigr)g_R^2\,\dd y.
\]
Here the second derivatives of $\log\rho_R$ cancel after substituting
$w=\rho_R^{-1/2}g_R$. With
$c_{\betaG}=\betaG(1/2-\betaG)>0$, the last term is at most
$-c_{\betaG}\int|y|^2\theta_Rg_R^2$.
The divergence-free advection contributes
\[
\betaG\int(K*w+E)\cdot y\,\theta_Rg_R^2\,\dd y.
\]
For $\tau\ge\tau_0$, the Nash estimate and the similarity change give
$\norm{K*w}_\infty\le C_{s_0}m$. The foreign contribution is at most
$\betaG\lambda_0\int|y|^2\theta_Rg_R^2$, while Young's inequality gives
\[
\betaG\norm{K*w}_\infty\int|y|\theta_Rg_R^2
\le\frac{c_{\betaG}}{4}\int|y|^2\theta_Rg_R^2
+C_{\betaG}\norm{K*w}_\infty^2\norm{g_R}_2^2.
\]
Choose $\lambda_0$ so that $\betaG\lambda_0\le c_{\betaG}/4$.
It follows that, with constants independent of $R$,
\[
\tfrac12\frac{\dd}{\dd\tau}\norm{g_R}_2^2
\le-\norm{\nabla g_R}_2^2
-\frac{c_{\betaG}}{2}\int|y|^2\theta_Rg_R^2
+C(1+m^2)\norm{g_R}_2^2.
\]
Gronwall gives a uniform bound on every fixed finite time interval.
Monotone convergence and weak lower semicontinuity show that $F_{\betaG}$
is finite there, and that $\nabla(e^{\betaG|y|^2/2}w)$ and
$|y|e^{\betaG|y|^2/2}w$ are square integrable in space-time. Thus
$D_{\betaG}$ is locally integrable in time. The transformed equation has
its time derivative in the dual of the space with norm
$\norm g_2+\norm{\nabla g}_2+\norm{|y|g}_2$: the linear drift and
resulting quadratic potential define bounded bilinear forms on that
space. The resulting energy identity supplies the
continuous weighted-$L^2$ representative. Cutoffs in the now integrable
full weight justify the identities and energy inequalities below. This preliminary
argument uses no oscillator gap for the bounded weights.
Writing $g=e^{\betaG|y|^2/2}w$ gives the exact identities
\begin{align*}
\langle w,\mathcal Lw\rangle_{\betaG}
&=\tfrac12\norm g_2^2-\norm{\nabla g}_2^2
-\betaG(1/2-\betaG)\norm{|y|g}_2^2,\\
D_{\betaG}&=\norm{\nabla g}_2^2+\betaG^2\norm{|y|g}_2^2
+2\betaG\norm g_2^2.
\end{align*}
For $a_{\betaG}=\sqrt{\betaG(1/2-\betaG)}$, completing squares in
$\sum_j\norm{\partial_jg+a_{\betaG} y_jg}_2^2$ proves
\[
\mathcal H_{\betaG}:=\norm{\nabla g}_2^2
+\betaG(1/2-\betaG)\norm{|y|g}_2^2
\ge 2a_{\betaG}\norm g_2^2=\frac{\sqrt6}{5}\norm g_2^2.
\]
Moreover $D_{\betaG}\le3\mathcal H_{\betaG}$: one can first bound it by
$\tfrac32\mathcal H_{\betaG}+\tfrac35\norm g_2^2$ and then use the
last inequality. Splitting $\mathcal H_{\betaG}$ into
$\frac3{50}\mathcal H_{\betaG}+\frac{47}{50}\mathcal H_{\betaG}$ yields
\begin{equation}\label{eq:resume-strong-energy}
\langle w,\mathcal Lw\rangle_{\betaG}
\le-\tfrac1{50}D_{\betaG}+\tfrac1{25}F_{\betaG}^2.
\end{equation}
Here $\frac12-\frac{47}{50}\frac{\sqrt6}{5}<\frac1{25}$.
The Hardy--Littlewood--Sobolev estimate and Gaussian weighted H\"older give
\[
\norm{K*w}_4\le C\norm w_{4/3}\le C_{\betaG} F_{\betaG}.
\]
The two-dimensional Gagliardo--Nirenberg inequality gives
\[
\norm g_4\le C\norm g_2^{1/2}\norm{\nabla g}_2^{1/2}.
\]
Since $\norm{|y|g}_2+\norm{\nabla g}_2\le C_{\betaG}\sqrt{D_{\betaG}}$,
self-advection contributes at most
\[
C F_{\betaG}^{3/2}D_{\betaG}^{3/4}
\le C_{\betaG} F_{\betaG} D_{\betaG}
\]
to the weighted energy. The foreign contribution is
$\betaG\int E\cdot y\,e^{\betaG|y|^2}w^2$, bounded by
$C_{\betaG}\lambda D_{\betaG}$. Thus, while $F_{\betaG}$ is sufficiently small,
\[
\tfrac12(F_{\betaG}^2)'\le-\tfrac1{100}D_{\betaG}
+\tfrac1{25}F_{\betaG}^2.
\]
The initial weighted norm and a continuity bootstrap using
\eqref{eq:resume-gaussian-small} prove
\begin{equation}\label{eq:resume-FD}
F_{\betaG}(\tau)\le Cme^{\tau/25},\qquad
\int_{\log(1+s_0)}^{\log S}D_{\betaG}(\tau)\,\dd\tau
\le Cm^2S^{2/25}.
\end{equation}
Let $P$ be angular averaging, $G=Pw$, and $h=(I-P)w$.
Every ordinary moment of $h$ of degree at most three vanishes:
angular averaging removes radial moments, and fourfold symmetry removes
all other moments in these degrees. In
\[
X=L^2(e^{|y|^2/4}\,\dd y),\qquad H=\norm h_X,
\qquad D_h=\norm{\nabla h}_X^2,
\]
one consequently has
\begin{equation}\label{eq:resume-Qthree-gap}
D_h\ge3H^2.
\end{equation}
Indeed $\mathcal L$ is self-adjoint in $X$, and its Hermite basis is
$\partial^\alpha\mathcal G$, with
$\mathcal G=(4\pi)^{-1}e^{-|y|^2/4}$ and eigenvalue $-|\alpha|/2$.
Orthogonality to degrees at most three is equivalent to the stated
ordinary-moment cancellations, because the corresponding dual Hermite
polynomials span these polynomial degrees. Expansion in this basis gives
$\langle h,\mathcal Lh\rangle_X\le-2H^2$; since the left side is
$-D_h+H^2$, \eqref{eq:resume-Qthree-gap} follows. This elementary
Hermite expansion also follows from the tensor one-dimensional
harmonic-oscillator factorization.
Angular averaging is orthogonal for all the radial weights used here,
and commutes with $\mathcal L$. Writing $V_a=K*a$, the angular equation is
\[
h_\tau=\mathcal Lh-(I-P)\operatorname{div}
[V_Gh+V_hG+V_hh+EG+Eh].
\]
The radial field $V_G$ is tangential, so its weighted energy contribution
is zero. The $h$--$h$ and $E$--$h$ contributions are bounded by
$CHD_h$ and $C\lambda D_h$. Put
$D_G=\norm{\nabla G}_X^2\le D_{\betaG}$.
Weighted integration by parts, unweighted HLS, and GN give
\[
|\langle h,-\operatorname{div}(V_hG)\rangle_X|
\le CH F_{\betaG}^{1/2}D_G^{1/4}D_h^{1/2}
\le\eta D_h+C_\eta H^2F_{\betaG} D_G^{1/2}.
\]
The strict Gaussian margin $\betaG-1/4=1/20$ absorbs cubic multiplication:
\[
\norm{e^{|y|^2/8}EG}_2\le Ca(\tau)F_{\betaG}.
\]
Consequently the $E$--$G$ contribution is bounded by
$\eta D_h+C_\eta a(\tau)^2F_{\betaG}^2$.
Take $\eta$ and the bootstrap constants sufficiently small. Using
\eqref{eq:resume-Qthree-gap} yields
\[
(H^2)'\le-\tfrac{19}{5}H^2
+CF_{\betaG} D_G^{1/2}H^2+Ca(\tau)^2F_{\betaG}^2.
\]
By \eqref{eq:resume-FD} and Cauchy--Schwarz,
\[
\int F_{\betaG} D_G^{1/2}\,\dd\tau
\le Cm^2S^{2/25}\sqrt{1+\log S}\le Cc^2.
\]
Variation of constants therefore gives
\begin{equation}\label{eq:resume-h-decay}
H(\tau)\le Cm\left[e^{-19\tau/10}
+de^{51\tau/25}\right].
\end{equation}
Factors depending on the fixed initial time are absorbed in $C$.
Finally $B_4(f(s))=e^{2\tau}B_4(w(\tau))$.
Harmonicity cancels diffusion, and differentiating $e^{2\tau}$ cancels
the dilation term. Radial self-advection vanishes. HLS and Gaussian
weighted H\"older show that
\[
\left|\frac{\dd}{\dd\tau}B_4(f(e^\tau-1))\right|
\le Ce^{2\tau}[F_{\betaG} H+a(\tau)F_{\betaG}].
\]
Substitution of \eqref{eq:resume-FD} and \eqref{eq:resume-h-decay}, followed
by integration, gives a first term
$Cm^2S^{1/25+1/10}(1+\log S)$ and remaining terms at most
$CmdS^{102/25}$, using $m\le1$. Together with
\eqref{eq:resume-initial-B}, this proves the proposition.
The bounded-weight argument and the subsequent uniform estimates also
justify passage from smooth data and drifts to the stated parabolic
limits. No initial $L^\infty$ norm enters a constant.
\end{proof}
\subsubsection{Comparison with the actual local foreign field}
\begin{proposition}[Local harmonic field and a rough small leak]
\label{prop:resume-local-transfer}
Let $\nu,r,T,R_*>0$, $R_*\ge4r$, and $p>2$. Let
$f_0\in L^1\cap L^p$ be real, fourfold symmetric, supported in $B_r$,
and satisfy $\int f_0=0$ and $B_4(f_0)=0$. Put
$M=\norm{f_0}_1$, and let $f$ solve on $[0,T]$
\[
f_t+(K*f+b)\cdot\nabla f=\nu\Delta f.
\]
After removal of a solid rotation, suppose $b$ is divergence free,
has fourfold covariance, and admits, on $B_{2R_*}$, the decomposition
\begin{equation}\label{eq:resume-harm-core}
\begin{aligned}
b&=b_{\rm h}+e,& |b(t,x)|&\le L|x|\quad\hbox{globally},\\
|b_{\rm h}(t,x)|&\le C_3|x|^3,&
|Db_{\rm h}(t,x)|&\le C_3|x|^2,\\
|e(t,x)|&\le\epsilon L|x|.
\end{aligned}
\end{equation}
where $b_{\rm h}$ is divergence free with fourfold covariance and
$0\le\epsilon\le1$. All bounds hold on $0\le t\le T$.
Its streamfunction is defined on $B_{2R_*}$.
Assume
\begin{equation}\label{eq:resume-exit-margins}
C_3R_*^2T+\epsilon LT\le\tfrac14,\qquad
C(M/\nu)\sqrt{\nu T}\le R_*/8,\qquad
\sqrt{\nu T}\le cR_*.
\end{equation}
Take a fixed radial cutoff of that streamfunction, equal to one in
$B_{R_*}$ and zero outside $B_{2R_*}$, and denote its velocity by
$\widetilde b$. Let $g$ solve the same self-consistent equation as $f$,
with foreign field $\widetilde b$ and the same initial datum. Set
$\ell=C C_3R_*^2$. If $M/\nu$ and
$\ell(r^2/\nu+T)$ are sufficiently small, then
\begin{align}
\sup_{t\le T}|B_4(f(t))-B_4(g(t))|
&\le CM R_*^4e^{CLT}\Bigl[
\epsilon L\bigl(T+r\sqrt{T/\nu}\bigr)\nonumber\\
&\hspace{35mm}
+(1+LR_*\sqrt{T/\nu})e^{-cR_*^2/(\nu T)}\Bigr].
\label{eq:resume-B-transfer}
\end{align}
No derivative bound on the leak $e$ is required.
The assertion holds for smooth drifts and for parabolic limits obtained
by approximation with the stated bounds.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
Choose the streamfunction $\psi_{\rm h}$ zero at the origin.
Integration along radial segments gives
$|\psi_{\rm h}(x)|\le CC_3|x|^4$. A streamfunction cutoff gives
\[
|\widetilde b|\le CC_3|x|^3,\qquad
|\widetilde b|\le\ell|x|,\qquad
\norm{D\widetilde b}_\infty\le\ell.
\]
It is divergence free, has fourfold covariance, and equals $b_{\rm h}$
in $B_{R_*}$. A second useful bound is
$|\widetilde b(x)|\le CL|x|$: from $\epsilon\le1$ and
\eqref{eq:resume-harm-core}, $|b_{\rm h}|\le2L|x|$ on $B_{2R_*}$,
so $|\psi_{\rm h}|\le CL|x|^2$ there, and cutoff derivatives preserve
this linear growth. Thus this bound does not require $C_3R_*^2\le L$.
We first verify the velocity-gradient estimate needed for comparison.
Normalize $r=\nu=1$ and write $m=M/\nu$; the cutoff growth and Lipschitz
constant are normalized in the same way. Nash gives
\[
\norm{g(t)}_\infty\le Cm/t,\qquad
\norm{u_g(t)}_\infty\le Cm/\sqrt t,\qquad u_g=K*g.
\]
For $M_k(t)=\int|x|^k|g(t,x)|\,\dd x$, Kato's inequality gives
\begin{align*}
M_2'&\le4m+Cm t^{-1/2}\sqrt{mM_2}+2\ell M_2,\\
M_4'&\le16M_2+Cm t^{-1/2}m^{1/4}M_4^{3/4}+4\ell M_4.
\end{align*}
Since $M_2(0),M_4(0)\le m$, a continuity bootstrap gives
\[
M_2(t)\le Cm(1+t),\qquad M_4(t)\le Cm(1+t)^2
\]
when $m$ and $\ell(1+T)$ are small. On these trial bounds the integrated
self terms are respectively $O(m^2(1+t))$ and $O(m^2(1+t)^2)$;
$\ell T\ll1$ absorbs the foreign terms. Hence
\[
\norm{xg(t)}_1\le Cm\sqrt{1+t},\qquad
\norm{xg(t)}_4\le Cm t^{-3/4}\sqrt{1+t}.
\]
The second follows from $\norm{xg}_4^4\le\norm g_\infty^3 M_4$.
With $H_t$ the heat kernel, scaling and the smooth kernels' exterior
decay give
\begin{align*}
\norm{\nabla K*H_t}_\infty&\le Ct^{-1},\\
\norm{\nabla K*\operatorname{div}H_t}_\infty&\le Ct^{-3/2},\quad
\norm{\nabla K*\operatorname{div}H_t}_1\le Ct^{-1/2},\quad
\norm{\nabla K*\operatorname{div}H_t}_{4/3}\le Ct^{-3/4}.
\end{align*}
For the nonlinear differentiated kernel the tail is $O(|x|^{-3})$,
so the last three norms are finite before scaling. The self flux $u_gg$
has $L^1$ norm $Cm^2t^{-1/2}$ and $L^\infty$ norm $Cm^2t^{-3/2}$.
Split the heat-mild time integral at $t/2$, using the kernel's
$L^\infty$ norm first and its $L^1$ norm second; its contribution to
$\nabla u_g$ is $Cm^2/t$. The foreign flux has $L^1$ norm
$C\ell m\sqrt{1+t}$ and $L^4$ norm
$C\ell mt^{-3/4}\sqrt{1+t}$. Use the kernel's $L^\infty$ norm first
and its $L^{4/3}$ norm second. This contribution is
\[
C\ell m t^{-1/2}\sqrt{1+t}\le Cm/t,
\]
because $\ell(1+T)$ is small. The initial heat contribution is $Cm/t$.
Undoing normalization proves
\begin{equation}\label{eq:resume-gradient-comparison}
\norm{\nabla u_g(t)}_\infty\le C(M/\nu)/t.
\end{equation}
Put $\delta=f-g$, $v=K*\delta$, and $F=(b-\widetilde b)f$. Then
\[
\delta_t-\nu\Delta\delta
+(u_f+\widetilde b)\cdot\nabla\delta
+v\cdot\nabla g=-\operatorname{div}F.
\]
Let $\psi$ be a streamfunction of $\delta$. Testing in $H^{-1}$ gives
\begin{equation}\label{eq:resume-Hminus-energy}
\tfrac12(\norm v_2^2)'+\nu\norm\delta_2^2
\le (\norm{\nabla u_g}_\infty+
\norm{D\widetilde b}_\infty)\norm v_2^2
+\norm v_2\norm F_2.
\end{equation}
Here $v\cdot\nabla\psi=0$. Thus the term $v\cdot\nabla g$ vanishes
when paired with $\psi$, and the same identity replaces $u_f=u_g+v$
by $u_g$ in the other self transport term. Integration by parts bounds
that term by $\norm{\nabla u_g}_\infty\norm v_2^2$. The identical
calculation applies to $\widetilde b$.
The circulation of $\delta$ is zero, and its polynomial moments are
finite, so $v\in L^2$ and these tests are justified by approximation.
Both solutions converge to their common datum in $L^1\cap L^p$ as
$t\downarrow0$. Interpolation, using $p>2$, therefore gives
$\norm{\delta(t)}_2\to0$. Their first absolute moments are uniformly
bounded near zero by the Kato moment estimates and the linear-growth
bounds. Since $\int\delta=0$,
\[
|\widehat\delta(t,\xi)|
\le |\xi|\int|x|\,|\delta(t,x)|\,\dd x.
\]
In the Fourier identity
$\norm v_2^2=C\int|\xi|^{-2}|\widehat\delta(t,\xi)|^2\,\dd\xi$,
the part with $|\xi|2$, gives from the same mild
formula
\[
\norm{\nabla u_g(t)}_\infty
\le C_0(t^{-1/p}+t^{1/2-1/p}),\qquad 00$, assume
$0<\delta\le1$ and $1\le H\le C_H\log(1/q)$, and take a receiver
$(A_i,R_i)$ with
\[
r=qR_i,\quad M\le C\beta A_iq^2R_i^2,\quad
\kappa=\frac{\nu}{A_iR_i^2}=q^{3/2},\quad
T=H/A_i,\quad R_*=\kappa^{1/4}R_i.
\]
Suppose the actual outer-colour estimates furnish
\[
L\le CA_i,\qquad C_3\le C\delta A_i/R_i^2,\qquad
\epsilon\le Ce^{-c/(\kappa H)}.
\]
Then $m=O(\beta q^{1/2})$, $d=O(\delta q^{5/2})$, and
$S=O(q^{-1/2}H)$. Dividing the first line of
\eqref{eq:resume-full-tail-bound} by $A_iR_i^6$ gives
\begin{equation}\label{eq:resume-tail-budget}
O\!\left(\beta^2q^{643/100}H^{7/50}(1+\log S)
+\beta\delta q^{323/50}H^{102/25}\right).
\end{equation}
The powers are $6.43$ and $6.46$. The localization terms are smaller than
every $q$-power for logarithmic $H$, since
\[
\frac{R_*^2}{\nu T}=\frac1{\sqrt\kappa H},\qquad
LT=O(H),\qquad C_3R_*^2T=O(\delta\sqrt\kappa H).
\]
The remaining tail margins follow from
\begin{align*}
\ell(r^2/\nu+T)&=O\!\left(\delta[q^{5/4}+q^{3/4}H]\right),\\
\frac{(M/\nu)\sqrt{\nu T}}{R_*}
&=O(\beta q^{7/8}\sqrt H),\qquad
\frac{\sqrt{\nu T}}{R_*}=q^{3/8}\sqrt H,\\
mS^{1/25}\sqrt{1+\log S}
&=O\!\left(\beta q^{12/25}H^{1/25}\sqrt{1+\log S}\right).
\end{align*}
Also $r/R_*=q^{5/8}$ and
$\epsilon LT=O(He^{-c/(q^{3/2}H)})$. All these quantities tend to zero
uniformly in the stated horizon range. Writing $L_q=\log(1/q)$, the
two terms of \eqref{eq:resume-tail-budget} are bounded by
\[
C\beta^2q^{643/100}L_q^{57/50}
+C\beta\delta q^{323/50}L_q^{102/25}=o(q^6),
\]
uniformly for $0<\delta\le1$ and $1\le H\le C_HL_q$.
A fixed prefactor in the support radius changes only the constants.
The actual outer-core argument supplies the required harmonic-plus-leak
hypothesis conditionally on the density bound
\[
\sup_{t\le T}\norm{(I-P)w_l(t)}_1
\le\delta A_lR_l^2,\qquad l\le i.
\]
Its harmonic exterior multipole series can be differentiated to give
$|Db_{\rm h}(x)|\le CC_3|x|^2$ throughout $B_{2R_*}$ when this disk lies
strictly inside the constant-core probe region; the exponentially small
core density defect contributes the rough leak. When these inputs are
obtained from Proposition~\ref{prop:cont-outer-core}, its core margins
\eqref{eq:cont-core-margins} must also hold. Thus the present section
closes full-window nonlinear inner-tail suppression under this explicit
outer-density input. It does not prove that input for the active colour
and older seeds, a signed outward transfer, or distinct vanishing-viscosity
accumulation paths.
The zero initial fourth moment used here is the one of the prescribed
initial inner stack: termwise integration is justified by
$\sum_l A_lR_l^6<\infty$. A restart from a later state retains its
actual fourth moment. If only $B_4(f_0)=0$ is dropped while all other
hypotheses of Proposition~\ref{prop:resume-gaussian} remain in force,
the same proof adds $|B_4(f_0)|$ to
\eqref{eq:resume-gaussian-B}. A noncompact restarted state additionally
requires a separate Gaussian-space entry estimate.
\begin{remark}[Selected-cutoff scope]
The displayed $q^{6.43}$ and $q^{6.46}$ budget uses
$\kappa_i=q^{3/2}$ at the selected cutoff level. At later, larger
receivers the same physical viscosity has a smaller normalized value;
their aggregate of smaller colours includes the intended active child.
The budget is not an erasure estimate for that entire aggregate at every
later stage. After a source leaves its small cap neighbourhood, its
constant-core probe on a canonical source window requires a separate
comparison; it is not a consequence of the small-density hypothesis
over that post-cap window.
\end{remark}
\section{The actual inactive prefix}\label{sec:inactive}
\subsection{Fixed seeds: separate initial and forced prefix contributions}
The following scalar comparison separates the common initial seeds from the
forced response. Its coupling inequality is a hypothesis.
\begin{lemma}[Two prefix norms]\label{ph:two-norms}
Let $\beta\ge4$, $00$, $\eta,r_*>0$, $f_i\ge0$ are integrable, and the
nonnegative matrix $K$ obeys
\[
K_{ii}\le Cr_*/\beta,\qquad
K_{il}\le
\begin{cases}
C\beta^{l-j}q^{2(i-l)},&l\beta$ with $Dq^8<\beta$, put $w_i=(Dq^6)^{j-i}$ and
\[
r_P=\frac C\beta\left(r_*+
\frac{\beta}{D-\beta}+
\frac{Dq^8}{\beta-Dq^8}\right),\qquad
\lambda_P=\lambda_0+Mr_P.
\]
The forced contribution satisfies
\begin{equation}\label{ph:P}
P(\theta):=\max_{i6$. Then
$B\le M\delta_*q^{C_0(\sigma-\lambda_*)}=O(q^6)$, and its
receiving-field row adds a factor $O(q^2)$. If $Dq^6<1$, the local chart bound follows from
$x_i\le B+w_iP\le B+Dq^6P$ whenever the latter quantity is below $r_*$.
\end{proof}
For the coloured Navier--Stokes evolution, the spatial $q^2$ and $q^6$
rows and the forced term must be estimated separately; see
Proposition~\ref{prop:inactive-actual-row} and
Section~\ref{sec:next-packet-force}.
\begin{remark}[A generic smooth-profile self rate]
The same positive-matrix proof works with $\lambda_0=\gamma/\beta$
for any fixed $\gamma>0$. Choose $\beta>4\gamma/\sigma$, then choose
the foreign-row parameters so $Mr_B$ and $Mr_P$ are less than
$\sigma/4-\gamma/\beta$. For a differential inequality whose diagonal
rate is at most $\gamma\beta^{i-j}$, use $\gamma/\beta$ as its common
upper bound. Thus a fixed-profile Kato rate can be used independently of the unstable
eigenvalue.
The transform selection in Lemma~\ref{smooth-transfer-transform} permits
choosing a good $\beta$ in any fixed sufficiently large interval, so
this parameter change causes no conflict with the isolated source
transform.
\end{remark}
\subsection{Actual inactive densities and a large amplitude ratio}
\label{sec:inactive-density}
Fix the smooth radial reference $W$ and $p>2$. The inactive comparison
uses the actual coloured Navier--Stokes equation without differentiating
an inactive colour. Its fixed-profile transport-stability rate is made
small in the receiver clock by choosing the amplitude ratio sufficiently
large. The first two closure corollaries assume an explicit packet bound;
Section~\ref{sec:next-packet-force} derives a bound from the actual packet.
Let $P$ denote angular averaging. Use
\[
\begin{aligned}
A_l&=A_1\beta^{l-1},&R_l&=R_1q^{l-1},\\
G_l(t,x)&=A_l\left[e^{\nu tR_l^{-2}\Delta}W\right](x/R_l),&&\\
\zeta_l&=w_l-G_l,&h_l&=(I-P)w_l=(I-P)\zeta_l.
\end{aligned}
\]
For any density $v$ put
\[
\norm v_{X_l}=\frac{\norm v_1}{A_lR_l^2}
+\frac{\norm v_p}{A_lR_l^{2/p}},
\qquad x_l(t)=\norm{\zeta_l(t)}_{X_l}.
\]
Assume the initial colours are real, fourfold symmetric, have zero
circulation, are supported in $B_{c_0R_l}$, equal a constant in
$B_{a_0R_l}$, and satisfy
\[
\norm{w_l(0)}_1\le C_0A_lR_l^2,\qquad
\norm{w_l(0)}_\infty\le C_0A_l.
\]
Here $a_0,c_0,C_0$ are fixed. For the smooth seeded family these facts
follow from the fixed compact derivative collars. The series of colours
is absolutely convergent in $L^1\cap L^p$, and $\beta q<1$, so its common
velocity and coloured evolution are well defined as before.
Choose a fixed dimensionless annulus $\mathcal A$ and $d_*>0$ such that
\[
\operatorname{dist}(\operatorname{supp}\nabla W,
\R^2\setminus\mathcal A)\ge d_*.
\]
Set $\mathcal A_l=R_l\mathcal A$. Choose $q$ afterwards so that these
annuli lie inside the older constant-core probes and are separated from
the small receiver truncation balls used below.
\begin{proposition}[Stopped inactive row with explicit parabolic errors]
\label{prop:inactive-actual-row}
There are constants $\gamma,C,c>0$, depending only on the fixed smooth
profile, $p$, and the displayed initial prefactors, with the following
property. Fix $j\ge2$ and
\[
T\le S/A_j,\qquad
\kappa_j=\frac{\nu}{A_jR_j^2}\le q^{3/2},\qquad
1\le S\le C_1\log(1/q).
\]
Stop at the first time any $ik}\beta^{-r}e_r
+\sum_{1\le rl$ use
$\norm{K*w_k}_\infty\le CA_kR_k$ and
$\sum_{k>l}A_kR_k\le CA_lR_l\beta q$.
The same estimate holds for only the foreign radial field.
The constants in these sums are uniform for $\beta\ge4$ and
$\beta q\le1/2$.
Apply the actual outer-core bootstrap to the stopped finite prefix
$l\le j-1$. Its nonradial-density hypothesis follows from
$\norm{h_l}_1\le2A_lR_l^2x_l\le2\delta A_lR_l^2$.
All colours $k\ge j$ enter that bootstrap through the unrestricted,
convergent velocity sum $\sum_{k>l}A_kR_k$.
The parameter margin \eqref{eq:inactive-radial-margin} and small $q$
therefore give the individual core estimate
\begin{equation}\label{eq:inactive-individual-core}
\norm{w_l(t)-c_l}_{L^\infty(B_{aR_l})}
\le CA_l e^{-cR_l^2/(\nu t)},\qquad a=a_0/2.
\end{equation}
The bootstrap error threshold is of order $S^{-1}$; its improvement follows
from $\kappa_jS\ll1$ just as in the outer-core proof. Retaining the
individual radius in that proof, rather than its maximum over $l$, gives
\eqref{eq:inactive-individual-core}.
Fix $c_2>c_0$. On $B_{c_2R_l}$ the own nonradial velocity is bounded by
$C\sqrt\delta A_lR_l$. Older constant cores contribute only rotation;
their harmonic remainders contribute $C\delta A_lR_lq^2/\beta$ and their
core leaks are exponentially small. All inner velocities contribute at
most $CA_lR_l\beta q$. Choose $q$ so that this ball is strictly inside
every older core probe disk. By \eqref{eq:inactive-radial-margin}, the
integrated radial drift is less than a fixed fraction of
$(c_2-c_0)R_l$. The radial exit estimate for the positive scalar evolution
from $|w_l(0)|$ gives
\begin{equation}\label{eq:inactive-source-exit}
\int_{|x|>c_2R_l}|w_l(t,x)|\,\dd x
\le CA_lR_l^2e^{-cR_l^2/(\nu t)}.
\end{equation}
For its post-exit fourth moment use
$\phi(x)=(R_l^2+|x|^2)^2$.
Equation \eqref{eq:inactive-global-radial} gives
$u\cdot\nabla\phi\le CA_l\phi$, while
$\nu\Delta\phi\le C\nu R_l^{-2}\phi$.
Conditioning at exit from $B_{c_2R_l}$ consequently gives
$\mathbb E[\phi(X_t)\mid\mathcal F_{\rm exit}]
\le CR_l^4e^{C(A_l+\nu/R_l^2)T}\le CR_l^4e^{CS}$.
Multiplication by the exit probability proves
\begin{equation}\label{eq:inactive-source-moment-exit}
\int_{|x|>c_2R_l}|x|^4|w_l(t,x)|\,\dd x
\le CA_lR_l^6e^{CS}e^{-cR_l^2/(\nu t)}.
\end{equation}
Angular averaging preserves radial integrals. Inside $B_{c_2R_l}$ use
$\norm{h_l}_1\le2A_lR_l^2x_l$; outside use
\eqref{eq:inactive-source-moment-exit}. It follows that
\begin{equation}\label{eq:inactive-h-moment}
\int|x|^4|h_l(t,x)|\,\dd x
\le CA_lR_l^6[x_l(t)+e_{j-l}].
\end{equation}
For an inner colour $i0$ such that
$B_{\eta R_i}$ is inside the initial constant disk of colour $i$ and
$c_0q<\eta/4$. In this ball the radial velocity estimate based on index
$i$ has the same small integrated bound: the own nonradial term is
$C\sqrt\delta A_iR_i$, older remainders are controlled by
\eqref{eq:inactive-individual-core}, and all inner colours enter by
$CA_iR_i\beta q$. Starting the $l$th positive colour in $B_{c_0R_l}$,
radial exit from $B_{\eta R_i}$ therefore gives
\begin{equation}\label{eq:inactive-receiver-exit}
\int_{|x|>\eta R_i}|w_l(t,x)|\,\dd x
\le CA_lR_l^2e^{-cR_i^2/(\nu t)}.
\end{equation}
This receiver-radius estimate is essential.
On $\mathcal A_i$, for $l0$ be the growth rate of the fixed smooth reference.
Choose $\beta$ sufficiently large that $\gamma/\beta<\sigma/4$,
then a fixed $D>\beta$ sufficiently large, then $q$ sufficiently small.
Set $w_i=(Dq^6)^{j-i}$ and $b=\delta e^{-\sigma S}$.
Assume $x_i(0)\le Mb$, and the packet-history bound
\begin{equation}\label{eq:inactive-packet-input}
\sup_{\theta\le A_jT}\int_0^\theta e^{\lambda_P(\theta-s)}
\max_{i0$ and choose the cap so that
\begin{equation}\label{eq:inactive-cap-scale}
q^{L_\delta}\le\delta(q)\le1,\qquad
CS(\sqrt{\delta(q)}+\beta q)\le c.
\end{equation}
All constants and exponents are fixed before $q$ is decreased.
Then the stopped solution remains strictly below its stopping threshold:
\[
x_i(t)\le B+w_i\left[CC_*\delta+o(q^K)\right]<\delta/4,
\qquad B\le M\delta e^{-(\sigma-\lambda_B)S},
\]
for every $i0.
\]
Choose $L>L_\delta+6$. Then \eqref{eq:inactive-cap-scale} gives
\[
\frac{H_G(q)}{\delta(q)q^6}
\le\frac{o(q^L)}{q^{L_\delta+6}}\longrightarrow0.
\]
Thus the error is $o(\delta q^6)$ in the forced weighted norm.
Under the alternative \eqref{eq:inactive-relative-error}, this relative
bound holds directly.
The positive-matrix variation of constants and
\eqref{eq:inactive-packet-input} yield the asserted bound.
Choose $C_2$ so $C_2(\sigma-\lambda_B)>6$; then $B\ll\delta q^6$.
Finally $\max_{i6/\sigma$. Choose $\beta,D$, and then $q$, so that
\[
C_2(\sigma-\lambda_B)>6,\qquad C_2\lambda_P<1.
\]
With $S=C_2\log(1/q)$ and the cap condition
\eqref{eq:inactive-cap-scale}, or the alternative relative condition
\eqref{eq:inactive-relative-error} together with the radial margin, the
actual inactive densities remain below $\delta/4$. Their normalized
inward nonradial velocity on the current
receiver's fixed collars is
\[
O\!\left(\delta S q^{8-C_2\lambda_P}\right)+o(\delta q^6)
=o(\delta q^6).
\]
The static packet bound is an explicit input. The packet estimate in
Section~\ref{sec:next-packet-force} closes the inactive stop directly,
without requiring this static input to be $O(\delta)$.
\end{corollary}
\begin{proof}
The stated parameter choices are possible since $\lambda_B,\lambda_P$
can be made arbitrarily small by taking the fixed $\beta,D$ large and
then $q$ small. The packet contribution to the forced weighted norm is
at most $CC_*\delta S e^{\lambda_PS}$. Thus
\[
x_i\le B+(Dq^6)^{j-i}
\left[CC_*\delta S q^{-C_2\lambda_P}+o(q^K)\right].
\]
The baseline $B=o(\delta q^6)$ and the nearest forced bound
$C\delta S q^{6-C_2\lambda_P}$ are both below the stopping threshold.
The parabolic errors are $o(\delta q^6)$ in the forced weighted norm
by the preceding relative-error calculation, so they are below the
stopping threshold as well.
For the inward field use the actual older-core multipole estimate:
\[
\sum_{i0$.
The initial support bounds $Y(0)$ by $C_nR_j$, proving the claim.
To justify the moment calculation without assuming moments in advance,
start with a finite truncation of the positive initial aggregate. The
common velocity is bounded on the physical window, so its positive
diffusion representation gives finite moments. Apply the displayed
uniform calculation and pass monotonically to the full positive datum.
Equivalently one may use truncated radial weights. The constants in the
refined estimate use only $L,V$ above, not the crude global drift bound.
\end{proof}
\begin{proposition}[Actual force on a stopped inactive prefix]
\label{prop:next-packet-force}
Under the stopped hypotheses and parameter margins of
Proposition~\ref{prop:inactive-actual-row}, set
\[
\mathcal M(S)=(1+S+\sqrt{\kappa_jS})^4 e^{C_4S/\beta}.
\]
For every $i1$,
\[
\sup_{\theta\le A_jT}\max_{i0$ so that $B_{\eta R_i}$ is inside the constant
core probe of colour $i$, and is separated from $\mathcal A_i$.
On this ball the own radial field is bounded by
$C\sqrt\delta A_iR_i$, the older fields by their actual core/harmonic
bounds, and all inner fields by $CA_iR_i\beta q$.
The stop and its radial margin therefore give a displacement strictly
smaller than $\eta R_i/2$ up to $T$.
Every positive packet constituent starts in $B_{c_0R_j}\subset
B_{\eta R_i/4}$. The radial exit estimate consequently gives
\[
\int_{|x|>\eta R_i}P_j(t,x)\dd x
\le CA_jR_j^2 e^{-cR_i^2/(\nu t)}.
\]
This estimate uses the unrestricted convergent inner velocity sum, not a
small-density assumption on the packet.
Radial truncation of $h_{\ge j}$ has zero circulation and vanishing
harmonic moments of degrees one to three. Its field on $\mathcal A_i$
is therefore bounded by $CR_i^{-5}\int|x|^4|h_{\ge j}|$.
For the exterior leakage use the last exit estimate and the $L^p$
contraction of $P_j$. The elementary kernel split gives, for $p>2$,
\[
\norm{K*f}_\infty
\le C_p\norm f_1^{\frac{p-2}{2(p-1)}}
\norm f_p^{\frac{p}{2(p-1)}}.
\]
Indeed the near integral is at most
$C_p d^{1-2/p}\norm f_p$, and the far integral at most
$C\norm f_1/d$; optimize $d$.
Angular averaging preserves radial tail masses and contracts $L^p$.
Thus the leaked nonradial packet has velocity at most
$CA_jR_j e^{-c_pR_i^2/(\nu t)}$.
Combining this with the fourth moment and the uniform scaled heat-gradient
bound on $G_i$ proves \eqref{eq:next-packet-force}: the force normalization
is velocity divided by $A_jR_i$.
After division by $w_i$, the first term is at most
$CD^{-k}\mathcal M(S)$. The second is at most
\[
CD^{-k}q^{-5k}e^{-c_pq^{-2k}/(\kappa_jS)}.
\]
For small $q$ successive such terms decrease, and the first is smaller
than every $q$-power because $\kappa_jS\le q^{3/2}C\log(1/q)$.
This proves the weighted assertion.
\end{proof}
\begin{corollary}[Unconditional stopped inactive closure]
\label{cor:next-inactive-closed}
Fix $K>6$ and any fixed $C_2>6/\sigma$.
Suppose $x_i(0)\le Mq^K$ for every $i0$ once $q$ is small,
so its error is also $o(\delta q^6)$. Since $\kappa_jS\ll1$, this proves
\eqref{eq:next-inactive-conclusion}. Write $a=C_2(\lambda_P+C_4/\beta)<1$. The nearest forced
density is bounded by $CDq^{6-a}S(1+S)^4$, and the initial
term has exponent $K-C_2\lambda_B>6$. Their sum and the Gaussian
error are $o(\delta)$, giving the strict $\delta/4$ improvement. The radial margin holds since
$S\sqrt\delta=O((\log(1/q))^{-1})$ and $S\beta q\to0$.
A first stopping time is thus impossible. Finally sum the actual older
core harmonic row
$\sum_{ij}(A_l/A_j)(R_l/R_j)\le C\beta q$ by the individual colour
contractions. Multiplication by the bounded $\nabla T_{\rm adj}$ gives their term.
On $|y|\le a/(2q)$, the actual older harmonic/core-leak decomposition,
with the rigid rotation removed, gives
\[
|b_{0$. Suppose $R\ge8$, $H_0\ge1$,
$0<\kappa\le1$, $M=\int P_0>0$, and
\begin{align}
\int(1+|y|)^4P_0(y)\dd y&\le C_0M,
\label{eq:next-postcap-init-moment}\\
\int_{|y|>R/4}(1+|y|)^4P_0(y)\dd y
&\le C_0M\exp\left[-\frac{c_0R^2}{\kappa H_0}\right]
\label{eq:next-postcap-init-leak}
\end{align}
for a fixed $c_0>0$. Assume the actual radial drift satisfies
\begin{align}
|v(u,y)\cdot e_r|&\le a|y|+D &&(|y|0$ depend only on the fixed constants and $c_0$.
For every $0\le J\le U$ and every real measurable phase $\vartheta(u)$,
\begin{align}
\int_J^U e^{-\sigma u/\beta}
\left|e^{i\vartheta(u)}B_4(f(u))\right|\dd u
&\le C_{\beta,\sigma}M(1+J)^4e^{-\sigma J/(2\beta)}
+\frac\beta\sigma\mathcal E.
\label{eq:next-postcap-discounted-tail}
\end{align}
In particular the same bound controls any complex moment integral with
weight $e^{-\mu u}$ and $\operatorname{Re}\mu=\sigma/\beta$.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
All statements can first be proved for the actual smooth positive-time
Navier--Stokes velocity and then by approximation. Its positive scalar
representation is the diffusion with drift $v$ and covariance $2\kappa I$.
For radial estimates a predictable rotation eliminates the tangential
component of its drift: if $Y_u=O_uX_u$, then the martingale
$\int O_u\dd B_u$ is again a planar Brownian motion and
$|Y_u|=|X_u|$. Equivalently one may use the radial exit estimate proved
above. The local drift bound and Gronwall give, up to the first exit time
$\tau_R$ from $B_R$,
\[
\sup_{s\le u\wedge\tau_R}|X_s|
\le e^{au}\left[|X_0|+Du+
\sqrt{2\kappa}\sup_{s\le u}|B_s|\right].
\]
The stopped process is kept at its exit point in this inequality.
For $|X_0|\le R/4$, \eqref{eq:next-postcap-margins} and the Brownian
supremum tail therefore imply
\begin{equation}\label{eq:next-postcap-exit-prob}
\Pr_{X_0}(\tau_R\le U)
\le C\exp\left[-\frac{cR^2}{\kappa U}\right].
\end{equation}
For $U=0$ this means zero exit probability. The predictable rotation can
be regularized at the origin; for a smooth fourfold Navier--Stokes drift
$v(0)=0$ and its tangential angular speed is locally bounded, so removal
of that regularization causes no difficulty. No angular drift bound
enters the constants.
Split $P_0$ into its restrictions to $B_{R/4}$ and its complement.
On unexited trajectories of the first part, the path bound and the
fourth moment of the Brownian supremum give
\[
\mathbb E_{X_0}[(1+|X_u|)^4\mathbf1_{\{\tau_R>u\}}]
\le C e^{4au}\left[(1+|X_0|)^4+(Du)^4+
(\kappa u)^2\right].
\]
Integration against the initial positive density and
\eqref{eq:next-postcap-init-moment} bound this contribution by the
first term of \eqref{eq:next-postcap-moment}, after enlarging $C_*$.
The global radial bound also gives, conditionally from any starting time
$s$ and point $x$,
\[
\mathbb E[(1+|X_u|)^4\mid X_s=x]
\le C e^{C_* (u-s)/\beta}
\left[(1+|x|)^4+(D(u-s))^4+
(\kappa(u-s))^2\right].
\]
This follows from the same radial rotation and Gronwall argument, now
using $a_0$. Conditional application at $\tau_R$, where $|X_{\tau_R}|=R$,
and \eqref{eq:next-postcap-exit-prob} bound all exited trajectories
of the first initial part by
\[
CM e^{C_*U/\beta}(1+R+U+\sqrt{\kappa U})^4
e^{-cR^2/(\kappa U)}.
\]
For the second initial part, the global conditional bound and
\eqref{eq:next-postcap-init-leak} give at most
\[
CM e^{C_*U/\beta}(1+U+\sqrt{\kappa U})^4
e^{-c_0R^2/(\kappa H_0)}.
\]
Reducing $c$ and combining these estimates gives
\eqref{eq:next-postcap-error}, and hence
\eqref{eq:next-postcap-moment}. This proves in particular that the
entire fourth moment of $f$ is well defined.
Since $|f|\le P$, one has $|B_4(f)|\le\int|y|^4P$.
The cap-smallness condition in \eqref{eq:next-postcap-margins} makes
its discounted first term bounded by
\[
CM(1+u)^4e^{-3\sigma u/(4\beta)},
\]
because $\kappa\le1$. Integrating from $J$ to infinity yields
$C_{\beta,\sigma}M(1+J)^4e^{-\sigma J/(2\beta)}$.
The constant-error term integrates to at most
$(\beta/\sigma)\mathcal E$. Unit complex phases do not change any
absolute value, proving \eqref{eq:next-postcap-discounted-tail}.
\end{proof}
\begin{corollary}[Uniform scale margin for an actual source]
\label{cor:next-postcap-scale-margin}
Fix all profile constants and a fixed finite $\beta$.
Let $q\downarrow0$ and assume
\[
R=c_R/q,\qquad
U\le C_U\beta\log(1/q),\qquad
H_0\le C_H\log(1/q),\qquad
\kappa\le q^{3/2},\qquad
\delta=[\log(1/q)]^{-4},
\]
with the preceding proposition's explicit actual drift and cap-envelope
hypotheses. For small $q$, the margins in that proposition hold, and
$\mathcal E/M$ is smaller than every fixed power of $q$, uniformly in
viscosity, depth and seed phases. The actual discounted source histories
then have uniformly integrable future tails:
\[
\int_J^U e^{-\sigma u/\beta}|B_4(f(u))|\dd u
\le C_{\beta,\sigma}M(1+J)^4e^{-\sigma J/(2\beta)}+M\,o(q^K)
\]
for any fixed prescribed $K>0$.
\end{corollary}
\begin{proof}
Here $aU=O(\delta\log(1/q))\to0$ and $DU/R=O(q\log(1/q))\to0$,
so the displacement margin holds. The exponential in
\eqref{eq:next-postcap-error} has an exponent bounded above by
\[
-\frac{c q^{-7/2}}{\log(1/q)},
\]
whereas its remaining factors are bounded by a fixed power of $q^{-1}$
times a fixed power of $\log(1/q)$. This proves the superpolynomial
error estimate, uniformly for every smaller $\kappa$. The discounted
estimate follows from the proposition.
\end{proof}
\begin{remark}[How the actual drift hypotheses arise]
For a child colour at scale $(A_j,R_j)$, its own field and all descendant
fields have normalized velocity bounded by a fixed $D$, by individual
$L^1,L^\infty$ contractions and $\sum_{l\ge j}A_lR_l\le CA_jR_j$.
The global older fourfold fields obey a radial bound $C|y|/\beta$.
Inside a fixed fraction of the parent's protected constant core, the
stopped actual older densities and their harmonic/core-leak estimate give
instead a radial bound $C\delta|y|/\beta$, after the rigid rotation has
been removed and exponentially small leaks have been absorbed into that
coefficient. These facts supply
\eqref{eq:next-postcap-local-drift}--\eqref{eq:next-postcap-global-drift}
when that stopped core estimate is available.
The positive cap-envelope moment and parent-radius leak
\eqref{eq:next-postcap-init-moment}--\eqref{eq:next-postcap-init-leak}
remain explicit inputs here. They must be obtained from the actual
preparation-stage localization; they are not consequences of a signed
cap-coordinate estimate alone.
\end{remark}
\subsection{The actual deepest selected source}
\label{sec:next-selected-source}
We retain the fixed smooth profile $W$, its unstable eigenvalue
$\lambda=\sigma+i\tau$, its normalized growing coordinate $\mathcal A$,
and its neutral seeds $\Phi_\vartheta$. All colours below solve the scalar
equation with the same actual unforced Navier--Stokes velocity.
\begin{lemma}[Weighted off-diagonal Nash estimate]
\label{lem:next-weighted-nash}
Let $\mathcal S(t,s)$ be the positive scalar propagator for the actual
divergence-free Navier--Stokes velocity $u$, or its rigidly rotating frame,
and diffusion coefficient $\kappa>0$ in two dimensions.
Let $\phi$ be a fixed bounded smooth function satisfying
$|\nabla\phi|\le1$, $|\Delta\phi|\le C_\phi$. Suppose
$|u\cdot\nabla\phi|\le V(t)$, where $V\ge0$, and put
$D(t,s)=\int_s^tV$. For $\ell\ge0$ one has
\begin{equation}\label{eq:next-weighted-nash}
\|e^{\ell\phi}\mathcal S(t,s)e^{-\ell\phi}\|_{L^1\to L^\infty}
\le\frac C{\kappa(t-s)}
\exp\bigl(\ell D(t,s)+\kappa\ell^2(t-s)
+C_\phi\kappa\ell(t-s)\bigr).
\end{equation}
If a positive datum of mass $M$ is supported where $\phi=0$, while
$\phi=d_0>0$ on a set $E$, and $D(t,0)0$.
Since $D2$, the physical
velocity is bounded by the Biot--Savart split; its rotating-frame addition
is tangential to radial cutoff boundaries. Thus the integrations by parts
are justified by cutoff limits. Their estimates use only $V$, not that
possibly large velocity bound. Truncating the positive initial datum and
passing monotonically gives the $L^1$ version, with the same constants.
The vorticity generating $u$ may have either sign: divergence freedom is
the only property of that velocity used in these energy identities.
For any signed transported aggregate $g$, scalar positivity gives
$|g|\le\mathcal S(t,0)|g(0)|$, or domination by the sum of the absolute
initial colours. That latter positive datum need only be in $L^1$;
no summed initial $L^\infty$ norm appears in any step.
\end{proof}
Choose once and for all
\[
6K/\sigma+1.
\]
Use the actual packet estimate to choose $\beta,D$ so large that
\begin{equation}\label{eq:next-source-prefix-powers}
e_B=C_2\lambda_BC_W/\sigma$ if a reference-state reset is required below.
There are constants $B,\delta_*>0$, allowed to depend on this finite order
and independent of $j$ and all phases,
such that through
$H_* =\sigma^{-1}\log(\delta_*/\alpha)$,
\begin{equation}\label{eq:next-source-envelope}
\|f_j(t)\|_X\le B a(t),\qquad
\int_0^{H_*}\|K*f_j(t)\|_\infty\,dt\le CB\delta_*.
\end{equation}
The first hitting time $t_j$ of
$|\mathcal A(f_j)|=\delta_q$, $\delta_q=(\log(1/q))^{-4}$, is well defined
and protected: in a fixed neighbourhood of that crossing, almost everywhere,
\[
\frac{d}{dt}|\mathcal A(f_j(t))|\ge\sigma\delta_q/2.
\]
It obeys
\[
t_j=\sigma^{-1}\log(\delta_q/\alpha)
+O(\delta_q+q^\gamma(1+\log(1/q))^{D_0})
\]
for some $\gamma>0$ and finite $D_0$.
For that fixed finite $M$, let $s_q$ be the exact $\delta_q$ cap on
one fixed canonical reference orbit. Choose $\phi_j$ so that
$\mathcal A(\mathcal T_{\phi_j}\Omega_{\rm ref}(s_q))
=\mathcal A(f_j(t_j))$. Then the full vorticity state satisfies
\begin{equation}\label{eq:next-source-cap-reset}
\|\widetilde w_j(t_j)-\mathcal T_{\phi_j}\Omega_{\rm ref}(s_q)\|_X
\le C_M\delta_q^{M+1}
+C_Mq^\gamma(1+\log(1/q))^{D_M}\delta_q
+C\kappa t_j.
\end{equation}
The last, radial term is the explicit difference between the exact
Navier--Stokes heat base and the Euler base. It is not a seeded error.
One can choose $M>C_W/\sigma$, where $C_W$ is the one-sided $X$ comparison
constant of a fixed small ancient segment. All fixed positive-envelope
moments at $t_j$ are bounded uniformly; outside one fixed ball they are
smaller than every $q$-power. This theorem concerns the deepest source
selected by diffusion. It does not assert inductive transmission to all
larger receiving annuli.
\end{theorem}
\begin{proof}
The initial series converges absolutely in $L^1\cap L^p$. Individual scalar
contractions give
$\|w_l\|_1\le CA_lR_l^2$, $\|w_l\|_\infty\le CA_l$ and hence
$\sum_{l>j}\|K*w_l\|_\infty\le CA_jR_j\beta q$.
These are actual-colour bounds and require no hypothesis on the deep
colours' nonradial densities.
Work in the normalized rotating frame. Let $C_\Phi$ bound the fixed
autonomous first coefficient in $X$ divided by $e^{\sigma t}$, and fix
$B>4(C_\Phi+1)$ now. All later field estimates use this fixed $B$;
their constants may depend on it. Stop provisionally when
$\|f_j(t)\|_X=B a(t)$. The terminal cap $\delta_*$ is a provisional
small number, to be fixed after the finite expansion orders, before the
final choice of $q$. By
Corollary~\ref{cor:next-inactive-closed}, all larger colours already obey
their unconditional inactive-density estimate through
$S=C_2\log(1/q)$; their cores and harmonic estimates hold there. Their
nonrotational field on any fixed source collar is, in every fixed spatial
derivative norm,
\begin{equation}\label{eq:next-source-old-small}
O(q^{K+2-e_B})+O(q^{8-e_P}(1+S)^5)+o(q^P)
\end{equation}
for every fixed $P$. Derivatives here are taken only on the harmonic
part; the core leak has no asserted derivative bound and is included in
the last velocity remainder.
The stopped source core persists directly, without a source-core hypothesis
in the bootstrap. Write its own velocity exactly as
$K*e^{\kappa t\Delta}W+K*f_j$; the first term is tangential everywhere
and the second is bounded by $CBa(t)$. Larger cores have already been
proved independently by the inactive-prefix result. Their harmonic and
leaked nonrotational contributions on the fixed source-core disk have
integral tending to zero by \eqref{eq:next-source-old-small}. Every
smaller velocity contributes at most $C\beta q$. Thus the integral of
the absolute radial drift on that disk is at most
\[
CB\delta_*/\sigma+C\beta qS+o(1).
\]
Choose $\delta_*$ and then $q$ so this is less than $a_0/8$. In the
exact backward representation the sign of the drift is reversed, but
the same absolute radial bound holds. Starting in $B_{a_0/2}$ and
stopping on exit from the initial constant core $B_{a_0}$ gives
\[
\|\widetilde w_j(t)-W(0)\|_{L^\infty(B_{a_0/2})}
\le C e^{-c/(\kappa t)}
\]
by the radial exit lemma and the individual colour maximum principle.
Consequently, in the
source core all foreign fields acting on the aggregate
$g=\sum_{l>j}\widetilde w_l$ are harmonic plus a rough exponentially small
leak; after rotation their cubic constant is at most $CB\delta_*$. Their
global growth is $C|x|$, uniformly in $j$.
The aggregate $g$ has mass norm $M_g\le C\beta q^2$, initial support in
$B_{Cq}$, zero circulation and zero initial $B_4$. Apply the already proved
full nonlinear cold-tail estimate with
$r=Cq$, $R_*=\kappa^{1/4}$ and window $S$. Its margins hold since
$M_g/\kappa=O(\beta q^{1/2})$,
$\kappa S\to0$, and $CB\delta_*\sqrt\kappa S\to0$.
It yields
\begin{equation}\label{eq:next-source-cold-fourth}
\sup_{t\le H_*}|B_4(g(t))|
\le C q^{643/100}(1+S)^{D_1}.
\end{equation}
Every constant in this stopped calculation is independent of $j$.
For completeness, higher moments require no signed cancellation. Nash
for the positive passive envelope gives
$\|K*g(t)\|_\infty\le CM_g/\sqrt{\kappa t}$.
Inside $B_{2R_*}$, foreign radial drift is bounded by
$(CB\delta_*R_*^2+\epsilon(t))|x|$.
Its integrated linear-growth coefficient tends to zero. The elementary
radial moment calculation, or the integrating-factor diffusion comparison,
therefore gives for each fixed integer $n\ge2$, before exit,
\[
\int|x|^n|g(t,x)|\,dx
\le C_nM_g\bigl(q+\sqrt{\kappa S}
+M_g\sqrt{S/\kappa}\bigr)^n.
\]
The last displacement is smaller than $\sqrt{\kappa S}$ since
$M_g/\kappa\to0$. Radial exit from $B_{R_*}$ has probability
$Ce^{-cR_*^2/(\kappa S)}$, because both integrated self displacement and
the cubic displacement are small compared with $R_*$. After exit the
global foreign linear growth and integrable self displacement amplify a
fixed moment by at most $C_ne^{C_nS}$, absorbed by that probability.
Thus the whole-moment bound is
\begin{equation}\label{eq:next-source-cold-higher}
\sup_{t\le H_*}\int|x|^n|g(t,x)|\,dx
\le C_n q^{2+3n/4}(1+S)^{n/2}+o(q^P).
\end{equation}
In particular $B_8(g)=O(q^8(1+S)^4)$. Using only the absolute fourth
moment instead of \eqref{eq:next-source-cold-fourth} would fail, since
its available power is merely $q^5$.
There is also an exponentially small actual density leak on the source
collars. Choose in Lemma~\ref{lem:next-weighted-nash} a fixed radial
$\phi$ which rises from zero to $d_0$ entirely inside the protected
source core, and is constant thereafter. On the support of its derivative
the integrated radial drift is at most
$CB\delta_*+C\beta qS+o(1)0$. Indeed one may take any number smaller than
\[
\min\{643/100-K,\ 8-K-e_P,\ 2-e_B\}>0.
\]
The fourth cold coefficient uses \eqref{eq:next-source-cold-fourth};
the higher coefficients use \eqref{eq:next-source-cold-higher};
the old coefficients use \eqref{eq:next-source-old-small}.
Retaining enough moments makes the remainder exponent $P$ arbitrarily
large: the next cold moment has power $2+3n/4$, while old Taylor
remainders gain arbitrarily many factors of $q$. All density/core leaks
are superalgebraic. This step is valid for each fixed finite $P,k$ and
does not assert a derivative bound for a rough leak.
Expand the receiving/source colour in $\alpha,\kappa$ as in the isolated
proof, adding the ACTUAL coefficient functions $b_1=b_{\rm app}/\alpha$ to
the triangular recursion. Explicitly, in addition to the right-hand side
of \eqref{smooth-active-recursion}, add
\[
-\mathbf1_{m=1}b_1(t)\cdot\nabla W_\ell(t)
-\mathbf1_{m\ge2}b_1(t)\cdot\nabla g_{m-1,\ell}(t),
\qquad W_\ell(t)=t^\ell\Delta^\ell W/\ell!.
\]
Here $g_{1,0}(0)=\Phi_{\vartheta_j}$ and all other initial coefficients
vanish. Their dependence on this actual run does not require analyticity
in either parameter: $b_1(t)$ is one fixed coefficient function for that
run, and the recursion cancels the actual equation algebraically.
We make the finite derivative hierarchy explicit. Fix an integer $r\ge4$
and estimate coefficient $(m,\ell)$ at Sobolev order
\[
d_{m,\ell}=r+2(M-m)+2(N-\ell),
\qquad 1\le m\le M,\quad0\le\ell\le N.
\]
The Laplacian input $(m,\ell-1)$ has two more assigned derivatives.
Every heat coupling $(m,\ell-s)$, $s\ge1$, has at least two more; each
nonlinear input has strictly smaller seed order and therefore at least
two more assigned derivatives, sufficient for its one differentiated
factor. The external differentiated input $(m-1,\ell)$ also has two more.
Use the already established $C^k$ bounds for $b_1$ up to the finite
maximum assigned order, and smoothness of $W$ up to that order plus the
finitely many heat Laplacians. The finite-sector propagator acts at each
of these assigned orders without radial derivative loss: base transport
is angular multiplication on each sector. In two dimensions $H^d$, $d\ge4$,
is an algebra; on the fixed coefficient support, zero circulation and the
Fourier low-frequency estimate give
$\|K*g\|_{H^d}\le C_d\|g\|_{H^d}$.
These facts prove all coefficient estimates by induction in $m+\ell$.
There is no infinite derivative iteration and no regularity assumption
on a rough actual core leak. Coefficients remain smooth, supported in the
fixed collars, and of zero circulation, since every forcing is a Laplacian
or the divergence of a compactly supported flux. If the retained input
stream frequencies are at most $4N_{\rm h}$, coefficient $(m,\ell)$ has
frequencies at most $4mN_{\rm h}$; thus only one fixed finite frequency
set is used throughout this hierarchy.
The first coefficient differs
from the isolated coefficient by
$C\varepsilon_q(1+t)e^{\sigma t}$, by the sharp finite-sector
semigroup. For orders $m\ge2$, the forcing has exponent $m\sigma$ and
the gap $m\sigma-\sigma>0$; induction bounds the coefficient differences
by $C_m\varepsilon_q(1+S)e^{m\sigma t}$.
The finite coefficient bounds are uniform since
$\varepsilon_q S\to0$. Positive-viscosity terms have only finite time
polynomials. The source factor is retained in the heat Taylor remainder.
Use the ACTUAL foreign drift in the transport part of the comparison
between the actual source and this expansion. It cancels from the Kato
norm calculation. The additional residual is
$(b-b_{\rm app})\cdot\nabla\omega_{\rm app}$.
All nonheat coefficient gradients have compact collar support, so
\eqref{eq:next-source-input-remainder} controls them. Away from a broad
collar annulus the exact heat gradient is Gaussian; its product with the
foreign radial field is uniform because
$|b\cdot e_r|\le C(|x|+\beta q)$ globally, by origin growth for old
colours and the unrestricted deep velocity sum. Thus the residual obeys
\[
\|R\|_X\le C a^{M+1}
+C\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^Da+Cq^P+o(q^{P'}),
\]
where $P'$ can also be arbitrarily large.
The Kato coefficient is the same fixed
$C_1=C_p(\|\nabla W\|_X+1)$ as before, after a small terminal cap.
For clarity the parameter choices and bootstrap improvement can be made
in the following order. Fix $C_1$ before the expansion orders. Choose
$(M+1)\sigma>C_1$, then $N$ with
\[
\tfrac32(N+1)>K(C_1/\sigma-1)_++1,
\qquad P>K\max\{1,C_1/\sigma\}+1,
\]
then choose the finite harmonic truncation and derivative hierarchy above.
Use the $B>4(C_\Phi+1)$ fixed at the start of the density bootstrap.
The finite pure-coefficient bounds are uniform when
$\varepsilon_q(1+S)$ is small. Choose $\delta_*$ sufficiently small that
the summed higher pure coefficients are at most $Ba/32$, the pure gradient
sum is at most $1/2$, the pure residual comparison is at most $Ba/32$, and
the stopped source core has its fixed radial margin. All remaining
constants are finite and fixed. Now choose $q$ small so the forced
first-coefficient correction, positive-viscosity sums and comparisons,
spatial mismatch comparison, and remaining gradients are each within
their respective $Ba/32$ or gradient-$1/2$ budgets.
In particular $\|\nabla\omega_{\rm app}\|_X\le\|\nabla W\|_X+1$,
so the coefficient is precisely the previously fixed $C_1$.
The explicit comparison error is bounded by
\[
C a^{M+1}
+C\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^{D+1}a(t)e^{(C_1-\sigma)_+t}
+Cq^P(1+t)e^{C_1t}+o(q^{P'}e^{C_1t}),
\]
uniformly through $H_*$. Dividing by $a(t)$, the second term is bounded
by $Cq^{\frac32(N+1)-K(C_1/\sigma-1)_+}(1+S)^{D+1}$; the third by
$Cq^{P-K\max\{1,C_1/\sigma\}}(1+S)$. Both tend to zero, with explicit
positive powers. Choose $P'$ large enough for the last superalgebraic term.
The approximate density and comparison error sum to less than $Ba/2$.
Continuity of $\|f_j\|_X/a$ therefore rules out its first stop and proves
\eqref{eq:next-source-envelope}. The core and cold-tail estimates held
on that sole provisional density stop and were obtained before its
improvement. Therefore no conditional source-density input remains.
The autonomous pure coefficients approach their universal ancient
homological coefficients at an exponential rate. To check the rate, use
the rotating generator $\mathcal L_{\rm rot}$ of the ancient-profile
construction and normalize coefficient $m$ by its factor $e^{m\sigma t}$
and the common angular rotation. The first normalized coefficient differs
from its growing limit by $O(e^{-2\sigma t})$. For $m\ge2$ its equation
is
\[
F_m'(t)=(\mathcal L_{\rm rot}-m\sigma)F_m(t)
-\sum_{m_1+m_2=m}(K*F_{m_1}(t))\cdot\nabla F_{m_2}(t).
\]
The finite-sector propagator of the first operator decays at least as
$Ce^{-(m-1)\sigma t}$. Its limiting constant is the unique homological
resolvent coefficient. Subtract that constant; the differentiated-input
hierarchy above controls the forcing difference. Induction gives a bound
$C_me^{-c t}$, with any fixed $02$, and one sufficiently small canonical ancient
segment before choosing the later finite expansion orders. On this
segment fix a reference orbit with
$\mathcal A(\Omega_{\rm ref}(0))=\delta_{\rm ref}>0$ and write
\[
\mathcal A(\Omega_{\rm ref}(u))
=c_{\rm ref}e^{\lambda u}+O(e^{2\sigma u}),\qquad
a_{\rm ref}=|c_{\rm ref}|.
\]
Fix $C_00$ is a fixed one-sided $X$ comparison exponent on the chosen
canonical segment. Set $t_{\rm ref}=\tau-s_q$.
The actual older-field and descendant hypotheses needed on the advance
follow from Corollary~\ref{cor:next-inactive-closed},
Proposition~\ref{prop:cont-harmonic-outer-field}, and the individual scalar
contractions. Consequently
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cr-integrated-error}
\sup_{0\le v\le-s_q}
\|\widetilde w(\tau+v)-\Omega_{\rm ref}(s_q+v)\|_X
+\int_0^{-s_q}
\|\widetilde w(\tau+v)-\Omega_{\rm ref}(s_q+v)\|_X\,\dd v
\le C\delta^{-r}(E_q+q).
\end{equation}
There is no hypothesis comparing $\delta_{\rm ref}$ with a terminal
finite-expansion amplitude. If
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cr-weighted-order}
\delta^{-r-1/\beta}(E_q+q)\longrightarrow0,
\end{equation}
the actual signed fourth-moment history on $[s_q,0]$ converges to the
canonical history in the weighted absolute norm with weight
$e^{-\sigma u/\beta}$.
For sufficiently small fixed $\delta_{\rm ref}$ and subsequently small
$q$, the actual positive envelope of the child, and that of its entire
source/deep packet, have uniformly bounded moments of every fixed order
at $t_{\rm ref}$. They have superalgebraic moment tails outside one fixed
ball. More strongly, choose a fixed $c_R>0$ so
$R=c_R/q$ lies in a fixed fraction of the parent's protected core. If
$P(t)$ denotes either positive envelope and $M=\int P(0)$, then for every
fixed integer $n\ge2$,
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cr-parent-radius-tail}
\int_{|y|>R/4}(1+|y|)^nP(t_{\rm ref},y)\,\dd y
\le C_nM\exp\left[-\frac{c_nR^2}{\kappa C_2L}\right].
\end{equation}
In particular, for either positive envelope, the sixth-moment bound gives
the explicit fourth-moment tightness estimate
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cr-reference-tightness}
\sup_{\substack{j,\,\text{allowed seeds}\\
P\,\text{child or source/deep envelope}}}
\int_{|y|>R_{\rm cut}}|y|^4P(t_{\rm ref},y)\,\dd y
\le \frac{C_6M_{\rm sup}}{R_{\rm cut}^2}\longrightarrow0
\quad(R_{\rm cut}\to\infty),
\end{equation}
where $R_{\rm cut}>0$ is an independent cutoff radius and
$M_{\rm sup}:=\sup_{j,\,\text{allowed seeds},\,P}\int P(0)<\infty$
is the common normalized envelope-mass bound, with the same two envelope
choices as in the displayed supremum. The fixed-radius and parent-radius Gaussian estimates
are separate assertions; \eqref{eq:cr-reference-tightness} does not
replace the stronger parent-radius estimate.
All constants are independent of depth and of fixed trial past/reset
constants; the threshold for $q$ may depend on those trial constants.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
The canonical first jet and exact-cap monotonicity give
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cr-exact-clock}
s_q=\sigma^{-1}\log(\delta/a_{\rm ref})+O(\delta),
\qquad -s_q=O(\log L).
\end{equation}
Thus $t_{\rm ref}+Jj}\|_\infty\le C\beta q$, as in
Lemma~\ref{lem:next-packet-moments}. Therefore on the canonical support
\begin{equation}\label{eq:cr-foreign-small}
\|b\|_\infty\le
\rho_q:=C\{\beta q+q^{K+2-e_B}+q^{8-e_P}(1+C_2L)^5\}+o(q^P)
=O(q).
\end{equation}
In particular neither an actual child-core hypothesis nor a continuation
of the finite-expansion envelope is used here.
Set $\zeta(v)=\widetilde w(\tau+v)-\Omega_{\rm ref}(s_q+v)$ and
$E(v)=\|\zeta(v)\|_X$. Its exact equation is
\[
\partial_v\zeta+(K*\widetilde w+b)\cdot\nabla\zeta
=\kappa\Delta\zeta-(K*\zeta+b)\cdot\nabla\Omega_{\rm ref}
+\kappa\Delta\Omega_{\rm ref}.
\]
The actual foreign field stays in divergence-free transport. Lemma~\ref{pre:scalar-comparison} and
\eqref{smooth-active-KX} imply
\[
E'(v)\le C_WE(v)+C(\rho_q+\kappa).
\]
Hence $E(v)\le C e^{C_Wv}(E_q+q)$, and integration of this exponential,
using $C_W>0$ and \eqref{eq:cr-exact-clock}, proves
\eqref{eq:cr-integrated-error}. This proof never uses a derivative of
the actual colour or of a rough density leak.
We next reset the positive envelopes at a fixed radius. Choose a fixed
ball enclosing their original support with a fixed radial margin.
Before the cap, \eqref{eq:cr-past} and
\eqref{smooth-active-KX} bound the child's integrated nonradial speed by
$CC_{\rm past}\delta$. On the advance, the radial component of its own
velocity is at most
\[
\|K*(\Omega_{\rm ref}(u)-W)\|_\infty+C_pE(u-s_q).
\]
The fixed canonical negative envelope, which follows from its first
finite jet in \eqref{smooth-ancient-polynomial-error}, gives
\[
\int_{s_q}^0\|K*(\Omega_{\rm ref}(u)-W)\|_\infty\,\dd u
\le C a_{\rm ref}=O(\delta_{\rm ref}).
\]
The comparison contribution tends to zero by
\eqref{eq:cr-integrated-error}. Older nonrotational fields contribute
$o(1)$ and descendants contribute $C\beta q C_2L=o(1)$. The resulting
absolute radial displacement is
\[
O(C_{\rm past}\delta)+O(\delta_{\rm ref})+o(1).
\]
Fix $\delta_{\rm ref}$ sufficiently small for the prescribed margin,
and then choose $q$ for the fixed trial constants. The radial exit
estimate of Lemma~\ref{lem:cont-radial-exit} gives the fixed-radius
Gaussian exit bound. Conditional global moment growth, using
\eqref{eq:inactive-global-radial}, multiplies it by at most
$C_ne^{C_nC_2L}(1+C_2L)^n$, which is absorbed by its Gaussian. Thus all
fixed envelope moments are bounded and their fixed-radius moment tails
are smaller than every prescribed $q$-power. The packet has bounded
initial mass and the same fixed initial support by the positive-envelope
construction preceding Lemma~\ref{lem:next-packet-moments}; it uses the
same actual common drift, so the argument applies without a summed
initial $L^\infty$ norm.
For completeness, the parent-radius estimate is proved directly, rather
than deduced from the fixed-radius tail. Choose $c_R$ so $B_R$ is inside
a fixed fraction of the parent's older probe core. The actual older
harmonic and leak estimates give there
\[
|b_{R/4}(1+|y|)^nP(H,y)\,\dd y
\le C_nM e^{C_nH/\beta}
(1+R+H+\sqrt{\kappa H})^n
e^{-cR^2/(\kappa H)}.
\]
Its prefactor is a fixed power of $q^{-1}$ times a fixed logarithmic
power, whereas $R^2/(\kappa C_2L)\ge c q^{-7/2}/L$. Reducing the
Gaussian exponent constant proves \eqref{eq:cr-parent-radius-tail}.
Truncation of the positive initial packet and monotone passage justify
the calculation when that initial packet has no finite $L^\infty$ norm.
For either envelope, the already proved sixth-moment bound implies
\eqref{eq:cr-reference-tightness}, since
$|y|^4\mathbf1_{\{|y|>R_{\rm cut}\}}\le R_{\rm cut}^{-2}|y|^6$.
Finally, cut the fourth moment off at the fixed reset radius. Its
difference is bounded by the cutoff norm times $E$, plus superalgebraic
tails. Since $e^{-\sigma u/\beta}\le C\delta^{-1/\beta}$ on $[s_q,0]$,
\eqref{eq:cr-integrated-error} gives
\[
\int_{s_q}^0 e^{-\sigma u/\beta}
|B_{\rm actual}(u)-B_4(\Omega_{\rm ref}(u))|\,\dd u
\le C\delta^{-r-1/\beta}(E_q+q)+o(q^P).
\]
This proves the weighted assertion under \eqref{eq:cr-weighted-order}.
\end{proof}
\begin{remark}[The outer source]
When $j=1$, the older field is empty. The comparison and fixed-radius
reset in Lemma~\ref{lem:cr-actual-reference} remain valid with that term
zero. No parent-radius handoff is needed at the outermost scale; the
$R=c_R/q$ estimate is asserted only for $j\ge2$.
\end{remark}
\begin{corollary}[Actual reference-state reset and fixed source windows]
\label{cor:next-source-reference-reset}
Choose the order in Theorem~\ref{thm:next-selected-source} with
$M>C_W/\sigma$, and normalize one sufficiently small canonical reference
state in time and phase so that
\[
\mathcal A(\Omega_{\rm ref}(0))=\delta_{\rm ref}>0,
\qquad
\mathcal A(\Omega_{\rm ref}(s))
=c_{\rm ref}e^{\lambda s}+O(e^{2\sigma s})\quad(s\to-\infty).
\]
Write $a_{\rm ref}=|c_{\rm ref}|$; then
$a_{\rm ref}=\delta_{\rm ref}+O(\delta_{\rm ref}^2)$, but the two
parameters are not identified. Let $s_q<0$ be the exact canonical hitting time of
$|\mathcal A|=\delta_q$ on $\Omega_{\rm ref}$, and remove the actual source's
constant phase so that its first-cap coordinate equals
$\mathcal A(\Omega_{\rm ref}(s_q))$. Put $L_q=-s_q$ and
$t_{\rm ref}=t_j+L_q$. For every fixed $J<\infty$, after the same phase
and rigid-rotation removal,
\[
\widetilde w_j(t_{\rm ref}+\cdot)
\longrightarrow\Omega_{\rm ref}
\quad\text{in }C([-J,J];L^1\cap L^p),
\]
uniformly in cascade depth and all other seed phases. Whole fourth moments
converge uniformly on each such window. At $t_{\rm ref}$ the actual source's
positive passive envelope, and the positive envelope of its entire source/deep
packet, have all fixed moments bounded uniformly and have
superalgebraic moment tails outside one fixed ball. In particular no power
of $\log\log(1/q)$ is lost in this reference-time moment reset.
\end{corollary}
\begin{proof}
Theorem~\ref{thm:next-selected-source} is used only through its shrinking
exact cap $t_j$. Its full-state reset, including the radial heat-base
defect, gives
\[
E_q\le C_M\delta^{M+1}
+C_Mq^\gamma(1+C_2L)^{D_M}\delta+C\kappa t_j.
\]
Its preparation envelope supplies \eqref{eq:cr-past} with a fixed
$C_{\rm past}$. The choice $M>C_W/\sigma$ makes
$\delta^{-r}(E_q+q)\to0$, so
Lemma~\ref{lem:cr-actual-reference} (with its empty-older-prefix variant when $j=1$) proves convergence at the fixed
reference and on every fixed earlier reference window, together with
both positive-envelope resets. It is immaterial whether the selected
source's terminal finite-expansion amplitude exceeds $\delta_{\rm ref}$.
The clock lies inside the required inactive horizon directly. Indeed
the selected-source cap clock and \eqref{eq:cr-exact-clock} give
\[
t_{\rm ref}=t_j-s_q
=\frac K\sigma L+\frac1\sigma\log a_{\rm ref}+o(1).
\]
The choice $C_2>K/\sigma+1$ therefore places every fixed reference window
inside $[0,C_2L]$ for small $q$. On a fixed later window the canonical
Euler support and its $X$ gradient/Laplacian bounds depend only on that
window. The independently available actual older-field bound and
descendant velocity sum still apply there. The same one-sided comparison
extends convergence to $C([-J,J];X)$.
To remove the fourth-moment cutoff on such a later window, the child and
descendant total velocity is uniformly bounded by scalar contractions.
On a sufficiently large fixed ball the actual older radial field is
small; the initial reference envelope has the fixed-radius Gaussian
tail just proved. Radial exit and the unrestricted global moment bound
give uniform fourth-moment tightness on that fixed window. Strong $L^1$
convergence on a cutoff ball then proves uniform whole-fourth-moment
convergence. This completes the corollary without extending the
selected-source expansion envelope beyond its proved endpoint.
\end{proof}
\begin{lemma}[Gaussian handoff at the parent radius]
\label{lem:next-source-parent-handoff}
Fix any $j\ge2$ and any viscosity with normalized value
$0<\kappa\le q^{3/2}$ at this child. The child may have been activated by
its incoming packet; it need not be the deepest source selected by diffusion.
Use only the common geometric initial colour bounds and constant cores,
and assume every actual larger nonradial density is at most
$\delta_qA_lR_l^2$ through a normalized horizon
$00$ such that, for every fixed
integer $n\ge0$,
\begin{equation}\label{eq:next-source-parent-handoff}
\int_{|x|>r_0/q}(1+|x|^n)F_j(t,x)\,dx
\le C_n\exp\left[-\frac{c_nq^{-2}}{\kappa H}\right].
\end{equation}
This estimates positive-envelope leakage at the parent radius independently
of any fixed-radius cap reset.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Take $r_0/q$ strictly inside the parent's protected core, for example
$r_0=a_0/4$. The actual larger cores follow from the stipulated density
stop by applying the outer-core proposition at the parent index. Its horizon
in parent units is $H/\beta=O(\log(1/q))$, its normalized viscosity is
$\beta q^2\kappa\le\beta q^{7/2}$, and its radial margin tends to zero
because $(H/\beta)\sqrt{\delta_q}=O(1/\log(1/q))$ and $qH\to0$.
Thus no selected-source cold-tail theorem or child small-density assumption
is being invoked in this handoff lemma.
The actual old core and harmonic decomposition gives on this
disk a radial bound
$C\delta_q|x|/\beta+\epsilon(t)|x|$, with superalgebraic leak integral.
The own source and all smaller velocities together are at most $C$, by
the convergent individual scalar $L^1,L^\infty$ bounds. Consequently the
radial displacement bound for exit from this disk is at most
\[
CH+\bigl(C\delta_qH/\beta+\text{superalgebraic error}\bigr)r_0/q.
\]
Since $H\ll q^{-1}$ and $\delta_qH=o(1)$, this is less than a fixed
fraction of its radius. The initial source support has fixed radius.
The radial exit lemma bounds its exit probability by
$C\exp[-c q^{-2}/(\kappa H)]$.
Globally all older colours satisfy the origin-growth bound
$|u_{0$ one has
\[
|B_4(\widetilde w_j(t_{\rm ref}+u))|
\le C(1+u)^4 e^{C\delta u/\beta}+o(q^P),
\]
for every fixed $P$, uniformly in depth. Choose $\delta$ additionally so
$C\delta<\sigma/2$. Then this is an integrable uniform positive-history
bound under the receiving discount $e^{-\sigma u/\beta}$.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
On the disk $|z|\le a_0/(4q)$ the actual old harmonic series gives
$|b_{\rm old}\cdot e_r|\le C\delta |z|/\beta+\epsilon(t)|z|$.
Indeed the series is bounded by
$C\delta\sum_{k\ge1}\beta^{-k}q^{2k}|z|^3$, and
$q^2|z|^2$ is bounded on this disk. The core leak has superalgebraic
time integral. At every time the source's own velocity is bounded by
$C$, while the sum of all smaller velocities is bounded by $C\beta q$,
without any nonradial stop. Thus actual radial drift there is at most
$C(1+\beta q)+(C\delta/\beta+\epsilon(t))|z|$.
For its actual positive passive envelope use the weight
$(1+|z|^2)^2$. Its diffusion contribution is at most $C\kappa(1+|z|^2)$,
its additive-drift contribution at most $C(1+|z|^2)^{3/2}$, and its
linear-drift contribution at most $C\delta(1+|z|^2)^2/\beta$.
H\"older and scalar Gronwall for the fourth root give the displayed
polynomial times weak exponential bound before exit.
Write $R=c_R/q$, $L=\log(1/q)$, and let
$U\le C_U\beta L$. On $B_R$ use
$|v\cdot e_r|\le a|y|+D$, with
$a=C_a\delta/\beta$ after absorbing the Gaussian core leak, while
globally use $|v\cdot e_r|\le a_0|y|+D$ with
$a_0\le C_g/\beta$ and $D\le C_d$.
Choose the fixed $\delta$ sufficiently small that
\[
\theta:=C_aC_U\delta<\tfrac14,
\qquad 4C_a\delta<\tfrac\sigma2.
\]
The first condition gives $e^{aU}\le q^{-\theta}$.
Put $b=Re^{-aU}$ and split the initial positive envelope at
$r_{\rm cut}=b/8$. Then
$r_{\rm cut}\ge c q^{-1+\theta}\to\infty$, and
$DU\le b/8$ for small $q$.
For paths beginning in $B_{r_{\rm cut}}$, let $X_u$ be the actual
diffusion and set $Y_u=e^{-au}X_u$. Its radial drift, until $X$ exits
$B_R$, is at most $De^{-au}$ and its diffusion coefficient is
$\sqrt{2\kappa}e^{-au}$. If $X$ exits $B_R$ by $U$, then $Y$ has
already exited $B_b$; until this latter exit the local drift hypothesis
applies because $|X_u|=e^{au}|Y_u|\le R$. Applying the cosh test from
Lemma~\ref{lem:cont-radial-exit}, using only the upper radial bound,
gives
\[
\Pr\{\tau_R\le U\}
\le 2\exp\left[-\frac{c b^2}{\kappa U}\right]
=2\exp\left[-\frac{c R^2e^{-2aU}}{\kappa U}\right].
\]
Indeed the test generator is bounded by
$[2\kappa e^{-2au}\lambda^2+De^{-au}\lambda]\cosh(\lambda|Y|)$,
and the exit gap is at least $b-r_{\rm cut}-DU\ge3b/4$.
No tangential drift bound is used. At $U=0$ the exit probability is zero.
The stopped fourth-moment calculation gives, for the unexited part,
\[
\int |y|^4P(u,y)\,\dd y
\le CM(1+u+\sqrt{\kappa u})^4e^{4au}
\quad\hbox{before adding exited and initially exterior paths}.
\]
This follows by testing $(1+|y|^2)^2$ and taking the fourth root;
the initial fourth moment is at most $C_4M$.
Conditional global moment growth after exit gives a remainder bounded by
\[
CM e^{C_g'U/\beta}
(1+R+U+\sqrt{\kappa U})^4
\exp\left[-\frac{cR^2e^{-2aU}}{\kappa U}\right],
\]
where $C_g'$ depends only on the global growth and additive speed.
This is smaller than $Mq^P$ for every fixed $P>0$: with
$\kappa\le q^{3/2}$, its Gaussian exponent has size at least
$c q^{-7/2+2\theta}/L$, and all its other factors are fixed powers
of $q^{-1}$ and $L$.
For the initially exterior part, the $n$th reset moment gives
\[
\int_{|y|>r_{\rm cut}}(1+|y|)^4P_0(y)\,\dd y
\le C_nM r_{\rm cut}^{-(n-4)}.
\]
Propagating this part with the global radial bound costs at most
$Ce^{C_g'U/\beta}(1+U)^4$. For any prescribed $P$, choose one finite
$n$ such that $(1-\theta)(n-4)>P+C_g'C_U+1$.
The resulting exterior contribution is $M o(q^P)$.
Thus, uniformly on $0\le u\le U$,
\[
\int |y|^4P(u,y)\,\dd y
\le CM(1+u)^4e^{4C_a\delta u/\beta}+M o(q^P).
\]
The second cap-smallness condition makes this bound integrable under
$e^{-\sigma u/\beta}$, with uniformly vanishing discounted future
tails. This proves the stated generic future-history estimate. In the actual
application $\delta=\delta_q$, the strict displacement margin of
Proposition~\ref{prop:next-actual-postcap-tail} also holds, and its sharper
Gaussian-error estimate is used by Lemma~\ref{repair:prepared-child-history}.
\end{proof}
\begin{remark}[The core part of a stopped parent environment]
If every larger colour is stopped at the sharper density level
$\delta_q=(\log(1/q))^{-4}$, the core hypothesis in
Proposition~\ref{prop:next-source-positive-history} follows from the
already proved outer-core proposition, applied at the parent index.
Its total time horizon in parent units is $O(\log(1/q))$, its normalized
viscosity is $\beta q^2\kappa\le\beta q^{7/2}$, and its radial margin is
$O(\log(1/q)\sqrt{\delta_q}+\beta q\log(1/q))=o(1)$.
Thus only the actual parent/larger density stop is a substantive input
in this usual logarithmic window; a separate post-cap small-density
assumption on the source is unnecessary.
\end{remark}
\begin{corollary}[The actual whole-history source transform]
\label{cor:next-source-whole-transform}
Use the fixed reference gauge of
Corollary~\ref{cor:next-source-reference-reset} and the actual post-reference
environment of Proposition~\ref{prop:next-source-positive-history}.
Assume also $U_q\to\infty$. Extend the actual source moment by zero before
its physical initial time and after $U_q$. Then, with
$\mu_\beta=[\sigma+i(\tau-4/5)]/\beta$,
\[
\int_{\mathbb R}e^{-\mu_\beta u}B_{\rm actual,ref}(u)\,du
\longrightarrow
\int_{\mathbb R}e^{-\mu_\beta u}
B_4(\Omega_{\rm ref}(u))\,du,
\]
uniformly in depth and all other seed phases. The same conclusion holds
for the weighted absolute difference of the two moment functions.
The actual history is used only through $U_q$; the zero extension is a
definition of the truncated history, not a claim about later actual dynamics.
If the canonical transform is nonzero at the chosen $\beta$, the actual
one is nonzero for all sufficiently small $q$, with a uniform lower bound
in this fixed reference gauge.
\end{corollary}
\begin{proof}
On the preparation interval, the actual source norm envelope and fixed-radius
Gaussian tails imply
$|B_4(\widetilde w_j(t))|\le C\alpha e^{\sigma t}$.
The exact reference shift satisfies
$\alpha e^{\sigma t_{\rm ref}}=a_{\rm ref}(1+o(1))$.
Thus the actual reference moment is bounded by $Ce^{\sigma u}$ for $u<0$,
including the part between the shrinking cap and the reference state.
Its tail outside the fixed source radius is superalgebraic and smaller
than $\alpha$, so it is included in that same envelope.
The post-reference bound gives
$C(1+u)^4e^{C\delta u/\beta}$ for $u>0$ up to its endpoint, with
superalgebraic errors uniformly on a logarithmic horizon. The canonical
moment has the corresponding negative exponential and positive polynomial
bounds. Since $\beta>1$ and $C\delta<\sigma/2$, both are integrable under
$e^{-\sigma u/\beta}$. The extra superalgebraic errors times the whole
logarithmic horizon and its possible fixed q-power amplification still tend
to zero. The fixed-window whole-moment convergence now proves the weighted
absolute-difference assertion by truncating at $[-J,J]$, first choosing $J$
and then $q$. This gives the transform assertion and its nonzero conclusion.
\end{proof}
\begin{remark}[Why the fixed reference gauge matters]
If the transform is instead centred at the shrinking exact cap, the time
and phase shift multiplies both actual and canonical transforms by the
same factor whose modulus is comparable to
$(\delta_q/a_{\rm ref})^{1/\beta}$. The absolute lower bound then
shrinks by that factor, while the relative transform error remains small.
Using the fixed reference state as the receiving force origin avoids that
artificially shrinking coefficient. Merely comparing a fixed window around
the shrinking cap would omit the later nonlinear source pulse.
\end{remark}
\begin{remark}[The reference inputs in the invariant class]
\label{rem:cr-invariant-input}
For the inductive reset write
\[E_q\le C_{\rm reset}\delta^{M+1}+q^\chi L^D.\]
The fixed choice $M+1>C_W/\sigma+2$ implies \eqref{eq:cr-weighted-order}, including the
extra factor $1+|s_q|$ used in Proposition~\ref{prop:ar-stage}. For each
fixed trial reset constant the reference comparison error and its
integrated radial contribution tend to zero. The reference and its
localization radius are fixed before that later finite order.
The reference past before its small cap has weighted norm at most
$CC_{\rm past}\delta^{1-1/\beta}$. In small-cap time $v\le0$, this
follows from the envelope $C_{\rm past}\delta e^{\sigma v}$ and the
factor $e^{-\sigma s_q/\beta}=O(\delta^{-1/\beta})$. The advance has
fixed canonical history norm plus the vanishing error just proved.
At reference time \eqref{eq:cr-parent-radius-tail}, with $n=4$, supplies
\eqref{eq:next-postcap-init-leak} with $H_0=C_2L$, while the fixed-radius
moment reset supplies \eqref{eq:next-postcap-init-moment}. Under the
current parent's protected-core stop, its actual older harmonic/leak
field satisfies \eqref{eq:next-postcap-local-drift}; its unrestricted
origin-growth bound gives \eqref{eq:next-postcap-global-drift}; the child's
own and descendant velocity sum gives the fixed $D$. Thus
Proposition~\ref{prop:next-actual-postcap-tail} supplies the prospective
future history without an assumed signed source waveform.
The upper history prefactor can be chosen independently of a fixed trial
parent stop. In the proof of that proposition the local stop constant
occurs in $e^{CC_{\rm stop}\delta u/\beta}$, while the prefactor uses only
the reset moment and $D$. On $u\le C_2\beta L$, this factor is at most
two after choosing $q$ for the fixed trial stop; its discounted exponent
is at most $-\sigma u/(2\beta)$. Conditional global moment growth in
the Gaussian error uses the unrestricted bound, independently of that
stop. The future weighted norm is consequently bounded by a fixed
reference constant. Hence, for the finite derivative orders selected
before the class constants,
\[
M_{\rm input}\le M_{\rm ref}
+CC_{\rm past}\delta^{1-1/\beta}+o(1),
\]
where $M_{\rm ref}$ may depend on those finite orders, fixed stream
cutoffs, profile, reference, clocks, and $\beta$, but not on trial
past/reset/stop constants or depth. Orders can be chosen using the
already fixed comparison exponents, then their input constant computed,
then the output class constants fixed, and finally $q$ decreased.
Fixed-window comparison and the two discounted tails also give uniform
$o(1)$ closeness of the signed transform to the fixed canonical transform.
This provides its nonzero lower bound once the full prospective receiver
interval is reached; the independent upper input bound is available on
every shorter stop. These are the reference and handoff inputs needed
by Proposition~\ref{prop:next-uniform-induction}.
\end{remark}
\section{Finite nonlinear expansions for retained actual forcing}\label{sec:finite-receiver}
\subsection{Finite actual forcing: density closure and exact-cap reset}
\label{sec:ffr}
A finite expansion with the actual foreign-field coefficients gives an
actual density envelope and an exact-cap state reset. The recursion uses
those coefficients as measurable functions of time. A nonzero growing
coefficient and pointwise bounds on the protected late window supply the
first-cap conclusion.
\subsubsection{Spaces, operators and the derivative reserve}
Let $\mathcal C$ be the union of the two closed derivative collars of the
fixed smooth radial profile $W$. Choose a closed radial interval
$I\Subset(0,\infty)$ containing these collars in its interior.
For an integer $J\ge1$, let $E_j^r$ denote the real finite angular-sector
space of functions supported in $\mathcal C$ whose sectors are
$m\in4\mathbb Z$, $|m|\le4Jj$, with radial coefficients in $H^r(I)$.
More explicitly, with the fixed smoothing length $\epsilon$, set
\[
\mathcal C:=\{x:\big||x|-\rho\big|\le\epsilon\}
\cup\{x:\big||x|-1\big|\le\epsilon\},\qquad
\mathcal M_j:=\{m\in4\mathbb Z:|m|\le4Jj\}.
\]
Then the space and its norm are
\[
E_j^r:=\left\{f(x)=\sum_{m\in\mathcal M_j}
h_m(|x|)e^{im\arg x}:\ h_m\in H^r(I),\
\operatorname{supp}f\subset\mathcal C,\ f\text{ real}\right\},
\]
\[
\|f\|_{E_j^r}:=\sum_{m\in\mathcal M_j}\|h_m\|_{H^r(I)}.
\]
Each $h_m$ is extended by zero outside $I$, and $f(0):=0$.
The support condition makes $h_m$ vanish off the two collar intervals.
On these supported
finite-sector functions it is equivalent to the full-plane $H^r$ norm,
with constants depending on $I,J,j,r$. Initially and in every recursion
below the functions are smooth, flat at the collar endpoints, and have
zero integral. The coefficient equations therefore use a common closed
supported subspace on each finite Sobolev level; there is no assertion of
an unrestricted all-angular-mode spectral estimate.
Write
\[
\mathcal L f:=-(K*W)\cdot\nabla f-(K*f)\cdot\nabla W,
\qquad Q(f,g):=-(K*f)\cdot\nabla g.
\]
The inherited finite-sector spectral lemma gives
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ffr-spectral}
e^{t\mathcal L}=e^{\lambda t}P_+
+e^{\bar\lambda t}P_-+\mathcal R(t),
\qquad \norm{\mathcal R(t)}_{H^r\to H^r}\le C_r e^{2\eta t},
\quad 2\eta<\sigma,\quad \lambda=\sigma+i\tau.
\end{equation}
This is used only in one of the finitely many spaces $E_j^r$.
The growing eigenfunction $F_+$ lies in sector $+4$ and is normalized by
$\mathcal A(F_+)=1$; its real conjugate lies in sector $-4$.
The global test defining $\mathcal A$ selects sector $+4$.
For the pattern rotation set
\[
(\mathcal T_\theta f)(r,\varphi)=f(r,\varphi+\theta/4),
\qquad \mathcal L_{\rm rot}
=\mathcal L-(\tau/4)\partial_\varphi.
\]
For vector fields its definition is the pushforward
$\mathcal T_\theta V(x)=\mathsf R_{-\theta/4}
V(\mathsf R_{\theta/4}x)$, where $\mathsf R$ is the planar rotation
matrix. Equivalently its polar components are shifted by $\theta/4$.
This gives $K*(\mathcal T_\theta f)=\mathcal T_\theta(K*f)$ and
$\mathcal T_\theta[V\cdot\nabla f]
=(\mathcal T_\theta V)\cdot\nabla(\mathcal T_\theta f)$.
This rotation is applied to the entire function, separately in every
angular sector. It is not replaced by the scalar factor $e^{-ij\tau s}$
on an order-$j$ coefficient. The operators commute, and rotations are
isometries in radial Sobolev norms. Thus
$e^{t\mathcal L_{\rm rot}}\le Ce^{\sigma t}$ and the growing real
space has eigenvalue $\sigma$.
Fix truncation orders $M,N\ge1$ and a desired final Sobolev order $k$.
The letter $N$ in this finite recursion is the viscosity truncation order;
it is distinct from the depth selected by $\nu_N$ in the global cascade.
Set
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ffr-reserve}
k_*:=\max\{4,k\},\qquad
r_{j\ell}:=k_*+2(M-j)+2(N-\ell),\qquad
R:=k_*+2M+2N+3.
\end{equation}
The reserve is explicit. A diffusion source uses $g_{j,\ell-1}$, whose
order exceeds $r_{j\ell}$ by two. A quadratic or foreign-advection
source uses a coefficient with strictly smaller seed order, whose order
exceeds the requested order by at least two. A heat-interaction source
uses $g_{j,\ell-r}$, again with at least two additional derivatives.
All profile derivatives used below are fixed derivatives of $W$;
$W$ is smooth in every finite order.
For zero-integral functions supported in one fixed ball,
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ffr-bilinear}
\norm{K*f}_{H^{r+1}(\R^2)}\le C_r\norm f_{H^r},\qquad
\norm{Q(f,g)}_{H^r}\le C_r\norm f_{H^r}\norm g_{H^{r+1}},
\quad r\ge2.
\end{equation}
To check the first low-frequency estimate, compact support and zero mass
give $|\widehat f(\xi)|\le C|\xi|\norm f_1$ for $|\xi|\le1$.
The Biot--Savart multiplier has order $-1$, so it is bounded there by
this cancellation and is of order $-1$ at high frequency. Plancherel
proves the first estimate. For the second, $H^r(\R^2)$ is an algebra
for $r>1$, and $\nabla g\in H^r$; multiplication and the first estimate
prove the assertion. On the supported spaces $H^{k_*}$ also controls
all the $L^1,L^p$ product norms and the two extra derivatives in residual
Laplacians. These elementary bounds justify, rather than hide, every
transport derivative in the finite induction.
\subsubsection{The finite recursion and its exact residual}
Put $X=L^1\cap L^p$, $p>2$, with its sum norm. In a scale family write
$L=\log(1/q)$, $\delta=L^{-4}$, with $00$ are fixed before $q$ is decreased. Splitting Biot--Savart
at radius one gives $\norm{K*f}_\infty\le C_p\norm f_X$.
Let $0\le H<\infty$, $t_0\ge0$, $\alpha\ge0$, $\varepsilon>0$,
$0<\kappa\le1$, and
\[
s:=t-t_0,\qquad a(t):=\varepsilon e^{\sigma(t-t_0)},
\qquad W_\kappa(t):=e^{\kappa t\Delta}W,
\qquad W_r(t):=\frac{t^r}{r!}\Delta^rW.
\]
Let $B(t,x)$ be real and divergence free, spatially $C^\infty$ for
almost every time, and locally integrable in time with values in every
fixed finite $C^m$ norm. Only its $C^R$ norm is used in the quantitative
bounds. This qualitative regularity is automatic for the finite smooth
stream basis with actual moment coefficients. Its polar velocity components have finitely many
angular sectors $m\in4\mathbb Z$, $|m|\le4J$.
Define the retained field by
\[b_J(t,x):=\varepsilon B(t,x).\]
Assume
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ffr-input}
\frac\alpha\varepsilon e^{\sigma t_0}
\norm\Phi_{H^{r_{10}}}\le A_0,
\qquad
D(t):=e^{-\sigma(t-t_0)}\norm{B(t)}_{C^R},
\qquad \int_0^H D(t)\dd t\le B_0,
\end{equation}
where $\Phi\in E_1^{r_{10}}$ is a real smooth zero-integral seed.
The bounded constants $A_0,B_0$ are the input ball; no pointwise upper
bound on $D$ is imposed.
Define the initial coefficients by
\[
g_{10}(0):=(\alpha/\varepsilon)\Phi,\qquad
g_{j\ell}(0):=0\quad\bigl((j,\ell)\ne(1,0)\bigr).
\]
For $1\le j\le M$, $0\le\ell\le N$, the coefficients are defined
successively by the following initial-value problems:
\begin{align}
(\partial_t-\mathcal L)g_{j\ell}
={}&\mathbf1_{\ell\ge1}\Delta g_{j,\ell-1}
-\sum_{r=1}^{\ell}
\big[(K*W_r)\cdot\nabla g_{j,\ell-r}
+(K*g_{j,\ell-r})\cdot\nabla W_r\big]
\nonumber\\
&+\sum_{\substack{j_1+j_2=j,\ j_1,j_2\ge1\\
\ell_1+\ell_2=\ell}}
Q(g_{j_1\ell_1},g_{j_2\ell_2})
-\mathbf1_{j=1}B\cdot\nabla W_\ell
-\mathbf1_{j\ge2}B\cdot\nabla g_{j-1,\ell}.
\label{eq:ffr-recursion}
\end{align}
Every coefficient on the right precedes $(j,\ell)$ in the ordering by
$j+\ell$. The angular sectors are at most $4Jj$. All outputs are
supported in $\mathcal C$: Laplacians preserve the support of smooth
flat functions; $\Delta^rW$ with $r\ge1$ has this support; and every
advective term differentiates a supported function. Each forcing has
zero integral by divergence freedom or the Laplacian identity. The
bounded finite-sector generator and Duhamel therefore construct a unique
smooth coefficient, absolutely continuous in time in every required
lower Sobolev order. Measurable time coefficients are sufficient.
Define
\[
F(t):=\sum_{j=1}^M\sum_{\ell=0}^N
\varepsilon^j\kappa^\ell g_{j\ell}(t),
\qquad w_{\rm app}:=W_\kappa+F.
\]
Figure~\ref{fig:reader-recursion} summarizes the finite coefficient array and its derivative reserve.
\begin{figure}[H]
\centering
\begin{tikzpicture}[>=Latex,font=\small,
coeff/.style={draw,rounded corners=2pt,minimum width=1.2cm,
minimum height=.7cm},x=1cm,y=1cm]
\foreach \jj in {1,2,3} {
\foreach \ll in {0,1,2} {
\pgfmathsetmacro{\xx}{2.1*\ll}
\pgfmathsetmacro{\yy}{1.35*(\jj-1)}
\ifnum\ll=0
\node[coeff,draw=blue!75!black] (g\jj\ll) at (\xx,\yy)
{$g_{\jj\ll}$};
\else
\node[coeff,draw=orange!85!black] (g\jj\ll) at (\xx,\yy)
{$g_{\jj\ll}$};
\fi
}
}
\foreach \jj in {1,2,3} {
\draw[->,orange!85!black] (g\jj0)--(g\jj1);
\draw[->,orange!85!black] (g\jj1)--(g\jj2);
}
\foreach \ll in {0,1,2} {
\draw[->,blue!75!black] (g1\ll)--(g2\ll);
\draw[->,blue!75!black] (g2\ll)--(g3\ll);
}
\node[below,align=center] at (2.1,-.75)
{viscosity order $\ell\longrightarrow$\\
horizontal edges include $\Delta g_{j,\ell-1}$};
\node[rotate=90,align=center] at (-1.18,1.35)
{seed/forcing order $j\longrightarrow$};
\node[anchor=north west,align=left,text width=6.1cm] at (6.15,3.10) {
\textbf{A finite coefficient array.}\\[4pt]
$1\le j\le M$,\quad $0\le\ell\le N$.\\[6pt]
$\displaystyle F(t):=\sum_{j=1}^M\sum_{\ell=0}^N
\varepsilon^j\kappa^\ell g_{j\ell}(t)$.\\[6pt]
$w_{\rm app}(t):=W_\kappa(t)+F(t)$.\\[8pt]
\textbf{Derivative reserve.}\\[4pt]
$r_{j\ell}:=k_*+2(M-j)+2(N-\ell)$.\\[5pt]
Each decrease of one index supplies two derivatives for a source
term in the next equation.};
\end{tikzpicture}
\caption{Bookkeeping for the finite nonlinear recursion
\eqref{eq:ffr-recursion}. The drawn $3\times3$ corner is illustrative;
the actual orders $M,N$ are finite and chosen in the parameter selection.
Here $j$ is the coefficient order, rather than a physical scale index;
$N$ is the local viscosity truncation order, rather than the selected depth.
Blue nodes have viscosity order zero, while orange nodes have positive
viscosity order. Arrows show representative dependencies; quadratic
terms also use all partitions $j_1+j_2=j$, $\ell_1+\ell_2=\ell$ in the
displayed recursion. Every source coefficient precedes its output in
$j+\ell$. The proof controls the actual remainder after truncation and
does not require convergence of an infinite power series.}
\label{fig:reader-recursion}
\end{figure}
The recursion is an algebraic identity at the given run's $B,\kappa$.
Dependence of $B$ on the actual solution and on $\kappa$ does not change
that identity.
\begin{lemma}[Coefficients and finite residual]\label{lem:ffr-residual}
Under \eqref{eq:ffr-input}, with the reserve \eqref{eq:ffr-reserve},
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ffr-coeff}
\norm{g_{j0}(t)}_{H^{r_{j0}}}\le C e^{j\sigma s},
\qquad
\norm{g_{j\ell}(t)}_{H^{r_{j\ell}}}
\le C(1+t)^{d_{j\ell}}e^{j\sigma s},
\quad d_{j\ell}=2\ell(j+\ell),\quad\ell\ge1.
\end{equation}
The constants depend on the fixed finite orders and input ball, not on
$t_0,H,\varepsilon,\kappa$ or the particular waveform.
One may take $d_R=4N(M+N)+N+3$. If $a\le1$ and
$\kappa(1+H)^{d_R}\le c$, the residual in the retained field satisfies
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ffr-residual}
\norm{\partial_tw_{\rm app}
+(K*w_{\rm app}+\varepsilon B)\cdot\nabla w_{\rm app}
-\kappa\Delta w_{\rm app}}_X
\le C\big[a^{M+1}
+\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^{d_R}a\big](1+D(t)).
\end{equation}
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
For $g_{10}$, \eqref{eq:ffr-spectral} and the weighted initial bound
show that its homogeneous contribution is at most $Ce^{\sigma s}$.
Its forcing convolution is at most
\[
C\int_0^t e^{\sigma(t-r)}\norm{B(r)}_{C^R}\dd r
=Ce^{\sigma s}\int_0^tD(r)\dd r.
\]
The reserve supplies its requested derivatives. Suppose preceding
coefficients have the claimed bounds. A quadratic pure-seed source has
size $Ce^{j\sigma(r-t_0)}$ in the requested Sobolev order, by
\eqref{eq:ffr-bilinear}. For $j\ge2$ its convolution has the gap
$(j-1)\sigma$, so its bound is $Ce^{j\sigma s}$ with no polynomial.
A pure external-advection source has size
$Ce^{j\sigma(r-t_0)}D(r)$; dividing its convolution by
$e^{j\sigma s}$ leaves
$C\int_0^t e^{-(j-1)\sigma(t-r)}D(r)\dd r\le CB_0$.
This proves the pure-seed estimate.
For positive viscosity order, the heat terms carry $(1+r)^r$ from
$W_r$, the diffusion term has the preceding polynomial, and the
quadratic terms add their two polynomial degrees. A convolution at
$j=1$ can add at most one degree; for $j\ge2$ the strict gap adds none.
The choice $d_{j\ell}=2\ell(j+\ell)$ dominates all these degrees:
\[
d_{j\ell}\ge d_{j,\ell-1}+1,
\quad d_{j\ell}\ge r+d_{j,\ell-r}+1,
\quad d_{j\ell}\ge d_{j-1,\ell},
\quad d_{j\ell}\ge d_{j_1\ell_1}+d_{j_2\ell_2}.
\]
The second inequality is used for $r\ge1$ and $\ell\ge r$;
the third for $j\ge2$; the last for the displayed quadratic indices.
For the direct $B\nabla W_\ell$ term its degree $\ell$ is smaller.
The weighted $D$ convolution adds no degree beyond the preceding factor.
This proves \eqref{eq:ffr-coeff} by the finite induction, using precisely
the reserve already specified.
For completeness we give the residual identity. Put
$G_N=W_\kappa-\sum_{r=0}^N\kappa^rW_r$ and
$Q_rh=-[(K*W_r)\nabla h+(K*h)\nabla W_r]$.
Write $Q_Gh$ for the same expression with $G_N$ replacing $W_r$.
After cancellation of the retained monomials the residual is exactly
\begin{align}
R^J={}&-\sum_{j=1}^M\varepsilon^j\kappa^{N+1}\Delta g_{jN}
-\sum_{\substack{1\le j\le M,\ 0\le\ell\le N,\ 1\le r\le N\\
\ell+r>N}}
\varepsilon^j\kappa^{\ell+r}Q_rg_{j\ell}
\nonumber\\
&-\sum_{\substack{1\le j_1,j_2\le M,\ 0\le\ell_1,\ell_2\le N\\
j_1+j_2>M\ \mathrm{or}\ \ell_1+\ell_2>N}}
\varepsilon^{j_1+j_2}\kappa^{\ell_1+\ell_2}
Q(g_{j_1\ell_1},g_{j_2\ell_2})
\nonumber\\
&+\varepsilon^{M+1}\sum_{\ell=0}^N\kappa^\ell
B\cdot\nabla g_{M\ell}
+\varepsilon B\cdot\nabla G_N-Q_GF.\label{eq:ffr-exact-R}
\end{align}
Here juxtaposition with a gradient means a dot product.
The exact radial heat base has zero residual on its own. The integral
heat Taylor formula gives
\[
\norm{G_N}_X+\norm{\nabla G_N}_X
\le C\kappa^{N+1}t^{N+1}.
\]
Use the Biot--Savart $X$ bound and \eqref{eq:ffr-coeff} to estimate
$Q_GF$. Every remaining factor in \eqref{eq:ffr-exact-R}, other than
the heat remainder, is supported on the fixed collars. Pure terms with
seed order exceeding $M$ are $Ca^{M+1}$; their pure coefficient bounds
have no polynomial. A positive viscosity power multiplied by any of the
finitely many polynomial factors is absorbed by increasing $d_R$ and
requiring $\kappa(1+H)^{d_R}\le c$.
Terms with viscosity order exceeding $N$ are
$C\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^{d_R}a$, since $a^j\le a$.
The external top-seed term uses
$\norm B=e^{\sigma s}D$ and is $Ca^{M+1}D$.
The external heat remainder is
$C\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^{d_R}aD$.
This proves \eqref{eq:ffr-residual}, including all viscosity terms and
without assuming a pointwise bound on $D$.
\end{proof}
\subsubsection{Comparison with the actual foreign velocity}
Suppose the actual colour solves
\[
\partial_tw+(K*w+b)\cdot\nabla w=\kappa\Delta w,
\qquad w(0)=W+\alpha\Phi.
\]
The actual $b$ is divergence free; it may depend on the entire interacting
solution. Assume the usual positive-time smoothness and $C_tX$ initial
trace, sufficient for the scalar Kato inequalities. A removed rigid
rotation is allowed. Let $\mathcal U$ be a fixed annular neighbourhood
of $\mathcal C$, separated from its complement by a positive radial
heat-gradient gap. Assume
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ffr-mismatch}
\sup_{x\in\mathcal U}|b-b_J|\le m_q,
\qquad |b(t,x)\cdot e_r|\le C_b(1+|x|),
\end{equation}
with fixed $C_b$. The second is used only against the exact radial heat
gradient outside $\mathcal U$. No derivative of $b$ is assumed.
The stream extensions giving $B$ agree with the retained harmonics on
$\mathcal U$. These are exactly the collar omission and actual global
radial-growth inputs supplied by the packet/core estimates.
\begin{lemma}[Actual density comparison]\label{lem:ffr-comparison}
Fix
$C_1=C_p(\norm{\nabla W}_X+1)$ before choosing $M,N,J$.
Choose $(M+1)\sigma>C_1$. There is a later threshold $a_*>0$ such
that if $a(t)\le a_*$ and the finite viscosity smallness conditions
hold, then $\norm{\nabla w_{\rm app}}_X$ gives the fixed exponent
$C_1$ and
\begin{align}
\norm{w-w_{\rm app}}_X\le{}&Ca^{M+1}
+C\kappa^{N+1}(1+t)^{d_R+1}a
e^{(C_1-\sigma)_+t}\nonumber\\
&+Cm_q(1+t)e^{C_1t}
+C(1+H)e^{C_1H}(1+\varepsilon e^{\sigma H})
e^{-c/(\kappa H)}.\label{eq:ffr-error}
\end{align}
The last Gaussian term is understood as zero at $H=0$.
Consequently in a scale family
\[
\begin{gathered}
\varepsilon=q^r,\qquad \sigma t_0\le\theta L,\qquad
H\le C_HL,\qquad\kappa\le q^\gamma,\qquad m_q\le q^P L^{d_m},\\
r,\gamma,\chi>0,\qquad\theta\ge0,\qquad 0C_H(C_1-\sigma)_++\chi,
\qquad P>r+\theta+C_H(C_1-\sigma)_++\chi,
\end{equation}
then
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ffr-alltime}
\norm{w-w_{\rm app}}_X
\le Ca^{M+1}+Cq^\chi L^{d_*}a,
\qquad \norm{w-W_\kappa}_X\le Ca.
\end{equation}
These estimates require no nonzero transmission coefficient.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
The finite coefficient bounds make the pure perturbation gradient at most
$1/2$ after choosing $a_*$ sufficiently small. Choose the later viscosity
threshold so the remaining finite gradients are at most $1/2$.
Heat contracts $\norm{\nabla W}_X$. This yields the already fixed $C_1$;
the coefficient constants change thresholds, not that exponent.
For $z=w-w_{\rm app}$ the exact equation is
\[
(\partial_t+(K*w+b)\cdot\nabla-\kappa\Delta)z
=-(K*z)\cdot\nabla w_{\rm app}-R^J
-(b-b_J)\cdot\nabla w_{\rm app}.
\]
The actual foreign field is part of divergence-free transport and cancels
from the $L^1,L^p$ norm inequalities. The Biot--Savart $X$ bound gives
\[
(\norm z_X)'\le C_1\norm z_X+\norm{R^J}_X
+\norm{(b-b_J)\cdot\nabla w_{\rm app}}_X.
\]
The initial error is zero. Smooth norm regularizations and compact
cutoffs justify the integrated inequality from time zero.
On $\mathcal U$ the mismatch is at most $Cm_q(1+a)$.
Outside it, $\nabla F=0$ and the weighted radial heat-gradient norm is
$Ce^{-c/(\kappa t)}$, after decreasing $c$ to absorb fixed polynomial
heat factors. The actual radial-growth bound and
$\norm{b_J}_\infty\le aD$ therefore bound the omitted force by
$C(1+aD)e^{-c/(\kappa t)}$.
Convolve with $e^{C_1(t-v)}$.
For the top pure residual, division by $a(t)^{M+1}$ leaves
\[
\int_0^t e^{-[(M+1)\sigma-C_1](t-v)}(1+D(v))\dd v
\le [ (M+1)\sigma-C_1]^{-1}+B_0.
\]
For the viscous residual, division by $a(t)$ leaves at most
$C(1+t)^{d_R+1}e^{(C_1-\sigma)_+t}(1+B_0)$.
The constant collar mismatch gives $Cm_q(1+t)e^{C_1t}$.
The Gaussian force uses $\int D\le B_0$ and monotonicity of its
exponential, proving \eqref{eq:ffr-error} after enlarging its harmless
prefactor. In the scale family, $a(0)\ge q^{r+\theta}$ and
\eqref{eq:ffr-powers} makes both non-Gaussian errors relative to $a(t)$
positive powers of $q$ times fixed logarithms. The Gaussian dominates
all these fixed power losses uniformly for smaller viscosities.
Finally the finite coefficient sum has norm $Ca$ and the error has the
same bound, proving \eqref{eq:ffr-alltime}.
\end{proof}
\begin{corollary}[Upper continuation to a prospective endpoint]
\label{cor:ffr-upper-continuation}
Work in the setting of Lemma~\ref{lem:ffr-comparison}, including its
actual colour equation, initial condition $w(0)=W+\alpha\Phi$,
regularity and finite-recursion hypotheses. Fix the profile, finite orders
and input constants $A_0,B_0$. Let $L=\log(1/q)$,
$\delta=L^{-4}$, $a(t)=q^6e^{\sigma(t-t_0)}$,
$\sigma t_0\le\epsilon_0L$, $H_+\le C_2L$, $\kappa\le q^3$ and
$a(H_+)=E_0\delta$, where $E_0>0$ is fixed.
Assume $(M+1)\sigma>C_1$ and
\[
3(N+1)>C_2(C_1-\sigma)_++\chi,\qquad
P>6+\epsilon_0+C_2(C_1-\sigma)_++\chi
\]
for some $\chi>0$. For a trial $C_s\ge1$ define
\[
T_s:=\inf\{t\ge0:\|w(t)-W_\kappa(t)\|_X=C_s\delta\},
\qquad \inf\varnothing:=+\infty.
\]
Suppose $\|w(0)-W\|_X2C_aE_0$, subsequently small $q$ gives
\[
T_s>H_+,\qquad \|w(t)-W_\kappa(t)\|_X\le C_aa(t)
\quad(0\le t\le H_+).
\]
No signed transmission-coefficient lower bound is assumed.
\end{corollary}
\begin{proof}
The fixed endpoint relation gives $a(H_+)\to0$. All finite viscosity
smallness conditions also hold for sufficiently small $q$.
Lemma~\ref{lem:ffr-comparison} thus applies on every shorter stopped
interval, with one $C_a$ depending only on the fixed input ball and
finite orders. Since $a$ is increasing, it gives
\[
\|w(t)-W_\kappa(t)\|_X\le C_aE_0\deltad$ yield the same bound
for the normalized difference, including the decaying bounded initial
value at zero. Increasing a finite polynomial degree handles a possible
convolution polynomial. This proves the finite induction and
\eqref{eq:ffr-memory}.
\end{proof}
\subsubsection{Exact protected-coordinate matching}
Define the real Banach-valued polynomial
\[
\mathcal P_M(z)=W+\sum_{j=1}^MF_j(z),\qquad z\in\mathbb C.
\]
Its protected coordinate is
$\Psi_M(z)=\mathcal A(\mathcal P_M(z))$.
It is a real polynomial in $z,\bar z$, is rotation equivariant,
$\Psi_M(e^{i\theta}z)=e^{i\theta}\Psi_M(z)$, and
$D\Psi_M(0)$ is the identity on $\mathbb R^2$.
In particular it has the form $z[1+O(|z|)]$; the parity actually
eliminates its quadratic term, but that stronger fact is not needed.
\begin{lemma}[Exact polynomial and ancient cap gauge]
\label{lem:ffr-gauge}
There is a fixed $\rho>0$ such that $\Psi_M$ has a unique inverse
on $|\zeta|<\rho$, with inverse derivative uniformly bounded. Suppose
$\norm{v-\mathcal P_M(z)}_X\le e$, $|z|<\rho$, and
$\mathcal A(v)=\delta e^{i\theta}$ with $0<\delta\ll\rho$.
Then for
$z_*=\Psi_M^{-1}(\delta e^{i\theta})$,
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ffr-exact-gauge}
|z-z_*|\le Ce,
\qquad \norm{v-\mathcal P_M(z_*)}_X\le Ce.
\end{equation}
For the inherited canonical ancient orbit,
Corollary~\ref{smooth-ancient-all-orders} supplies every fixed finite jet
\[
\norm{\Omega_{\rm ref}(u)-\mathcal P_M(c_{\rm ref}e^{\lambda u})}_X
\le C_M|c_{\rm ref}e^{\lambda u}|^{M+1},\qquad u\ll0,
\quad c_{\rm ref}\ne0.
\]
If $u_\delta$ is its small exact cap, the rotation $\phi$ matching
its protected coordinate exactly to $\delta e^{i\theta}$ satisfies
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ffr-ancient-gauge}
\norm{v-\mathcal T_\phi\Omega_{\rm ref}(u_\delta)}_X
\le C[e+\delta^{M+1}].
\end{equation}
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Choose $2\rho$ so small that
$\sup_{|z|\le2\rho}\norm{D\Psi_M(z)-I}\le1/4$.
The integral mean-value formula then gives the quantitative inverse
estimate $|\Psi_M(z)-\Psi_M(z')|\ge(3/4)|z-z'|$ in that ball.
The inverse function theorem, or its contraction proof applied to
$z=\zeta-[\Psi_M(z)-z]$, supplies the inverse on a smaller ball.
Since $\mathcal A$ is bounded on $X$, the state error bounds the
coordinate error by $Ce$, and the inverse estimate proves the first
bound in \eqref{eq:ffr-exact-gauge}. The derivative of
$\mathcal P_M$ is bounded on this fixed ball, so the second follows.
At the canonical exact cap, its jet remainder is $O(\delta^{M+1})$
because $|c_{\rm ref}e^{\lambda u_\delta}|\asymp\delta$.
The same inverse estimate changes its linear asymptotic parameter to
the unique parameter matching its \emph{full} protected coordinate,
with error $O(\delta^{M+1})$. Rotation equivariance makes that parameter,
after the exact coordinate-matching rotation, precisely $z_*$.
The polynomial and ancient-state errors therefore add to the bound
\eqref{eq:ffr-ancient-gauge}. Matching only the linear parameter would
instead leave a lower-order error; it is not used here.
\end{proof}
\subsubsection{State reset and the separate instantaneous cap condition}
Combine the lemmas in a scale family with
$\eta_q\le q^{\chi_E}L^{d_E}$, $\chi_E>0$, and
$00$. Indeed $S_q=(r/\sigma)L+O(\log L)$,
so the intrinsic memory transient is a positive power of $q$ times
fixed logarithms. The other errors have the strict powers already stated.
The exponent $\chi_*$ is independent of an incoming canonical state error:
that error may change the waveform and $C_q$, but is not used in the
memory estimate. Exact coordinate matching by Lemma~\ref{lem:ffr-gauge}
then gives the same order of ancient-state reset at any exact cap in this
window.
A weighted time norm alone does not supply a crossing slope. For a
protected first-cap conclusion, impose the following \emph{separate
pointwise actual-field bounds} on the late window whenever
$3\delta/4\le|\mathcal A(w)|\le5\delta/4$, writing $f=w-W_\kappa$:
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ffr-pointwise-cap}
\left|\int T_{\rm adj} b\cdot\nabla W\right|
+\int|f|\,|b|\,|\nabla T_{\rm adj}|
+\left|\int T_{\rm adj} b\cdot\nabla(W_\kappa-W)\right|
\le\rho_q\delta,\qquad \rho_q\to0.
\end{equation}
These are instantaneous hypotheses, not consequences of
\eqref{eq:ffr-input}. In the actual receiver application they follow,
respectively, from the absolute packet moments and older collar bounds,
the global weighted adjoint lemma, and the weighted smooth heat-profile
estimate with the global radial-growth bound. These pointwise criteria are checked separately in the receiver
application.
\begin{corollary}[Protected actual first cap]\label{cor:ffr-cap}
Assume the preceding scale-family bounds, the nonzero coefficient bound,
\eqref{eq:ffr-pointwise-cap}, and a sufficiently wide prospective
interval. Then for small $q$ there is a unique first crossing
$|\mathcal A(w(t_q))|=\delta$. It lies in the fixed late window and
satisfies
\[
t_q=t_0+S_q+o(1),\qquad
\frac{\dd}{\dd t}|\mathcal A(w)|\ge\sigma\delta/2\quad\hbox{a.e.}
\quad\hbox{for }3\delta/4\le|\mathcal A(w)|\le5\delta/4
\hbox{ in that window}.
\]
The upper slope is $C\delta$ almost everywhere, and its exact-cap state satisfies
\[
\norm{w(t_q)-\mathcal T_{\phi_q}
\Omega_{\rm ref}(u_\delta)}_X
\le C\delta^{M+1}+q^{\chi_*}L^{d_*},
\]
where the canonical coordinate and actual coordinate are matched exactly.
Any continuous family of actual solutions satisfying these uniform bounds
has continuous cap times and phases.
\end{corollary}
\begin{proof}
The all-time density bound and boundedness of $\mathcal A$ give
$|\mathcal A(w)|\le C a(t)$. Choose $L_0$ so large that
$Ce^{-\sigma L_0}/c_*<1/4$. Then no cap occurs for
$t-t_0\le S_q-L_0$. In the fixed late window
\eqref{eq:ffr-state-reset} and the polynomial coordinate yield
$\mathcal A(w)=z(t)+O(\delta^2)+o(\delta)$ uniformly. The moduli at
the window endpoints straddle $\delta$, so continuity gives a crossing.
The adjoint identity proved in Section~\ref{smooth-transfer-section}, with
\eqref{eq:ffr-alltime} and \eqref{eq:ffr-pointwise-cap}, gives
\[
\mathcal A'=\lambda\mathcal A+E_A,
\qquad |E_A|\le C\delta^2+\rho_q\delta
+C\kappa(1+H)\delta.
\]
The last term tends to zero relative to $\delta$.
The coordinate is absolutely continuous. Its modulus derivative exists
almost everywhere and equals
$\sigma|\mathcal A|+\operatorname{Re}(\overline{\mathcal A}E_A)
/|\mathcal A|$. On the stated level interval it is at least
$3\sigma\delta/4-C\delta^2-o(\delta)\ge\sigma\delta/2$.
The upper bound follows from the same identity. Let $C_{\rm speed}$ be
its fixed upper-speed constant. For all sufficiently small $q$, the crossing
lies in the middle half of the late window. Choose
\[
d_{\rm cap}=\min\{L_0/4,\,(8C_{\rm speed})^{-1}\}.
\]
On $[t_q-d_{\rm cap},t_q+d_{\rm cap}]$ the radius stays in the level
band: before a first exit its change is at most
$C_{\rm speed}\delta d_{\rm cap}\le\delta/8$, whereas exit requires
a change of $\delta/4$. The almost-everywhere lower slope integrates on this entire
interval. At earlier times the envelope margin applies or the radius is
below $3\delta/4$; a previous return from a larger radius would require
a downward band crossing. Thus for each fixed $d\in(0,d_{\rm cap}]$
there is the explicit uniform precap margin
\[
\sup_{0\le t\le t_q-d}|\mathcal A(w(t))|
\le\delta-\min\{\delta/4,\,\sigma\delta d/2\}.
\]
A second crossing within the protected window would
require a downward passage through this level interval, contradicted by
the strictly positive slope. The endpoint estimate also gives
$t_q-(t_0+S_q)=o(1)$. Apply the exact-gauge lemma to
\eqref{eq:ffr-state-reset} at this crossing. Finally a uniform early
margin, common crossing slope, and uniform convergence of the continuous
coordinate under solution parameters prove continuity of the first hit;
its nonzero coordinate makes its circle-valued phase continuous.
\end{proof}
The finite density and reset estimates use upper field-history bounds.
The protected first-cap corollary additionally uses a nonzero $C_q$ and
\eqref{eq:ffr-pointwise-cap}.
\section{Transmission to an actual receiver}\label{sec:actual-receiver}
\subsection{An actual receiver and the loss of source memory}
\label{sec:ar-stage}
The receiving step starts from the child preparation envelope and its
phase-matched exact-cap state. The finite expansion is applied to the
actual harmonic coefficients of the coloured Navier--Stokes evolution.
Write $L=\log(1/q)$, $\delta=L^{-4}$, $\alpha=q^K$, where $K>6$,
and fix the smooth reference $W$, its protected coordinate $\mathcal A$,
its growing eigenvalue $\lambda=\sigma+i\tau$, and its canonical ancient
orbit $\Omega_{\rm ref}:=\Omega_{\delta_{\rm ref}}$. The reference amplitude
$\delta_{\rm ref}>0$ is fixed, sufficiently small, independently of $q$.
After one fixed time translation and rotation, normalize the canonical
orbit so $\mathcal A(\Omega_{\delta_{\rm ref}}(0))=\delta_{\rm ref}>0$.
The bilateral transform is multiplied by a nonzero factor by this
normalization; its nonvanishing selection is therefore unchanged.
Choose a fixed $\beta$ in a sufficiently large interval so that
\[
C_*:=\gamma_\epsilon
\int_\R e^{-\mu_\beta u}B_4(\Omega_{\delta_{\rm ref}}(u))\dd u\ne0,
\qquad \mu_\beta=[\sigma+i(\tau-4/5)]/\beta.
\]
All choices below are made before $q$.
\subsubsection{Discounted histories of an arbitrary prepared actual child}
The following conditional history estimate applies to a child prepared
by an incoming packet. It uses its preparation envelope and exact-cap
reset independently of the receiving-stage conclusion.
\begin{lemma}[Prepared-child reference history]
\label{repair:prepared-child-history}
Fix the smooth profile, its all-order canonical reference orbit,
$\beta>1$, logarithmic clock constants and finite spatial derivative
orders. Write
$L=\log(1/q)$, $\delta=L^{-4}$ and
$\mu_\beta=[\sigma+i(\tau-4/5)]/\beta$.
Assume the actual colours belong to the geometric stack of
Lemma~\ref{cont-stack-data}, with the clock and parameter margins of
Corollary~\ref{cor:next-inactive-closed} in child units.
Use child units, with all older constant rotations removed. Let the
actual child $w_c$ have normalized viscosity $\kappa_c\le q^{3/2}$,
an exact cap time $\tau_c$ satisfying
$c_0L\le\tau_c\le C_0L$, and the common geometric initial colour bounds.
Suppose, for fixed finite trial constants
$C_{\rm past},C_{\rm reset}>0$,
\[
\|w_c(t)-e^{\kappa_ct\Delta}W\|_X
\le C_{\rm past}\delta e^{\sigma(t-\tau_c)},
\qquad 0\le t\le\tau_c.
\]
Let $s_q<0$ be the canonical exact $\delta$-cap time, and match the
constant phase $\phi$ exactly in the protected coordinate. Suppose
\[
\|\mathcal T_{-\phi}w_c(\tau_c)-\Omega_{\rm ref}(s_q)\|_X
\le E_q,
\qquad
E_q:=C_{\rm reset}\delta^{M+1}+q^\chi L^D,
\quad \chi>0,
\]
and
\begin{equation}\label{repair:prepared-weighted-reset}
\delta^{-C_W/\sigma-1/\beta}(1+|s_q|)
\bigl[E_q+q(1+|s_q|)\bigr]\longrightarrow0.
\end{equation}
Here $C_W$ is the fixed one-sided comparison constant on the small
canonical ancient segment. The sufficient fixed choice
$M+1>C_W/\sigma+2$ has strict slack in this condition.
Put $t_{\rm ref}=\tau_c-s_q$. On the interval ending at this reference time, assume the actual
inactive-prefix estimates and the geometric preparation localization
hypotheses of Lemma~\ref{lem:cr-actual-reference}, with strict
clock slack. On the following prospective interval assume the
actual parent/larger constant-core and harmonic conclusions on the
provisional parent density stop
$\|w_i-W_{\kappa_i}\|_X\le C_s\delta$, where $C_s>0$ is fixed and
finite. In particular the child's older radial drift in a fixed fraction
of the parent core has coefficient at most
$C(1+C_s)\delta/\beta$. Use the Gaussian parent-radius handoff of
Lemma~\ref{lem:next-source-parent-handoff} at $t_{\rm ref}$.
Let the following child horizon satisfy
\[
0\le U_q\le C_U\beta L.
\]
The complete age and parent-unit horizon are assumed to lie in the
fixed logarithmic windows of the cited inactive/core estimates.
For every such shorter stopped interval the absolute differentiated
main-input history is bounded by one fixed ball independent of the trial
constants, after a later $q$ threshold depending on those constants.
If the complete prospective interval has been reached and $U_q\to\infty$,
define
\[
B_q(u):=
\begin{cases}
B_4(\mathcal T_{-\phi}w_c(t_{\rm ref}+u)),
&-t_{\rm ref}\le u\le U_q,\\
0,&\text{otherwise}.
\end{cases}
\]
Then
\begin{equation}\label{repair:prepared-history-convergence}
\int_{\mathbb R}e^{-\sigma u/\beta}
|B_q(u)-B_4(\Omega_{\rm ref}(u))|\,du\longrightarrow0.
\end{equation}
Consequently its complex discounted transform converges to the full
canonical transform at $\mu_\beta$.
For clarity, $B_q$ is the actual physical history \emph{truncated at the
controlled prospective endpoint and zero-extended thereafter}. The
canonical history in \eqref{repair:prepared-history-convergence} is
defined on the entire real line. No estimate for the genuine actual
infinite-time future after parent density/core control has ended is
asserted or needed.
The quantifiers are as follows. The fixed profile, reference, $\beta$,
clocks and finite spatial orders determine the input ball first. For
each fixed finite triple $(C_{\rm past},C_{\rm reset},C_s)$ satisfying
the stated preparation/reset assumptions, there is a later $q$ threshold.
Within that class every estimate and convergence above is uniform in
depth, source phase and allowed nondistinguished seed homotopies. The
threshold need not be uniform over unbounded trial constants. Thus the
constants may be selected once from the finite-forcing output bounds and
then one common $q$ chosen, without multiplying an inherited input
constant at every descending stage.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Write $L_q=-s_q$. The canonical exact-cap asymptotic gives
\[
L_q=O(\log L),\qquad
e^{-\sigma s_q/\beta}\le C\delta^{-1/\beta}.
\]
All phases below have already been removed by $\mathcal T_{-\phi}$.
Rigid rotations preserve every radial positive-envelope estimate.
\emph{Localization before the reference.}
On the preparation interval the child's own nonradial radial velocity
has time integral at most $CC_{\rm past}\delta$. The descendant
velocity contributes at most $C\beta q C_0L$. The actual older
nonrotational harmonic field and core leaks on a fixed child ball are
smaller, by Corollary~\ref{cor:next-inactive-closed}. For any fixed
trial $C_{\rm past}$ these displacements tend to zero. The initial
support and a fixed radial margin therefore give, at every preparation
time, positive-envelope Gaussian tails outside one fixed ball.
Conditional global origin-growth estimates control every fixed
post-exit moment; their fixed $q$-power amplification is absorbed by
the Gaussian. The exact radial heat base has the corresponding Gaussian
moment tails. These conclusions use the actual positive scalar envelope
and the common drift, not a gradient of the actual child.
On the cap-to-reference segment, Lemma~\ref{lem:cr-actual-reference}
gives the one-sided $X$ comparison with the phase-matched canonical
ancient solution
\begin{equation}\label{repair:prepared-advance-error}
\sup_{0\le v\le L_q}
\|\mathcal T_{-\phi}w_c(\tau_c+v)
-\Omega_{\rm ref}(s_q+v)\|_X
\le C\delta^{-C_W/\sigma}
[E_q+q(1+L_q)].
\end{equation}
Indeed the canonical segment has fixed derivative bounds and fixed
compact support. On that support the descendant field is $O(\beta q)$,
the actual larger nonrotational field tends to zero with a strict
positive $q$ power, and $\kappa_c\le q^{3/2}$.
The comparison forcing is therefore $O(q)$ with fixed parameters.
Gronwall over $L_q$ costs at most $C\delta^{-C_W/\sigma}$.
No derivative of an actual moment coefficient or actual colour occurs.
The canonical nonradial radial displacement on this segment is
$O(\delta_{\rm ref})$; the comparison error contributes $o(1)$ by
\eqref{repair:prepared-weighted-reset}. Choose the fixed reference
amplitude inside the fixed radial margin. Together with the descendant
and older-field contributions, this gives the same fixed-radius
positive-envelope moment reset at the reference. In particular no
factor $\log\log(1/q)$ is introduced into its moment constants.
The separate parent-radius handoff gives the Gaussian exterior-tail
input required by Proposition~\ref{prop:next-actual-postcap-tail};
fixed-radius tightness alone is not used as a substitute for that input.
\emph{The negative history.}
Let $u=t-t_{\rm ref}$. For $u\le s_q$, angular symmetry gives
$B_4(e^{\kappa_ct\Delta}W)=0$. Inside the fixed preparation ball the
whole-moment pairing is bounded by a fixed multiple of the perturbation
$L^1$ norm. Outside it use the preceding Gaussian positive-envelope
and heat tails. Thus
\[
|B_q(u)|\le
C C_{\rm past}\delta e^{\sigma(u-s_q)}+\mathcal G_q(u),
\qquad -t_{\rm ref}\le u\le s_q,
\]
where the Gaussian remainder is superpolynomial on the logarithmic
preparation horizon. Its weighted integral is still superpolynomial:
the earliest negative endpoint has size $O(L)$, so the discount costs
only a fixed power of $q^{-1}$, whereas $\kappa_c\le q^{3/2}$.
The main term has the explicit bound
\[
\int_{-t_{\rm ref}}^{s_q}e^{-\sigma u/\beta}
C C_{\rm past}\delta e^{\sigma(u-s_q)}\,du
\le
\frac{C C_{\rm past}\delta e^{-\sigma s_q/\beta}}
{\sigma(1-1/\beta)}
\le C C_{\rm past}\delta^{1-1/\beta}\longrightarrow0.
\]
The canonical moment on $(-\infty,s_q]$ has the same vanishing
discounted bound, since it is $O(e^{\sigma u})$. Therefore the
weighted absolute difference on the entire pre-small-cap interval tends
to zero. This calculation replaces the selected-source identity
involving $\alpha e^{\sigma t_{\rm ref}}$.
On $[s_q,0]$, the fixed-radius localization converts
\eqref{repair:prepared-advance-error} into a whole fourth-moment
difference with the same bound plus Gaussian errors. Since
\[
\int_{s_q}^0e^{-\sigma u/\beta}\,du
\le C\delta^{-1/\beta}(1+L_q),
\]
its weighted absolute difference tends to zero by
\eqref{repair:prepared-weighted-reset}. The negative canonical
history on this segment has one fixed discounted norm. This proves a
negative-history input bound consisting of a fixed reference majorant,
$CC_{\rm past}\delta^{1-1/\beta}$, and a vanishing reset contribution.
\emph{The controlled future.}
At reference the positive-envelope mass and fourth moment have fixed
majorants. The own and descendant velocities have a fixed bounded sum
by the individual scalar contractions and the convergent geometric
velocity series. The older global radial drift is at most
$C|y|/\beta$; inside the parent probe core its coefficient is
$C(1+C_s)\delta/\beta$, with Gaussian leaks. The parent-radius
handoff supplies its initial exterior Gaussian tail. Keep the local radial coefficient
$a=C(1+C_s)\delta/\beta$ explicit in the proof of
Proposition~\ref{prop:next-actual-postcap-tail}. Its unexited fourth
moment has a prefactor determined only by the initial envelope moments
and fixed source and descendant velocity bound, and a factor $e^{4au}$.
All stop-dependent constants in the exited part are absorbed by its
Gaussian after a later $q$ threshold. The proposition and
Corollary~\ref{cor:next-postcap-scale-margin} thus yield on every
shorter stopped interval
\[
|B_q(u)|\le
C(1+u)^4e^{C(1+C_s)\delta u/\beta}+o(q^P),
\qquad 0\le u\le U_q,
\]
for every fixed $P$. The prefactor is fixed by the reference-envelope
majorants and bounded source and descendant speed. It does not multiply
$C_s$. For each fixed trial $C_s$, a later threshold makes
\[
C(1+C_s)C_U\delta L\le\log2,
\qquad C(1+C_s)\delta<\sigma/2.
\]
Consequently the future absolute discounted input is bounded by a fixed
multiple of
\(\int_0^\infty e^{-\sigma u/\beta}(1+u)^4\,du\), and its tail from
$J$ is bounded by
\[
C_{\beta,\sigma}(1+J)^4e^{-\sigma J/(2\beta)}+o(q^P).
\]
The errors remain negligible under all logarithmic-window and fixed
$q$-power losses. Spatial differentiation of a retained fourth-harmonic
stream field differentiates only its fixed smooth spatial basis, so
the same argument supplies every fixed spatial derivative input norm.
Together with the negative-history estimates, this gives a fixed input
ball independent of the trial constants after their later thresholds.
It is an upper bound only and requires neither a nonzero signed
transform nor completion of a shorter density stop.
Once the complete prospective interval is available, every fixed window
$[0,J]$ lies within it for small $q$. From
\eqref{repair:prepared-advance-error}, the actual reference state
converges to the canonical reference state in $X$. On each such
following window the canonical derivatives are bounded, viscosity
tends to zero, and the actual older nonrotational and descendant
fields on fixed support tend to zero. The same one-sided comparison
therefore gives convergence in $C([0,J];X)$. Positive-envelope radial
localization on this fixed window, followed by conditional moment
growth, gives uniformly vanishing fourth-moment tails outside a
sufficiently large fixed ball. Whole fourth moments consequently
converge on the window. All constants are uniform over the fixed
prepared class.
The canonical positive history has its polynomial discounted tail.
Truncate at $J$, apply fixed-window whole-moment convergence, and then
let $J\to\infty$, using the uniform future tail just established.
Combining this with the two negative-history pieces proves
\eqref{repair:prepared-history-convergence}. The complex transform
conclusion follows because $|e^{-\mu_\beta u}|=e^{-\sigma u/\beta}$.
Every estimate used geometric normalized mass, amplitude or velocity
sums, fixed spatial orders and the common clocks. Its thresholds depend
on the fixed trial constants, not on depth or phase. Selecting those
constants once and then taking the minimum of the finitely many
thresholds yields the stated invariant-class quantifiers. If the force
origin is instead chosen at the actual protected crossing of the fixed
reference level, the same comparison and canonical positive slope
change its time and constant phase only by $o(1)$; this preserves the
history and transform conclusions.
\end{proof}
\begin{proposition}[Actual receiving-stage implication]
\label{prop:ar-stage}
Consider actual colours $w_l$ at scales
$A_l=A_1\beta^{l-1}$, $R_l=R_1q^{l-1}$, in the common unforced
Navier--Stokes velocity. Their initial conditions are the fixed smooth
seeded profiles constructed in Section~\ref{smooth-active-section}, with all seed amplitudes at most
$\alpha$; every colour is real, fourfold symmetric and has zero circulation.
Fix a receiving index $i$ and its immediate child $c=i+1$. Work in receiver
units and remove the common solid rotation of all older cores.
Assume $\kappa_c\le q^{3/2}$ and hence
$\kappa_i=\beta q^2\kappa_c\le\beta q^{7/2}$.
The inductive child hypothesis is as follows. In child units it has an
exact first cap $\tau_c$, with $|\mathcal A(w_c(\tau_c))|=\delta$,
\begin{align}
c_0L\le\tau_c\le C_0L,
\qquad
\norm{w_c(t)-e^{\kappa_ct\Delta}W}_X
&\le C_{\rm past}\delta e^{\sigma(t-\tau_c)}
&&(0\le t\le\tau_c),\label{eq:ar-child-past}\\
\inf_{\phi}\norm{w_c(\tau_c)
-\mathcal T_\phi\Omega_{\delta_{\rm ref}}(s_q)}_X
&\le C_{\rm reset}\delta^{M+1}+q^\chi L^D,\label{eq:ar-child-reset}
\end{align}
where $C_{\rm past},C_{\rm reset}$ are fixed finite trial constants,
and $s_q<0$ is the canonical exact-cap time
$|\mathcal A(\Omega_{\delta_{\rm ref}}(s_q))|=\delta$;
the phase in \eqref{eq:ar-child-reset} is chosen in the same exact
protected-coordinate gauge. Here $\chi>0$ is fixed. Choose the fixed finite order $M$ so that
$M+1>C_W/\sigma+2$, where $C_W$ is the one-sided cap-to-reference
comparison constant. Then \eqref{repair:prepared-weighted-reset}
holds and controls the discounted history through the advance.
The positive scalar envelope transported from $|w_c(0)|$ has at $\tau_c$
uniformly bounded moments of each fixed order and Gaussian tails outside
a fixed ball, as supplied by the preparation localization lemma.
All these constants are uniform in depth and in the allowed seed homotopies.
Choose fixed $C_0,C_2$ with
$C_2>C_0>\max(K/\sigma,6/\sigma)$, then $\beta,D$ sufficiently
large so that $C_0>6\beta/[\sigma(\beta-1)]$,
the unconditional inactive closure holds and
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ar-parameters}
\epsilon_0:=C_2\sigma/\beta0,D'<\infty$. The exponent $\chi'$ depends
only on the fixed stage parameters, and may be chosen independently of
the incoming reset exponent $\chi$. Advancing this cap to the fixed
reference preserves an upper clock bound $C_0L$, for small $q$.
At the cap, and whenever the coordinate lies in
$[3\delta/4,5\delta/4]$ within its protected late window,
\[
\frac{\dd}{\dd t}|\mathcal A(w_i(t))|\ge\sigma\delta/2.
\]
The corresponding upper derivative bound is $C\delta$. The positive
receiver envelope has uniformly bounded fixed moments and Gaussian tails
at the cap. The cap time and phase are continuous under all allowed seed
homotopies. If the child's reference phase is $\phi_c$, then the receiver
cap phase is $\phi_c+\arg C_*+\tau S_q+o(1)$, uniformly, where
$S_q=\sigma^{-1}\log[\delta/(q^6|C_*|)]$.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
Let $C_s\ge1$ be a fixed finite trial density-stop constant and put
\[
T_s:=\inf\{t\ge0:\norm{w_i(t)-W_{\kappa_i}(t)}_X=C_s\delta\},
\qquad\inf\varnothing=+\infty.
\]
For small $q$ the initial density is $O(q^K)0$, to be enlarged below, and define
\[
S_q^*:=\sigma^{-1}\log\frac{\delta}{q^6|C_*|},\qquad
H_+:=t_0+S_q^*+L_0,\qquad \widehat H:=\min(H_+,T_s).
\]
For small $q$, $H_+\le C_2L$. Corollary~\ref{cor:next-inactive-closed}
controls all older colours on $[0,\widehat H]$. The receiver's
nonradial mass is at most $2C_s\delta$ in normalized units, so its
actual constant core follows from Proposition~\ref{prop:cont-outer-core}:
$C_2L\sqrt{C_s\delta}\to0$ and $C_2L\beta q\to0$ for every fixed
trial $C_s$. The associated harmonic and Gaussian-leak estimates hold
on this entire density-stopped interval, including any portion after a
hypothetical coordinate crossing.
\emph{Upper child-history bounds on shorter stops.}
Apply Lemma~\ref{repair:prepared-child-history} with
$U_s=\beta(\widehat H-t_0)\le C_2\beta L$. The parent-radius Gaussian
handoff supplies its initial exterior tail. In child units the own and
descendant velocities have a fixed bounded sum, the global older radial
drift is at most $C|y|/\beta$, and inside a fixed fraction of the parent
core it is at most $C(1+C_s)\delta|y|/\beta$ plus Gaussian leaks.
These bounds persist to $\widehat H$ because they require the density
stop rather than a coordinate-cap restriction. The lemma gives
\[
|B_c(u)|\le C(1+u)^4e^{C(1+C_s)\delta u/\beta}+o(q^P),
\qquad 0\le u\le U_s,
\]
for every fixed $P$, with the prefactor determined by the fixed reference
moments and bounded source and descendant velocities, independently of
$C_s$.
For each fixed trial $C_s$, a later $q$ threshold makes
$C(1+C_s)C_2\delta L\le\log2$ and
$C(1+C_s)\delta<\sigma/2$. Hence the future discounted input is in a
fixed ball independently of the trial constant. The pre-small-cap
contribution is $O(C_{\rm past}\delta^{1-1/\beta})$, and the weighted
reset contribution tends to zero by
\eqref{repair:prepared-weighted-reset}. These upper bounds hold on
every shorter density-stopped interval; no signed-transform lower bound
or completion of the full interval has yet been used.
\emph{All other actual harmonic coefficients.}
In receiver units the inner packet has total mass $O(\beta q^2)$,
$L^p$ norm $O(\beta q^{2/p})$, and global velocity at most $C\beta q$.
Inside the protected receiving core the older/current radial remainder
has bound $C(1+C_s)\delta r^3$ plus Gaussian leakage. Radial moment comparison
and exit at a fixed core radius give, for every fixed $n$,
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ar-packet-moment}
\int |x|^{4n}|\hbox{inner packet}(t,x)|\dd x
\le C_n\beta q^{4n+2}(1+H)^{4n}+o(q^P)
\qquad(0\le t\le H\le\widehat H).
\end{equation}
Indeed its radial moment root is bounded, before exit, by
$Ce^{C_n(1+C_s)\delta t}[q+\beta qt+\sqrt{\kappa_it}]$;
$\kappa_i\le\beta q^{7/2}$ makes the square-root term smaller than
$q$ up to logarithms. At exit the probability is
$e^{-c/(\kappa_iH)}$, and the global radial growth amplifies each fixed
moment by only $e^{C_nH}$, which is absorbed by this Gaussian.
This calculation uses the positive aggregate, not its nonexistent summed
$L^\infty$ bound.
The descendants below the immediate child have mass $O(\beta q^2)$
in child units. The child's preparation envelope traps their positive
aggregate in a fixed child ball up to its reference time; afterwards their
fourth moment is bounded by
\[
C\beta q^2(1+u)^4e^{C(1+C_s)\delta u/\beta}+o(q^P).
\] Thus their fourth moment adds only
\[
O(q^{2-\epsilon_0}L^D)
\]
to the weighted child-reference transform. The factor $q^{-\epsilon_0}$
comes from the finite negative-history endpoint, whose source clock is
at most $C_2L+O(\log L)$; its receiving discount is $\sigma/\beta$.
This argument controls the actual entire descendant packet and does not
assert a separate small-density bound for its colours.
Retain exterior harmonics $4,8,\ldots,4J$ of the inner packet and
interior harmonics $3,7,\ldots,4J-1$ of the older colours. Use their
\emph{actual} time coefficients, and fixed smooth stream cutoffs agreeing
on the derivative collars; call the resulting global field $b_J$.
The leading child fourth harmonic gives the first-order coordinate forcing
\[
\beta q^6\gamma_\epsilon e^{4i(t-t_0)/5}B_c(\beta(t-t_0)).
\]
For each finite $k$, all retained higher inner harmonics have weighted
$C^k$ norm, divided by $q^6$, at most
$C_Jq^{4-\epsilon_0}L^D$ by \eqref{eq:ar-packet-moment}.
The unconditional inactive theorem bounds the actual older harmonics on
these collars by
\[
O(q^{K+2-C_2\lambda_B})
+O(q^{8-C_2(\lambda_P+C_4/\beta)}L^D).
\]
After source recentering, their weighted norm divided by $q^6$ is $o(1)$
by \eqref{eq:ar-parameters}. The own initial seed contributes only
$O(q^{K-6-\epsilon_0}L^D)$ to the first growing coefficient.
All these strict powers are uniform in depth.
For the collar density leak, the inner positive aggregate has Gaussian
$L^1$ tail outside a fixed protected radius and conserved finite $L^p$
norm. Biot--Savart interpolation therefore gives a Gaussian velocity
leak, despite its infinite sum of initial $L^\infty$ amplitudes.
Older leaks have the individual core estimates. The omitted harmonic
remainder is $O(q^{4J+6}L^D)$ for the inner packet, and gains arbitrarily
many $q$-powers for the older Taylor series. Choose $J$ so large that, writing $P=4J+6$,
\[
P>6+\epsilon_0+C_2(C_1-\sigma)_++\chi_1
\]
for a fixed $\chi_1>0$; older omission orders are chosen to meet the
same inequality. This is a relative envelope requirement, not only an
absolute endpoint error bound: the first envelope is
$a(0)=q^6e^{-\sigma t_0}\gtrsim q^{6+\epsilon_0}L^{-D}$,
and a $q^P$ forcing error divided by $a(t)$ amplifies by at most
$e^{(C_1-\sigma)_+C_2L}$. The fixed-profile Kato exponent $C_1$
is selected before $J$.
\emph{The actual nonlinear density bootstrap.}
Set $\varepsilon=q^6$, $s=t-t_0$ and $a(t)=\varepsilon e^{\sigma s}$.
Choose the finite orders first. The main child history and fixed stream
basis determine a fixed derivative input ball. For every fixed triple
$(C_{\rm past},C_{\rm reset},C_s)$ the preceding estimates place the
actual input in this same ball after a later $q$ threshold. Thus for
every spatial derivative order needed in the finite recursion,
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ar-weighted-input}
\int_0^H\varepsilon^{-1}e^{-\sigma(t-t_0)}
\norm{b_J(t)}_{C^k}\dd t\le C_k.
\end{equation}
This bound holds for every $H\le\widehat H$ and follows from
Lemma~\ref{repair:prepared-child-history} for the main harmonic and the
strict power estimates for all other harmonics. Spatial differentiation
acts on the fixed stream basis and leaves the actual time coefficients
undifferentiated.
Apply Lemmas~\ref{lem:ffr-residual} and \ref{lem:ffr-comparison}
to this actual run. In their notation take $\varepsilon=q^6$, $r=6$,
$\theta=\epsilon_0$, $C_H=C_2$ and $\gamma=3$:
$\kappa_i\le\beta q^{7/2}\le q^3$ for small $q$.
For each retained coefficient use the explicit reserve
$r_{j\ell}=k_*+2(M-j)+2(N-\ell)$ and
$R=k_*+2M+2N+3$, with $k_*=4$ for the $X$ conclusion.
The finite stream field has polar sectors at most $4J$; its order-$j$
coefficients therefore have sectors at most $4Jj$.
The seed bound in \eqref{eq:ffr-input} follows from
$q^{K-6}e^{\sigma t_0}\norm\Phi_{H^{r_{10}}}=o(1)$.
The other input bound is exactly \eqref{eq:ar-weighted-input} for this
finite derivative order $R$. Actual harmonics agree on the fixed broad
annulus $\mathcal U$, with omission $m_q\le q^P L^D$; Gaussian density
leaks can be absorbed in that bound. The actual global radial bound is
$|b\cdot e_r|\le C(|x|+\beta q)$, uniformly in depth.
Choose $(M+1)\sigma>C_1$ and a finite $N$ so that
$3(N+1)>C_2(C_1-\sigma)_++\chi_2$.
The harmonic order was chosen to satisfy
$P>6+\epsilon_0+C_2(C_1-\sigma)_++\chi_2$.
These are precisely the relative-error inequalities
\eqref{eq:ffr-powers}. The coefficient recursion including every viscosity
term is \eqref{eq:ffr-recursion}; its exact cancelled residual is
\eqref{eq:ffr-exact-R}, not a pointwise assumed forcing remainder.
The actual foreign field stays in the divergence-free error transport.
Consequently \eqref{eq:ffr-alltime} gives
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ar-comparison}
\norm{w_i-w_{\rm app}}_X
\le Ca(t)^{M+1}+q^{\chi_2}L^D a(t),
\qquad \norm{w_i-W_{\kappa_i}}_X\le C_a a(t).
\end{equation}
No signed growing-coefficient lower bound is used in this application.
The constant $C_a$ is computed in the fixed input ball, before
choosing $C_s$. Enlarge the fixed $L_0$ so that its half-width meets the
early-margin requirement of Corollary~\ref{cor:ffr-cap}, using the
coefficient target lower bound $|C_*|/2$. Then choose
\[
C_s>\max\{1,2C_a e^{\sigma L_0}/|C_*|\}.
\]
Only afterwards decrease $q$ to validate the input estimates and core
margins for this fixed choice, as well as the fixed child preparation
and reset constants. Since
$a(H_+)=\delta e^{\sigma L_0}/|C_*|$, \eqref{eq:ar-comparison} gives
$\norm{w_i-W_{\kappa_i}}_X0$, by the preceding
power estimates. The main-child transform converges to the canonical
value by \eqref{eq:ar-history}; that convergence is only $o(1)$ here,
since the finite ancient-truncation error may be logarithmic. Hence
\[
C_q=e^{i\phi_c}C_*+o(1),\qquad |C_q|\ge |C_*|/2.
\]
\emph{Universal coefficient reset.}
Use Lemma~\ref{lem:ffr-memory} with main field equal to the actual
immediate-child fourth harmonic. Its post-reference $C^R$ norm is
$C(1+s)^4e^{C(1+C_s)\delta s}$, so $h_*=\sigma/2$ is admissible
for the final small $q$.
Every other retained field has weighted remainder norm
$\eta_q\le q^{\chi_3}L^D$ by the preceding strict power estimates.
The pattern rotation is the vector pushforward/scalar rotation of
Section~\ref{sec:ffr}; all angular sectors are rotated separately.
The full coefficient in \eqref{eq:ar-full-Cq} equals
\eqref{eq:ffr-Cq}, with the field zero-extended at $H_+$.
Choose a fixed $00$. Since $a'=\sigma a$, its time
derivative is $\mathrm dR/\mathrm dt=\sigma a[1+O(a)]$. Matching the actual first coordinate therefore selects its
time/amplitude and phase gauges uniquely; the matching error has the
same orders as \eqref{eq:ar-reset}. This step uses the exact cap, rather
than identifying it with the linear preparation time.
Finally, \eqref{eq:ar-density} gives integrated receiver nonradial drift
$O(\delta)$; the younger global velocity gives $O(\beta qH)$, and the
older field is smaller. The positive receiver envelope has Gaussian tails
outside a fixed ball and bounded fixed moments at the cap by the radial
exit lemma and global moment growth. The same uniform preparation and
crossing estimates hold under the stated homotopies. Positive-viscosity
continuous dependence, followed by the strictly positive crossing slope,
proves cap-time and cap-phase continuity. Its own cap clock is
$[6/\sigma+C_0/\beta]L+O(\log L)2$, the smooth profile and a sufficiently small fixed reference
orbit, normalized once by a time shift and rotation so that
$\mathcal A(\Omega_{\rm ref}(0))=\delta_{\rm ref}>0$.
There are choices of $K\in(6,643/100)$, fixed $\beta>1$, $q>0$,
and constants $C_{\rm past},C_{\rm reset},R_0,c_0,C_0,C_2>0$, all
independent of the selected index $N$, such that the following holds.
Put $\alpha=q^K$, $\delta=(\log(1/q))^{-4}$,
$A_j=\beta^{j-1}$, $R_j=q^{j-1}$, and
$\nu_N=q^{3/2}A_NR_N^2$.
For arbitrary seed phases and amplitudes in $[0,\alpha]$, with the $N$th
amplitude exactly $\alpha$, every actual colour $j=N,N-1,\ldots,1$
has a protected first cap. For the selected viscosity,
$\kappa_j=q^{3/2}(\beta q^2)^{N-j}\le q^{3/2}$ for every $j\le N$.
In its normalized older-core rotating frame,
its cap time $\tau_j$ from the physical initial time obeys
\[
c_0\log(1/q)\le\tau_j\le C_0\log(1/q)0,D<\infty$.
The positive envelope is localized uniformly throughout preparation and
at its fixed-reference time. Its fixed moments and fixed-radius Gaussian tails have common bounds;
for $j\ge2$ the separate parent-radius Gaussian tails also have common
bounds.
The first caps have common protection constants at each fixed physical
scale and depend continuously on the seed parameters.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
Choose $K$, for example $K=31/5$. The generic profile constants, including
a one-sided $X$ comparison exponent $C_W$ uniform on a fixed small ancient
segment and the finite residual exponent $C_1$, are fixed first. Fix a
small reference on that segment; the finite expansion orders are selected
below after the clock and amplitude ratios, and before the invariant class
constants. The later advance from the shrinking actual cap to this reference
uses one-sided comparison; it does not require the selected source's
terminal expansion amplitude to exceed the reference amplitude.
Choose fixed clocks $C_0>K/\sigma$ and
$C_2>\max\{C_0,K/\sigma+1\}$ with strict slack. Fix
\[
06+\frac K{\beta-1},\qquad
\epsilon_0:=C_2\sigma/\beta<\min\{K-6,1/2\}.
\]
The unweighted inactive rate is made small by this large amplitude ratio.
After selecting $\beta$ as below, choose the fixed finite inactive weight
$D_{\rm w}$ (distinct from a later logarithmic power $D$) so
that the weighted inactive rate and its remaining geometric rows satisfy
\[
C_2\lambda_B0.
\end{equation}
These are respectively the descendant, higher inner harmonic, two older
harmonic, and own-seed powers in the actual receiving-stage proof.
Gaussian tails are smaller than any prescribed power. Define
\begin{equation}\label{eq:next-explicit-input-error}
\begin{split}
E_{\rm adv}(q;C_{\rm reset}):={}&
C\delta^{-r-1/\beta}(1+\ell_q)
\bigl[C_{\rm reset}\delta^{M+1}+q^\chi L^D
+q(1+\ell_q)\bigr],\\
E_{\rm in}(q;C_{\rm past},C_{\rm reset}):={}&
C C_{\rm past}\delta^{1-1/\beta}
+E_{\rm adv}(q;C_{\rm reset})+Cq^{\eta_{\rm in}}L^{d_{\rm in}}.
\end{split}
\end{equation}
Here $d_{\rm in}<\infty$ is a common logarithmic power for the finitely
many retained spatial derivatives. Lemma~\ref{repair:prepared-child-history},
especially \eqref{repair:prepared-advance-error}, and the strict-power
bounds preceding \eqref{eq:ar-weighted-input} give
\begin{equation}\label{eq:next-invariant-input-quantitative}
M_{\rm input}(H)\le M_{\rm ref}
+E_{\rm in}(q;C_{\rm past},C_{\rm reset}),
\qquad H\le\min(H_+,T_s).
\end{equation}
The constant $M_{\rm ref}$ depends only on the fixed reference/profile,
radius, ratios, clocks and finite derivative orders, not on trial
constants or depth.
Its positive-future majorant is uniform after the later threshold for
the fixed $C_s$ stated above. For each fixed trial class the displayed
error tends to zero: $M+1>r+2$ and $\beta>1$ give
$M+1-r-1/\beta>1$, so even
$\delta^{M+1-r-1/\beta}(1+\ell_q)\to0$; the remaining terms have
positive powers of $\delta$ or $q$ against fixed logarithmic factors.
Once that full prospective interval has been reached, the main signed
transform is uniformly within $o(1)$ of
$e^{i\phi_c}C_*$; fixed-window comparison followed by the two discounted
tails proves this uniformly on the trial class. Thus
$|C_q|\ge |C_*|/2$ once a sufficiently long prospective receiving interval
has been reached. The upper input bound, which is valid on any shorter
stop, is used first to reach that interval.
Select all finite expansion orders before computing the class constants.
Choose $M+1>C_W/\sigma+2$ and $(M+1)\sigma>C_1$;
choose enough actual harmonic terms and viscosity orders that their
generic residual losses are smaller than the entire growing envelope
on $0\le t\le C_2\log(1/q)$. In particular the omitted harmonic power
$P$ satisfies
$P>6+C_2\sigma/\beta+C_2(C_1-\sigma)_++1$ for the receiving stage,
and the analogous selected-source inequality with $a(0)=q^K$.
There are only finitely many required derivatives and sectors.
Compute finite-expansion bounds using the fixed input ball
$M_{\rm input}\le M_{\rm ref}+1$. Choose $C_{\rm past}$ larger than
twice the resulting cap-relative envelope constant, divided by the fixed
lower growing coefficient, and larger than twice the selected-source
past constant. The output past envelope will then improve this same
$C_{\rm past}$ ball when \eqref{eq:next-invariant-input-quantitative}
places the actual forcing in that fixed input ball.
The fixed comparison and coefficient bounds give a finite output
cap-reset constant independent of the incoming reset error: the source
waveform changes $C_q$, which exact-cap time and phase normalization remove;
the universal coefficient reset has only intrinsic positive-$q$-power
transients. Choose $C_{\rm reset}$ larger than twice this output constant
and the selected-source constant. Compute $C_a,L_0$ in the same fixed
input ball and choose once
$C_s>\max\{1,2C_a e^{\sigma L_0}/|C_*|\}$, as in
Corollary~\ref{cor:ffr-upper-continuation}.
Choose a common positive exponent $\chi$ smaller than the intrinsic
base and receiving exponents and take a common finite logarithmic power.
No input reset exponent is successively lost.
For these now fixed constants, choose $q$ so that $E_{\rm in}<1$, the
future exponential is at most two, the receiver density inequality
improves to $C_s\delta/2$, and all core, harmonic, geometric and clock
inequalities are strict. Absorb the finitely many intrinsic
$q^{\chi_0}L^{D_0}$ output bounds into $q^\chi L^D$ by choosing
$0<\chi<\chi_0$ and, if needed, a larger fixed $D$ and a later threshold.
All thresholds are uniform in depth and phase, so their finite minimum
is one choice of $q$ for every selected $N$. This constructs the invariant
class without a depth-dependent parameter diagonal.
\begin{table}[htbp]
\centering\small
\begin{tabular}{>{\raggedright\arraybackslash}p{.25\textwidth}
>{\raggedright\arraybackslash}p{.64\textwidth}}
\hline
Choice, in order & Constraints and dependencies\\\hline
Profile and reference
& Fix $W,\lambda,C_W,C_1$ and a small $\delta_{\rm ref}$ on the
canonical segment.\\
Ratios, clocks and weight
& Fix $K,C_0,C_2,c_0,\beta,D_{\rm w}$, with $C_*\ne0$ and the
strict clock and inactive inequalities above; fix the localization margin.\\
Finite orders
& Fix $M+1>r+2$, $(M+1)\sigma>C_1$, and viscosity/harmonic
orders satisfying \eqref{eq:ffr-powers}; hence fix $R$ and the input ball.\\
Output and trial constants
& Compute output constants in $M_{\rm ref}+1$; choose
$C_{\rm past},C_{\rm reset}$ with factor-two slack, then $L_0,C_s$
and common $\chi,D$ as above.\\
One small $q$
& Require $E_{\rm in}<1$, strict density improvement, all Gaussian/core
and clock margins, and $\beta q^{2/p},\beta q\le1/2$.
Thresholds may depend on the fixed trials, never on depth or phases.\\\hline
\end{tabular}
\caption{The finite constant-selection order for the invariant actual-stage class.}
\label{tab:next-constant-order}
\end{table}
Theorem~\ref{thm:next-selected-source} gives the actual base $j=N$ in
this invariant class. Its normalized cap clock is
$(K/\sigma)\log(1/q)+O(\log\log(1/q))$.
Assume the class holds for $j+1$. Proposition~\ref{prop:ar-stage}, with
the common input ball just established, supplies it for $j$.
The receiving normalized clock from the physical initial time obeys
\[
\tau_j\le\frac{\tau_{j+1}}\beta
+\frac6\sigma\log(1/q)+O(\log\log(1/q)).
\]
The geometric sum and strict clock slack keep it below $C_0\log(1/q)$
after a final decrease of $q$. The receiving growth interval gives a
common positive lower clock $c_0\log(1/q)$.
All core, tail, moment and inactive estimates therefore stay inside their
$C_2$ windows, including the short reference advance. Descending induction
proves the assertions for every finite $N$ with the same constants.
Only finite older prefixes are stopped; all infinite younger packets were
controlled by their convergent mass, $L^p$ and velocity sums.
Finally decrease $q$ so that $\beta q^{2/p}\le1/2$ and $\beta q\le1/2$.
Then the datum series and every required geometric sum converge, and
$\beta q^2<1$ gives the selected viscosities decreasing to zero.
The estimates hold throughout a fixed late interval on both sides of
each prospective cap and give a strict early margin and an integrated
positive radial slope on that late interval.
The quantitative first-cap lemma yields common protection constants.
At the outer physical scale they give fixed common numbers
$e,h,c,L_{\rm obs}>0$ in Lemma~\ref{ph:first-cap}. More explicitly, reduce
the selected-source and receiver protection windows to one common
$d_{\rm cap}>0$ and choose
\[
e:=d_{\rm cap}/2,\qquad c:=\sigma\delta/2,\qquad
h:=\min\{\delta/4,ce\},
\]
using Corollary~\ref{cor:ffr-cap} and
Theorem~\ref{thm:next-selected-source}.
The
upper scalar derivative gives a common Lipschitz bound $L_{\rm obs}$.
Indeed the fourfold origin-growth bound of Lemma~\ref{lem:cont-C4-origin}
and the individual descendant velocity sum give normalized total speed
$C(1+|y|)$, uniformly in depth; the global adjoint test has
bounded $(1+|y|)|\nabla T_{\rm adj}(y)|$ and bounded $\Delta T_{\rm adj}$.
The scalar coordinate identity and the common normalized colour mass
therefore give this same $L_{\rm obs}$ at every active scale.
For the normalized observable at any other fixed physical scale, its
clock is multiplied by $A_j$, so the constants are explicitly
$e_j:=e/A_j$, $h_j:=h$, $c_j:=A_jc$ and
$L_{{\rm obs},j}:=A_jL_{\rm obs}$.
Positive-viscosity continuous dependence and the protected crossing imply
continuous cap times and phases under seed homotopies. All estimates were
uniform in those phases and in all nondistinguished amplitude reductions.
\end{proof}
\begin{proposition}[Surjective outer phase for each selected viscosity]
\label{prop:next-phase-degree}
With the preceding fixed parameters, fix $N\ge2$, all phases except the
$N$th, and put all seed amplitudes equal to $\alpha$.
The map taking $\vartheta_N\in\R/(2\pi\mathbb Z)$ to the unit phase of
the outer colour at its first cap for viscosity $\nu_N$ is continuous
and surjective.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
Multiply every seed except the distinguished $N$th seed by $r\in[0,1]$.
The invariant actual-stage proposition applies throughout this homotopy.
At $r=0$ the initial datum is the radial stack plus just that seed.
Rotational covariance of the unforced equation and its colour equations
shows that changing its phase rotates the entire solution, leaves the cap
time unchanged and rotates the outer cap coordinate once. Thus the outer
phase map has degree one (with an immaterial sign if the opposite rotation
convention is used). Common protected caps give a continuous circle-valued
homotopy as $r$ goes to one. Its degree stays nonzero, and a continuous
circle map of nonzero degree is surjective.
For completeness, a map omitting a point factors through the circle minus
that point, an interval, and is homotopic to a constant; it has degree zero.
This proves the last assertion without a differentiability assumption.
\end{proof}
\subsubsection{Proof of the non-unique-selection theorem}
\begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:main}]
Use the fixed parameters in Proposition~\ref{prop:next-uniform-induction}.
All actual seeds will have the same fixed amplitude $\alpha$.
Set the outer seed phase to zero and provisionally every other phase to
zero. The compact admissible stack lemma gives all required norm,
support and circulation properties for every phase choice.
Choose $T_f>C_2\log(1/q)$ plus the common outer protection window.
Let
\[
a^\nu(t):=\int T_{\rm adj}(x)w_1^\nu(t,x)\dd x
\]
be the bounded smooth adjoint observable of the outer passive colour.
There is no older-core rotation at this outer scale. This is one fixed
bounded $C^2$ test with angular-four covariance, allowed in
\eqref{ph:observable}. Pairing convergence follows from
$|\int T_{\rm adj}(f_n-f)|\le\|T_{\rm adj}\|_\infty\|f_n-f\|_1$.
The scalar identity for this noncompact test is obtained using expanding
cutoffs; its bounded derivatives and the bounded physical velocity make
all cutoff errors tend to zero.
The invariant stage theorem gives cap times in one compact subinterval
of $(0,T_f)$, a common precap margin and common positive radial slope near
the first crossing of radius $\delta$.
The observable is uniformly Lipschitz, since its scalar equation gives
\[
|(a^\nu)'|\le\norm{w_1(0)}_1
[\norm{u^\nu}_\infty\norm{\nabla T_{\rm adj}}_\infty
+\nu\norm{\Delta T_{\rm adj}}_\infty].
\]
The velocity bound is uniform by the fixed-data $L^1,L^p$ contractions
and the kernel split, and $\nu_N\le1$ after choosing $q$ small.
We choose sparse indices $2\le N_10$
from uniform velocity continuity; no actual colour gradient is assumed.
At step $k$ choose a continuity radius $r_k>0$ at that step's assigned
datum, for its selected viscosity and target accuracy $2^{-k}$.
Here is one precise definition of that radius. For a phase vector
$\boldsymbol\theta=(\theta_j)_{j\ge1}$ with $\theta_1=0$, let
$a^\nu[\boldsymbol\theta]$ be the outer observable for the stack
$\omega_0[\boldsymbol\theta]$ defined by \eqref{eq:guide-initial-colours}.
In formulas,
\[
a^\nu[\boldsymbol\theta](t):=
\int T_{\rm adj}(x)
\bigl[\mathsf S_{u^\nu[\boldsymbol\theta]}^\nu(t)
(W+\alpha\Phi_0)\bigr](x)\dd x,
\qquad u^\nu[\boldsymbol\theta]:=K*\omega^\nu[\boldsymbol\theta],
\]
where the total solution on the right has datum
$\omega_0[\boldsymbol\theta]$. Put
\begin{equation}\label{eq:reader-continuity-radius}
\begin{split}
r_k:=\frac12\sup\bigl\{r\in(0,1]:\quad
&\text{for every }\boldsymbol\theta\text{ with }\theta_1=0,\\[-2pt]
&\|\omega_0[\boldsymbol\theta]-\omega_0^{(k)}\|_X0$. Its defining property is monotone
under decreasing $r$, so the half-supremum is positive and has the
displayed property. The explicit geometric bound
$\Delta_{\rm tail}$ from \eqref{eq:guide-phase-tail} permits the choice
\[
\Delta_{\rm tail}(N_{k+1})<\min_{i\le k}r_i.
\]
Require the worst-case norm of every variable phase tail starting at
$N_{k+1}$ to be below $\min_{i\le k}r_i$.
Protected first-cap continuity then gives the stated phase tolerances.
Tolerances may be chosen so the $k$th final cap phase differs from its
target by at most $2^{-k}$.
Every coordinate is changed at most once. Thus the final phases and datum
are explicitly
\[
\vartheta_j^\infty:=\lim_{k\to\infty}\vartheta_j^{(k)},\qquad
\omega_0:=\sum_{j\ge1}A_j
[W(\cdot/R_j)+\alpha\Phi_{\vartheta_j^\infty}(\cdot/R_j)].
\]
The geometric tail bound gives convergence of the assigned data to this
single datum in $X_p$.
No viscosity-dependent initial datum is used. The selected viscosities
$\nu_{N_k}=q^{3/2}(\beta q^2)^{N_k-1}$ tend to zero.
The fixed-data compactness theorem yields subsequences of the even and
odd selected solutions converging strongly in
$C([0,T_f];L^1\cap L^p)$ to Euler solutions $\omega^+$ and $\omega^-$.
Their velocities converge strongly, and the passive-colour theorem
identifies the limits of $w_1^\nu$ as the unique bounded transport colour
with the fixed initial outer density, determined by the total Euler path.
Thus their observables converge uniformly on $[0,T_f]$.
Extract also convergent cap times. Common precap protection and radial
slope ensure each limiting time is the first crossing of radius $\delta$
for its limiting observable: before the common cap window there is a
strict margin, and inside it the integrated radial lower slope excludes
an earlier crossing. The limiting cap coordinates are respectively
$+\delta$ and $-\delta$.
If $\omega^+=\omega^-$, uniqueness of the bounded passive colour in
that total velocity gives the same observable. It would then have the
same first cap time and coordinate, contradicting these two values.
Therefore the total Euler paths differ. The compactness theorem already
gives their strong initial trace and renormalization, completing the proof.
\end{proof}
\clearpage
\begin{thebibliography}{99}
\bibitem{GW01}
T. Gallay and C. E. Wayne,
\emph{Invariant manifolds and the long-time asymptotics of the
Navier--Stokes and vorticity equations on $\mathbb R^2$},
Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. \textbf{163} (2002), 209--258.
\url{https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0102197}.
\bibitem{DL89}
R. J. DiPerna and P.-L. Lions,
\emph{Ordinary differential equations, transport theory and Sobolev spaces},
Invent. Math. \textbf{98} (1989), 511--547.
\url{https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01393835}.
\bibitem{MB02}
A. J. Majda and A. L. Bertozzi,
\emph{Vorticity and Incompressible Flow},
Cambridge Texts in Applied Mathematics, Cambridge University Press, 2002.
\url{https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/vorticity-and-incompressible-flow/393C35E544EDD0711CAA7F7AB05D7432}.
\bibitem{CCS21}
G. Ciampa, G. Crippa and S. Spirito,
\emph{Strong convergence of the vorticity for the 2D Euler equations
in the inviscid limit},
Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. \textbf{240} (2021), 295--326.
\url{https://doi.org/10.1007/s00205-021-01612-z}.
\url{https://arxiv.org/abs/2008.12133}.
\bibitem{CFMS24}
\'A. Castro, D. Faraco, F. Mengual and M. Solera,
\emph{A proof of Vishik's nonuniqueness Theorem for the forced 2D Euler equation},
arXiv:2404.15995 (2024).
\url{https://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15995}.
\bibitem{Mengual23}
F. Mengual,
\emph{Non-uniqueness of admissible solutions for the 2D Euler equation
with $L^p$ vortex data}, arXiv:2304.09578 (2023).
\url{https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09578}.
\bibitem{BCK24}
E. Bru\`e, M. Colombo and A. Kumar,
\emph{Flexibility of Two-Dimensional Euler Flows with Integrable Vorticity},
arXiv:2408.07934 (2024).
\url{https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.07934}.
\bibitem{ACM25}
D. Albritton, M. Colombo and G. Mescolini,
\emph{Vanishing viscosity non-unique solutions to the forced 2D Euler Equations},
arXiv:2507.19257 (2025).
\url{https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.19257}.
\end{thebibliography}
\end{document}